3 ms·
It's an interesting question but I want to make a meta point. I came here to read people's thoughts on the article but the top comment shifts the debate onto a
by andybak 13y ago
It's an interesting question but I want to make a meta point.
I came here to read people's thoughts on the article but the top comment shifts the debate onto a wider topic.
This happens all the time on HN and is something I find slightly irritating if I'm actually interested in the topic itself. It's like that person at a dinner party who always changes the subject onto what THEY want to talk about.
I'm not blaming you - it's the fact that your post is the top one and the one most commented on that derails the original topic - which is a group decision.
Oh well. Democracy in action I suppose.
- rosser 13y agoSo find, upvote, and participate in — or, if necessary, create — a thread that offers the kind of discussion you're hoping to see. Coming into a thread that's not the discussion you wanted, and being all, "But guys! We should be talking about $other_thing!" is an even more annoying dinner party guest, IMO.
- andybak 13y agoYep. I was aware of that as I wrote the post. :) In my defence - the $other_thing is the actual article though. It's also that there are some predictable topics. Every post about a new Google product has someone bringing up the Reader shutdown and every post about ORMs has someone talking about how much they prefer raw SQL...
- calibraxis 13y agoUnfortunately, a problem is that ORMs are goofy: taking a decent model (relational) and mutilating it into a mis-designed one (mainstream OOP). Because of the split between the programming vs. database worlds, where the programmers have the worse solution.
- qudat 13y agoIt's not democracy, the top comment isn't the "only" comment as if the will of the majority chose it and that's all that exists in this thread, effectively suppressing minority influence. You have options to view other comments or start your own discussion if you please. I think your point of contention is that other people, reading this very same article, approve of a comment that did the exact same thing you did: made a point about a "meta"-topic by forking the conversation into some other concept that was assumed when both of you were compelled to comment. Now we have three (your parent, you, and me) off-topic forks of a conversation that is superfluous to the so-called ubiquitous topic of the thread. I see where you are coming from, but I find these "meta"-topics at times more interesting than the topic itself, hence why I'm commenting. Interests are interests, your response is just as much justified IMO as your parent commenter.