5 ms·
Nuclear plants in the US keep closing
- toomuchtodo 13y agoPossible solutions: * Increased incentives for solar (which serves as a consistent energy source during daylight hours) * Guaranteed rates for base load nuclear generation * A carbon tax on fossil fuel generation, used to subsidize nuclear Across the US, we already pay for reserve capacity, known as "peaker plants". They are paid simply to sit idle all year for those few days when we reach maximum system demand. It would be similar to paying low/zero-carbon base load plants (nuclear) to produce flat out, acknowledging their fixed costs. I cringe at the thought of a substantial number of natural gas turbine plants being built, and the price of natural gas skyrocketing.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoBuilding more solar/wind power means building more gas turbines, because that's the only way to ensure you can meet demand from a solar plant when it's dark out or a wind plant when it's not windy. If we want more nuclear capacity we need to be serious about it. I think LFTR probably deserves a few billions in research, if it pans out it could make nuclear competitive on price and reduce a whole crap-ton of issues normally associated with nuclear.
- MaysonL 13y agoAlthough increased forecasting accuracy for renewables will lessen the need for standby. See "Better Weather Analysis Could Lead to Cheaper Renewables" http://www.technologyreview.com/news/518051/better-weather-analysis-could-lead-to-cheaper-renewables/ http://www.technologyreview.com/news/518051/better-weather-a...
- toomuchtodo 13y agoGoogle invests in a weather forecasting firm (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Climate_Corporation); http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Climate_Corporation); combined with Nest data, Google could lead the utility energy management space.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoIt doesn't require forecasting to predict nightfall every day, that's still a serious problem for solar.
- logfromblammo 13y agoI always thought that it would be a better alternative to peak-demand power plants to have a variable-demand industry connected to the base-load power plant. Rather than firing up the peak-demand plants when load rises, just keep the plant humming along at the same rate and throttle back the cement producer, or biomass gasifier, or fertilizer plant, or aluminum smelter, or paper mill, or desalinator, until the grid load comes back down. Any industry that can singlehandedly soak up all the excess power on additional production would do.
- GregBuchholz 13y agoYes, we'd just need some kind of signal that was proportional to demand. If the demand was high, the signal would also be high, so that consumers would know it was time to cut back on consumption. And likewise, for producers, a high signal would indicate that it was time to bring on extra capacity. Of course, we'd want the signal to be something meaningful that people wouldn't ignore. It would be best if the whole signaling infrastructure was decentralized, so that producers and consumers could act according to their own needs without coordinating through a central authority. It seems like there may be a startup opportunity in there somewhere.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoYou just described how Nest is using their data and how utilities are trying to use Time Of Data metering to signal pricing to consumers (using smart meters). Also, most if not all industrial electricity users have load shedding agreements with utilities; in the event of demand spikes, those industrial users are required to curb their power use within X number of minutes.
- jjoonathan 13y agoThey already do that. There just isn't any industry that can singlehandedly soak up all the excess power (subject to constraints of proximity to power plants, distance from cities, etc). There's a chance electric cars will change this.
- 13y ago
- jseliger 13y agoIncreased incentives for solar (which serves as a consistent energy source during daylight hours) Solar, though, is not a panacea, for a variety of reasons: http://www.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/243plj/the_koch_attack_on_solar_energy_at_long_last_the/ch3mplx http://www.reddit.com/r/politics/comments/243plj/the_koch_at... or http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/elements/2013/09/jcap-solar-fuel-generator-artificial-leaf-liquid-hydrocarbons.html http://www.newyorker.com/online/blogs/elements/2013/09/jcap-... or http://www.forbes.com/sites/christopherhelman/2014/04/24/solar-is-booming-but-will-never-replace-coal/ http://www.forbes.com/sites/christopherhelman/2014/04/24/sol...
- protomyth 13y agoIf you spend a huge amount of time and money demonizing something along with making films about it in disasters and protesting every time an electric company wants to build one, then you get aging plants without replacements. Damn shame that was one of the things that could really help us now. At this point, it will probably be natural gas then what comes next. We have plenty of resources in the US to bridge to the next power source.
