5 ms·
An interesting counterpoint to this is Julie Ann Horvath, who leveraged Twitter to expose a toxic culture at Github (1) and eventually forced the CEO and his wi
by ilamont 13y ago
An interesting counterpoint to this is Julie Ann Horvath, who leveraged Twitter to expose a toxic culture at Github (1) and eventually forced the CEO and his wife to leave the company (2), and has kept Github and certain employees on the defensive (3).
She may have to deal with legal repercussions because of her actions on Twitter, but I can't help but think that nothing would have changed had she kept silent or quietly hired an employment lawyer after being forced out.
1. http://www.theverge.com/2014/3/19/5526574/github-sexism-scandal-julie-ann-horvath http://www.theverge.com/2014/3/19/5526574/github-sexism-scan...
2. http://recode.net/2014/04/21/julie-ann-horvath-on-github-investigation-how-do-you-sleep-at-night/ http://recode.net/2014/04/21/julie-ann-horvath-on-github-inv...
3. http://www.dailydot.com/business/julie-ann-horvath-names-github-harassment/ http://www.dailydot.com/business/julie-ann-horvath-names-git...
- nailer 13y agoHorvath's professional standing would be greater if she took on GitHub in court, proved they were harassing her on the basis of her gender, and won.
- jacquesm 13y agoWhen you're on the offensive things change considerably.
- jpmattia 13y agoThat would make for a good followup article.
- teacup50 13y agoIt's an interesting counter-point, but I'm not sure it's an example to be lauded; most of her complaints were found to have no basis in fact, and she's likely poisoned any future legal suit she might wish to bring. Additionally, she's incurred significant personal liability in the process. > She may have to deal with legal repercussions because of her actions on Twitter, but I can't help but think that nothing would have changed had she kept silent or quietly hired an employment lawyer after being forced out. I can't help but think the court of public opinion has been used to bludgeon an opponent, not achieve justice. The public absolutely lacks the facts necessary to judge the merits of the accusations, and the objectivity necessary won't be forthcoming through inciting angry internet mobs. This wasn't something as simple as Sterling's overt racism -- and even then, the public's ability to observe and act on his overt racism wasn't possible until it saw the cold light of day through objective and verifiable evidence. The safest and likely most productive way for GitHub to be held to account, if GitHub as an organization needed to be held to account, was by providing a clear, objective statement of the allegations, vetted by her lawyer, and if possible, a tenacious lawsuit and refusal to settle for anything less than a public statement.
- ceejayoz 13y ago> most of her complaints were found to have no basis in fact Enough of them had a basis in fact to get a founder fired.
- teacup50 13y ago> Enough of them had a basis in fact to get a founder fired. Which allegations were true? What did that founder actually do? Did she expose herself to liability through libelous statements? On this, The Court of Public Opinion lacks the standing to rule. Your comment is a case-in-point as to why.
- ceejayoz 13y agoGithub was willing to go on the record at https://github.com/blog/1826-follow-up-to-the-investigation-results https://github.com/blog/1826-follow-up-to-the-investigation-... stating " The investigation found Tom Preston-Werner in his capacity as GitHub’s CEO acted inappropriately, including confrontational conduct, disregard of workplace complaints, insensitivity to the impact of his spouse's presence in the workplace, and failure to enforce an agreement that his spouse should not work in the office."
- teacup50 13y agoThis doesn't appear in conflict with any of my statements above.
- cookiecaper 13y agoWhile I'm not sufficiently informed on the daily operations at GitHub, "basis in fact" has nothing to do with whether a C-level remains employed or not. Companies these days are hypersensitive about their reputations and you'll be considered a liability for a single misconstrued statement despite years of stellar (and most importantly, completely politically sanitary) work. You may even get owned for politically incorrect behavior that occurs in private and completely external to your professional affiliation. Off the top of my head I can cite a handful of such ousters that have occurred in the last month, including but not limited to Brendan Eich and Donald Sterling. We're in a really bad spot right now. The principles that undergird free society are not well regarded anymore. Make a single statement that stirs the ire of the reigning corporate thought police and you're done for, no matter how innocuous it may or may not be. People don't care about the facts, it's all about perception, and if you're perceived as a thought criminal in any of the many varied channels now considered taboo, you're "toxic" to the company. It's as simple as that. Considering this status, perhaps aggression and even subtlety are justified if you're seeking to defend yourself against the types of accusations that would get a toxic label applied to your name.
- noisy_boy 13y agoThe difference is that when she did that, she wasn't getting sued. The point of the article is, when matters have reached the court of law, keep mum and let the lawyer do the talking.
- danielweber 13y agoIf you are interested in not losing court cases, "naming names" is a very very bad idea.
- wpietri 13y agoSure, but it's a tradeoff. The Preston-Werners have made legally threatening noises. Julie Ann Horvath's public comments have made an impressive difference in the court of public opinion, but if she gets sued in the court of actual court, they provide a lot of attack surface to a plaintiff's attorney. I think it's great when people speak up about bad conditions: it's a big way that exploitative and oppressive behavior gets remedied. It seemed like Horvath knew the risks she was running, and I admire her bravery. But I wouldn't want people speaking up to be heedless about the risk they're taking.
- wisty 13y agoIf you want to hurt someone, then tweeting can be effective. So can setting fire to their dog. Neither is likely to help you win a court case though.