5 ms·
Steve Jobs, a Genius at Pushing Boundaries
- robmay 13y agoMakes you wonder if all that praise for design is really why Apple was successful, or if it was more because he pushed the limits of the law and was successful the way the old robber barons were, like a Rockefeller or Carnegie.
- benihana 13y agoTelecom companies do the same stuff as far as pushing the limits of the law and they are pretty universally reviled. Apple is successful because it provides things to people that they really want and like.
- jeremiep 13y agoI would definitely tend to think its more towards pushing the limits of the law. Didn't he get a salary of $1 a year without any backfire while CEOs of smaller companies tried it and got fined?
- tzakrajs 13y agoDepends on if you are willing to pay the fines to maintain your style.
- cmelbye 13y ago> Didn't he get a salary of $1 a year without any backfire while CEOs of smaller companies tried it and got fined? Yes, yes, no. It's very common and legal. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-dollar_salary http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/One-dollar_salary
- ebbv 13y agoWhile the various trust violations and other assholery bumped up Apple's profits, they hardly provide enough benefit on their own to be responsible for Apple's success. Unless we find out that Steve Jobs went around holding a gun to people's heads to force everyone to buy iPods, iPhones and iPads.
- loceng 13y agoI hope this isn't the only way to govern to be very successful.
- happyscrappy 13y agoThat would be convenient to some world views around HN but the hardware speaks for itself.
- jonathanjaeger 13y agoI'm currently reading "Inside Apple" by Adam Lashinsky and even though I knew Apple was secretive and Jobsian and intense, I never knew the extent of it. If you want to read more about pushing boundaries, read Inside Apple.
- j_s 13y agohttp://amzn.com/B005LH4Y3G http://amzn.com/B005LH4Y3G
- ggreer 13y agoHad Jobs been threatened with jail time, I wonder how much public backlash there would have been. As blind as we may want justice to be, nobody can overlook the fact that the man was responsible for some really nice gadgets. On top of that, the story is hard to get across to the general public: some stock back-dating and ebook price-fixing with no clear sympathetic victim. In light of that, I can see why the DoJ didn't charge him. They would have risked public opinion demonizing the prosecution and favoring Jobs no matter how guilty he was.
- jmzbond 13y agoI agree with you, and at the same time I'm a little saddened by this reality. Yes Job was responsible for some really nice gadgets that changed people's lives, but at some point the benefits are outweighed by the opportunity cost of competition that would have possibly led to even better gadgets. To be clear, I don't think we often get to that "point" today, but it is a risk worth asking ourselves as a public.
- taiki 13y agoBy the time Apple showed up to any particular gadget segment, that gadget segment had existed for years, and sometimes decades before. iPad? Tablets had been kicking around since the 80's. iPhone? iPod? Smart phones and MP3 players had been around since the late 90's. Mac? Apple II? I think you get my point.
- jmzbond 13y agoBut you're making the point I am. Competition is a GOOD thing. Apple showed up in gadget segments and made them better because they weren't terrorized by existing players to keep out. Again I'm not saying that's the point we were at, but I am saying that just because someone/ some company was great, that's no excuse to allow them to try and stop competition.
- smutticus 13y agoDennis Ritchie and John McCarthy died the same month as Jobs. Whenever I see articles about Jobs I always wonder about these two guys and their contributions. Will the NYT write an article about Ritchie or McCarthy? Does the public know anything about them? To me it just says something about American society that we obsess over Jobs yet forget two great men, without whom, Jobs never would have done anything interesting. Is it just because Jobs was rich that we care more? Is it because of his leadership, or place in the public eye? What does it say about our definition of success?
- benihana 13y ago>To me it just says something about American society that we obsess over Jobs yet forget two great men, without whom, Jobs never would have done anything interesting.* I have to disagree with this. You have absolutely no idea or proof what Steve Jobs would have done without Ritchie or McCarthy. Your entire line of reasoning is predicated on unprovable assumption. For all we know, Steve Jobs still would have been successful without Ritchie and McCarthy and that's why he's a more interesting figure. But that scenario is just as impossible to prove as yours.