- guscost 13y agoMaybe not a horrible situation, but completely unnecessary. It's another part of our present culture which will seem narrow-minded and primitive in retrospect.
- zurn 13y agostaving off catastrophic climate change is the issue, more natural gas doesn't help.
- tvladeck 13y agonatural gas as a replacement for coal-fired power does help, though. it helps a lot.
- whythehellnot 13y agoIn terms of total emissions, no we are doing much worse. Many, many gas wells crack and poisons the land and releases enormous amounts of gases hundreds times worse than CO2. In terms of total pollution, it removes the vast majority toxic waste produced by coal which kills many people. Not to mention the mercury levels in the ocean it's causing. WE really needed advanced technologies like Nuclear Energy in the face of virtually a coal/gas apocalypse. We are now in serious jeopardy without it. Why do you think China's making Nuclear energy such a massive initiative? Even India is doing decent research on them because they're sitting on a pile of thorium. This isn't a problem that we can be gambling with. We only get one good try at this because there will be tens of thousands of years of repercussions. The fact that we're settling with "good enough" on this could mean millions will be displaced & billions of people could starve to death. All because we're being controlled by a greedy gov, greedier lobbyists & a population too stupid to do the right thing.
- angersock 13y agoWell, another awesome legacy of the Baby Boomers and Gen-X. Thanks for all the scaremongering, folks--I'm sure my kids will appreciate your principles when we have to ration their electricity.
- protomyth 13y agoUs Gen-Xers were a little young given the hysteria was all about the 70's. We were the "remember all that free love and stuff? yeah, not for you" generation.
- angersock 13y agoFair enough--then again, there are a lot of folks in my demographic that aren't helping matters either.
- aaronem 13y agoWhat a constructive and helpful addition to the debate.
- angersock 13y agoIt hasn't really been a debate for over three decades--otherwise, rationality (and nuclear power or complete decomissioning) would've prevailed a long time ago.
- dang 13y agoThis comment is an off-topic tangent into pre-fab indignation and thus has a low signal/noise ratio. It doesn't take many comments like this to ruin a thread for substantive discussion. The desired conditions are, unfortunately, fragile. All: please don't post comments like this to HN.
- Zigurd 13y agoThe power plants that are closing would not be allowed to be built now. New plants are safer, and some designs appear to be inherently safe from meltdown. Vermont Yankee leaks. Seabrook might be at risk from earthquake. It's time for new and safer nuke plants.
- chc 13y agoIf we were talking about replacing old nuclear plants, that would be a different conversation. That isn't what's happening. We're largely transitioning from our aging nuclear infrastructure to our older and even less safe methods of power generation.
- neotoy 13y agoThis is good news. Solar will fill the gap.
- chc 13y agoIs there any reason to find this claim more credible than "The Flying Spaghetti Monster will provide all the energy we need"? People have been saying that solar is about to take off for about three decades now. They were wrong at every step of the way. Maybe you're right, but the odds are not in your favor. At this point, I'll believe it when I see it. Until then, nuclear power is actually proven to work and to do so more safely than any comparably effective fuel source, so it's unfortunate to see people saying we should abandon it in favor of a technology that has a demonstrated track record of not being good enough, and thus will just lead us to rely more on fossil fuels.
- Hypx 13y agoSolar power has been growing at an exponential rate for the last several years. The interesting thing about exponential growth is that it isn't actually all that fast in its first stages, and easy to dismiss as meaningless. Once adoption really gets going, solar will become very large very fast.
- mhandley 13y agoBut nothing in the real world really follows an exponential. In reality, what looks exponential is almost always a logistic curve: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logistic_function http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Logistic_function I'm optimistic about solar too, but even if it looks exponential now, this doesn't tell you much about where it will level off. That will no doubt be determined by how cheap the panels become, and how cost effective storage technologies turn out to be.
- whythehellnot 13y agoWe won't get non-trivial energy coverage by photovoltaic panels until they're unfortunately as cost effective as coal/oil. Which is predicted that it won't be until 2030. Most likely the coal industry will exploit their power to hold back said competition with as long as possible. So it could even take to 2050 before coal use will even start to dwindle. Literally the only technology worth our time right now is advanced nuclear fission. Occasionally hydroelectric when they're in the appropriate location. I wish people would realise that solar will only be amazingly useful when we build dyson spheres. But we need Fusion AND Fission to get there.
