4 ms·
Is anyone else horribly sad that this kind of content and discussion is ending up on Google+? I often find myself combing the mailing lists of key projects like
by saurik 13y ago
Is anyone else horribly sad that this kind of content and discussion is ending up on Google+? I often find myself combing the mailing lists of key projects like the Linux kernel to figure out why things happened the way they did, and Google+ comments are not searchable in the same way; and even if they were, I am having a difficult time believing that the content will not just end up gone entirely after another ten or twenty years. I know some people point out that using "modern" communication channels decreased friction, latency, etc. but for some use cases the value of records and centralization is high enough to warrant moving slower or more painfully.
- Igglyboo 13y agoIs anyone else horribly sad that this kind of content and discussion is ending up on the internet instead of written down in books? But seriously mailing lists are pretty archaic, not saying that g+ is great but it's possible to have solid data redundancy and centralization without living in the past.
- mwcampbell 13y agoWhy do you equate discussions on mailing lists with living in the past? Sure, Google+ is newer, but that doesn't make it better. On the contrary, mailing lists are better in at least two ways: they're decentralized, and they don't require proprietary software.
- taeric 13y agoThat said, the level of "discussion" in that thread is kind of sad. No guarantee it would be better elsewhere, but I at least have tools that help me wade through mailing list traffic. Basically, unthreaded messages for something like this is just obnoxious. And is pretty much the reason you move discussions to tables when you are at a public place and don't just sit having everyone try and shout at each other.
- lomnakkus 13y agoIf mailing lists have survived to this day they must be doing something right. (We'll see if G+ survives into 2020, but that's not really my point.)
- Nican 13y agoIt is not only that. I am have took for the other messages that Torvalds has said the mists of "I have no idea what you said, but cool." spam in the comment section.
- frou_dh 13y agoThe exact same happens with John Carmack's tweets. I don't know what's going through peoples' minds that they think these high-end folk are so in need of encouragement that half-hearted messages are worth sending. I imagine the end result is a bit like a performer having their own catchphrases sent to them, in that they're scroll-scroll-scrolled past without exception.