4 ms·
A frighteningly good idea.
by pg 19y ago
A frighteningly good idea.
- amichail 19y agoThe general idea behind Facebook is that the only way that you would care about anything (apps, ads, events, etc.) is if your friends tell you about it. Technically, this doesn't make much sense since your friends don't necessarily share your interests. But this isn't a technical achievement. It's a social achievement because it appears to be working.
- DanielBMarkham 19y agoDo you think it has legs? That is, do I really want this many commercial recommendations from people I barely know? At what point is the hassle more than the gain? I was never a huge FB fan. I guess I just don't get it. Sure I _might_ be interested in whether Sue had the hives last Friday night or not, but hearing about the coolest sports drink from the chick I met two years ago in a bar? It just seems to fall apart after it gets stretched so thin, right?
- amichail 19y agoIt's a bold experiment in human nature. Let's see what happens.
- DanielBMarkham 19y agoPerhaps it's a question of "how much" it succeeds instead of whether it succeeds or not. A young demographic is highly cohesive and peer-pressure-sensitive, whereas an older group with far-flung contacts isn't going to be so keen on the getting pitched so much. It's going to be a learning experience to see how it plays out. Could be a massive home run, from the comments I'm seeing.
- amichail 19y agoI think it has a bit to do with whether you trust algorithms. Would you trust a recommendation made by some obscure collaborative filtering algorithm or one made by a friend whom you know well?
- DanielBMarkham 19y agoSo here's my take: I don't want recommendations for crap I'm not looking to buy from anybody, friends included. In fact, if you want to stay my friend, be careful how much stuff you tell me I should be buying. I'm probably a minority. I know I have a couple of friends that will email from time to time with stuff. Just today a friend emailed talking about a 45-disc James Bond DVD extravaganza. But one or two of those a week is about my limit. If I started getting even one a day from any source, I'd do a double-take. But like I said, I'm not the demographic FB is pushing for. I've always heard kids were supposed to be very anti-commercial once they moved into their 20s. But heck, for all I know we should still be riding around in buggies and chariots. I've just gotten where as soon as I see somebody trying to pitch me, whether it's a google adword, TV commercial, YouTube ad or whatnot, I cringe. It's not a positive experience for me. Why would I want my friends as part of that? I dunno.
- jey 19y agoMaybe you're just not a member of the target audience. The target audience is the set of people who are dying to find out whether Sue had the hives last Friday. There's a whole lot of them; it's just sort of built into human nature to be curious about what's going on in your social circle.
- greendestiny 19y agoThings you might list as 'interests' may not overlap particularly well but most people have the same basic needs of transportation, food, entertainment, etc. I can't think of a better way to create a positive correlation with a brand than showing that your friends like it and/or own it. I wouldn't be surprised if recommendations from people you know less well were viewed more positively, familiarity breeding contempt and all that.
- whacked_new 19y agoWhat is frightening, the quality of the idea and that FB came up with it, or that only FB is in a position to pull this off?
- pg 19y agoMore the nature of the idea. It's a smart direction to go in, just as better-quality search results were for Google in 1998.
- whacked_new 19y agoThe nature of the idea, as in how it exploits a well-known psychological phenomenon? Better-quality search results was a technical advancement for Google, but I wouldn't say this is quite of the same nature. No doubt it's a beautiful plan, but unlike the Brin-Page paper, the ideas behind this has been around for a good while. There are plenty of ideas from research that can be similarly incorporated into a stronger advertising machine. For example, variable interval reinforcement is the most effective conditioning paradigm, which would be very useful for advertisers. It's fairly well-known, but not many companies are in a position to employ it.
- whacked_new 19y agoIn all my ignorance, I'm reposting to say that I disagree with the approach as said in the article. If one needs to create a personalized profile for a product, then one needs to friend, or fan, the product profile, it is a less efficient strategy. There are better ways to do this. But anyhow, it's facebook, so they'll probably get it.
- ntoshev 19y agoIndeed. The wealth that Facebook creates is that it enhances social capital, and this move capitalizes on it brilliantly. They are so good in designing features that fit in the way their society works, I wonder what is their systematic approach to do so. Google can test features on small % of their users, Facebook can't do this because it doesn't really show how the feature will scale. Geeks with a design sense are valuable, perhaps geeks with social sense get even more valuable. But I don't believe they just have a group of social geniuses that understand technology there.
- andreyf 19y agoReally? Throw ads based on people's recommendation, sell them based on profile content? It doesn't sound very impressive. Definitely no "wow!" factor for me. What would have a "wow!" factor is if they partnered with media and credit card companies to create a system to model people's beliefs and desires, and use that to sell ads.