- afterburner 13y agoEveryone likes to talk about scare-mongers when something like this pops up, which is disappointing and condescending. I oppose nuclear power plans on the basis of their incredible cost, always more than any budget or contingency plan can account for. It's a waste of money that can be put to better use in the renewables field.
- chc 13y agoWhich renewables have proven themselves to be remotely as efficient, practical and cost-effective as nuclear plants? I'm not aware of any unless you live around relatively special geography (e.g. there are places where hydro, geothermal or even wind power are strong contenders, but it doesn't seem like it can be generalized).
- sadris 13y agoNuclear has the lowest cost per kWh of any option on the market given their lifespans.
- castis 13y agodo you have sources for your opposition?
- massysett 13y agoDon't know why you're getting downvotes...nuclear's share has shrunk not due to scare-mongers but due to nuclear's poor cost profile.
- rglovejoy 13y agoThe scare-mongering is the very reason nuclear is so expensive.
- InclinedPlane 13y agoThat's largely a consequence of design, there are other designs which are much cheaper to operate.
- djern 13y agoAn article sponsored by GE that discusses how great nuclear power is? How surprising. Yes Nuclear power doesn't emit greenhouse gasses, but to say it's clean isn't true either. Nuclear waste is particularly nasty, and the politics behind dumping it are concerning.
- yulaow 13y agoI know that you were downvoted for the first sentence, but the second is a serious problem and this is why in my country, with a referendum, we legislated against the use of any form of production of energy through nuclear fission. Maybe it does not seem a problem UNTIL you found that some nuclear waste (and with some I mean A LOT) have been buried illegally and without controls not too far from your house [true story -> http://gizmodo.com/the-mob-is-secretly-dumping-nuclear-waste-across-italy-1513190243 http://gizmodo.com/the-mob-is-secretly-dumping-nuclear-waste...]
- bsder 13y agoThe problem with fossil fuels vs. nuclear is that everybody thinks of fossil fuels as SAFE. They are not. "Nuclear waste is bad--but I'm okay with you guys destroying the Gulf of Mexico." Dumping every ounce of nuclear waste we have at the bottom of the Gulf of Mexico would cause less damage than Deepwater Horizon did. And that's before you start talking about things like coal dust that actually adds MORE radioactivity to the environment than nuclear waste.
- rdtsc 13y agoInterestingly there is a small and lucrative market that specializes in "closing" and "decommission" of nuclear power plants. Just like it takes decades to build and start operating them. It takes very very long to close and decommission them. I knew someone who was in that business, very nice niche market!
- spenrose 13y agoOn a mostly-renewables grid: http://arstechnica.com/science/2012/12/the-grid-of-2030-all-renewable-90-percent-of-the-time/ http://arstechnica.com/science/2012/12/the-grid-of-2030-all-... The culture of budgeting new nuclear plants: http://www.carbontax.org/blogarchives/2013/11/21/why-official-nuke-plant-cost-estimates-are-like-campaign-promises/ http://www.carbontax.org/blogarchives/2013/11/21/why-officia... Nuclear is tied to water in problematic ways: http://www.smartplanet.com/blog/the-energy-futurist/the-energy-water-nexus-2012-edition/ http://www.smartplanet.com/blog/the-energy-futurist/the-ener...
- callmeed 13y agoI live 10 miles from the last operating one in California (Diablo Canyon, just south of San Luis Obispo, run by PG&E). I have several friends and parents of friends who work there. It's the #5 employer in our county behind only the county itself, prisons, and the university. One friend said he expects it to be shut down (or at least announced) by 2020. Maybe this is an uninformed opinion but it will be a bummer if they do. That's a lot of lost jobs for our area (1,700). I've lived here most of my life and no one hear feels unsafe (despite being near fault lines). They spend so much money on this thing, seems crazy to shut it down. (I heard they spent $70M on their SAP installation).