- dirkgently 13y agoA salesman needs a product to sale. For a product to exist, the foundation has to be in place. The guys who laid the foundation need to be in order for the foundation to be in place. A salesman is just that - a salesman.
- tvon 13y agoWell, sure, if you think of Jobs as nothing but a slick salesman then you just don't have a very high opinion of the guy in the first place.
- 67726e 13y agoThe point is that Steve Jobs, just as the rest of us, was standing on the shoulders of giants. So why then do we obsess over him and not others? Why is he any more important than Dennis Ritchie?
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoBut could he transgress the boundaries?
- jt2190 13y ago> Brian Lam, a technology reporter and founder of The > Wirecutter website, said Mr. Jobs’s seeming indifference > to the law wasn’t unusual in Silicon Valley... "It’s > just a characteristic of young tech entrepreneurs to > look at the rules and question them. "You can’t get > into this game without a healthy distaste for the > status quo." Isn't Elon Musk also trying to push the boundaries of society?
- vincetogo 13y agoSteve Jobs was a white, male billionaire. Of course he wouldn't be in jail.
- phillmv 13y ago>An investigation by Apple’s lawyers cleared Mr. Jobs of wrongdoing, saying he didn’t understand the accounting implications. I'm being hyperbolic but it strikes me as unlikely that Jobs sat down, opened up Quickbooks and just fiddled with it until the numbers made sense. You can't scratch your nose at an organization of that size without involving several layers of accountants and lawyers; did everyone else involved with this also happen to "not understand the accounting implications"? >Mr. Jobs’s conduct is a reminder that the difference between genius and potentially criminal behavior can be a fine line. What a loathsome false dichotomy. What is being described here is not genius but instead sociopathy. There's a rather large line between being able to think coherently about how we interact with technology, and breaking accounting laws so you can make more money. I'm willing to accept that being a huge asshole correlates strongly with your ability to milk every ounce of creativity out of your employees but I see no reason to grant them special courtesy; this ain't no high minded civil disobedience.
- Trufa 13y agoThe quality of the comments in this thread is terrible.
- dang 13y agoIndeed it is. If anyone has suggestions about what we could do about this, beyond not have shallowly provocative articles to begin with, we'd love to hear them.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- seizethecheese 13y agoSorry to suggest something you explicitly didn't ask for, but the problem is definitely the article to begin with. This is in a similar category as troll-bait; obnoxious behavior is guaranteed. An obvious but simple solution: an algorithm that punishes link titles that contain certain names. I propose: - Steve Jobs - Elon Musk - Jack Dorsey - Melissa Mayer - Sheryl Sandberg - Zuckerberg - Etc. In many genres the fetishization of individuals leads to lowest-common-denominator crap like this. Reminds me of "great man" history theories.
- michaelochurch 13y agoAt first, I thought of Steve Jobs as a high-variance person: difficult personality, very high creative output. Since I'm the same way, I always held him in high regard. Unlike most CEOs (low-variance, reliably mediocre types) he had the courage to be different. I really liked the idea of a CEO who had a genuine personality (even a difficult one) over the typical corporate social climber. The more that comes out about Jobs, the more I think of him as not only slimy, but toxic. He seems to have set the template for a thousand talentless hacks who use his success as an excuse to be unethical. Mr. Jobs’s conduct is a reminder that the difference between genius and potentially criminal behavior can be a fine line. This makes no sense. I'm one of those high-amplitude individuals. It comes with great difficulty. Most highly creative people have some kind of (possibly mild) mental illness: bipolar's a common one. That's not an excuse to be unethical, and to break laws for one's own benefit at others' expense. (It's one thing to break rules to make everyone win; the wage-fixing scandal is not a case of that.) That argument (fine line between genius and insanity) might excuse spending a whole weekend building a side project, and falling asleep in the Monday afternoon meeting. It doesn't excuse conspiring to suppress wages and wreck careers.