4 ms·
(Karma burning time. Summary: The only way to not swallow the Blue Pill is to make powers that be use trusted execution made by and for the people. Unfortunatel
by stcredzero 13y ago
(Karma burning time. Summary: The only way to not swallow the Blue Pill is to make powers that be use trusted execution made by and for the people. Unfortunately: Not going to happen.)
It’s time for a frank public discussion about how to make personal information privacy not just a series of check boxes but a basic human right, both online and off.
The problem is, is that there is no suitable infrastructure for guaranteeing such a right, and there is no one everyone trusts enough to implement it. To have this in actuality, we really need some sort of trusted execution environment. Unfortunately, this is the same thing as DRM, and we already know how manufacturers and big software companies might collude with the authorities to turn this against us.
In a way, this is a win-win for totalitarianism, big-data style. If the powers that be can implement DRM as they want, they control computing from the substrate-up and we've all swallowed the Blue Pill. However if the public has a vehement reaction against DRM, then the population is effectively inoculated against implementing such tools for themselves so they can hold authorities and website operators to account. Either way, the oligarchs/equity lords/0.01% win.
If you look at the activities of groups like the IRA, resistance has relied on the power of social networks in the oppressed population. Now, online social networks have embedded the structure of people's social networks in big data itself. That is a lot of aggregated power. Power corrupts.
EDIT: After engaging in the discussion below, I'll bend my position a bit. Such infrastructure would be nice (where "nice" = "really the only sane way to do it") but a social and legal framework to set expectations might be the pragmatic thing to go after first.
- wmf 13y agoMaybe you don't need a technical solution. Maybe opt-outs with HIPAA-style fines for noncompliance would work.
- crazy1van 13y agoI feel this will become an exercise in box checking "compliance" just like HIPAA. Sure, your medical records are encrypted on disk (but I have the key in plaintext right next them). Sure, there's an opt-out on our site. Good luck remembering to click the opt-out button in the corner every time you visit.
- stcredzero 13y agoTrusted execution environments enable the kind of automation that addresses these complaints. A government opt-out defaults database would partly address the 2nd objection. (Only partly)
- nitrogen 13y agoAnything with potentially negative consequences should be opt-in, not opt-out.
- gress 13y agoThis is a totally false and a distraction. We don't need a trusted execution environment. We just need rights enshrined in law. Rights do not have to be guaranteed by bulletproof technology in order to be valuable. We might not be able to guarantee that corporations never overstep the bounds we set, but the threat of a lawsuit can be a powerful disincentive.
- stcredzero 13y agoThis is a totally false and a distraction. We don't need a trusted execution environment. We just need rights enshrined in law. From a certain POV, this is correct, and I don't disagree with the general aim. Rights do not have to be guaranteed by bulletproof technology in order to be valuable. Entirely correct. What's of more concern is that we not only have a general public, but an "expert" population of programmers and other technical workers that doesn't make decisions about these things in an informed rational way. This is why I get on the soapbox in support of trusted execution environments and point out how they can be used against the authorities. the threat of a lawsuit can be a powerful disincentive. But I would argue that the "trusting trust" problem encompasses not only privacy and security, but political power as well. When transparency itself is strictly voluntary and comes into competition with the temptation of money and great power, we've seen that such a deterrent loses some of its potency. The threat of a lawsuit also doesn't work as well against certain governments in certain contexts. You may well be right that technology is a distraction, for now. The social and legal framework might be the thing to establish first.
- gress 13y agoSure - some kind of trusted execution environment (which I would argue we don't understand well yet) would be an ideal solution. But... a trusted execution environment would be no use if it wasn't mandated, so it is secondary to having rights enshrined in law. And yes, there is a trust problem. But I think it would be very difficult to operate a massive data collection empire on the scale of Google or Facebook without at least one whistleblower exposing it.
- whythehellnot 13y ago