4 ms·
Not the OP (and also not taking sides in this), but I consider slavery to be a legal concept. Wikipedia says slavery is "treating people as property that can b
by nostrademons 13y ago
Not the OP (and also not taking sides in this), but I consider slavery to be a legal concept. Wikipedia says slavery is "treating people as property that can be bought and sold" and property is itself a legal concept meaning that you have recourse to the state's monopoly on physical force to enforce your right to use an object. So I would consider slavery to be "using the state's monopoly on physical force to enforce dominion over another person".
There are certainly economic situations that I believe are abusive, like debt slavery, indentured servitude, or your McDonald's example. All systems eventually get gamed, and so even when the state says "I'm going to stay out of this, you're free to make contracts but I will not legitimize your power relationships against other people." But there's still a world of difference between "You are property of this plantation owner, if you escape or disobey him you will be hunted down and returned in chains" and "You lack the economic means to support yourself, but you are free to never go to McDonald's again and take your chances living on the street and scrounging up food from trash cans." (I actually think laws that criminalize homelessness are much closer to slavery than minimum-wage jobs.) Many people died for the right to take the latter option, back when "McDonalds" was "plantations".
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]