3 ms·
Do you think it has legs? That is, do I really want this many commercial recommendations from people I barely know? At what point is the hassle more than the ga
by DanielBMarkham 19y ago
Do you think it has legs? That is, do I really want this many commercial recommendations from people I barely know? At what point is the hassle more than the gain?
I was never a huge FB fan. I guess I just don't get it. Sure I _might_ be interested in whether Sue had the hives last Friday night or not, but hearing about the coolest sports drink from the chick I met two years ago in a bar? It just seems to fall apart after it gets stretched so thin, right?
- amichail 19y agoIt's a bold experiment in human nature. Let's see what happens.
- DanielBMarkham 19y agoPerhaps it's a question of "how much" it succeeds instead of whether it succeeds or not. A young demographic is highly cohesive and peer-pressure-sensitive, whereas an older group with far-flung contacts isn't going to be so keen on the getting pitched so much. It's going to be a learning experience to see how it plays out. Could be a massive home run, from the comments I'm seeing.
- amichail 19y agoI think it has a bit to do with whether you trust algorithms. Would you trust a recommendation made by some obscure collaborative filtering algorithm or one made by a friend whom you know well?
- DanielBMarkham 19y agoSo here's my take: I don't want recommendations for crap I'm not looking to buy from anybody, friends included. In fact, if you want to stay my friend, be careful how much stuff you tell me I should be buying. I'm probably a minority. I know I have a couple of friends that will email from time to time with stuff. Just today a friend emailed talking about a 45-disc James Bond DVD extravaganza. But one or two of those a week is about my limit. If I started getting even one a day from any source, I'd do a double-take. But like I said, I'm not the demographic FB is pushing for. I've always heard kids were supposed to be very anti-commercial once they moved into their 20s. But heck, for all I know we should still be riding around in buggies and chariots. I've just gotten where as soon as I see somebody trying to pitch me, whether it's a google adword, TV commercial, YouTube ad or whatnot, I cringe. It's not a positive experience for me. Why would I want my friends as part of that? I dunno.
- jey 19y agoMaybe you're just not a member of the target audience. The target audience is the set of people who are dying to find out whether Sue had the hives last Friday. There's a whole lot of them; it's just sort of built into human nature to be curious about what's going on in your social circle.