2 ms·
This is off-topic, so I'll demote it to the bottom in a little while, but since I've spent the last month telling people what isn't appropriate on HN, I want to
by nkurz 13y ago
This is off-topic, so I'll demote it to the bottom in a little while, but since I've spent the last month telling people what isn't appropriate on HN, I want to point out something that is.
Did you drop a negative somewhere, or add an extra? I have trouble following your sentence. My best guess at an interpretation is that you've spent a lot of time telling people "no, this is actually on-topic" and now you want to point out something that truly is off-topic?
If so, why do you feel this is off-topic? Like yesterday's article on parapsychology (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7666575 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7666575), this article offers useful insight into the ways in which the ideals of the "scientific method" differ from the realities of published science. I think a lot of people here find this of interest, and I don't think this particular slope is that slippery.
- dang 13y agoI don't think that sentence is worded wrong, but it's late and I may be missing it. In any case: no! The article was wonderfully on-topic and the thread was excellent. Edit: Oh, I get it now. "This" in "This is off-topic" meant "this meta comment I am currently posting". The article was superb. Sorry for the confusion! I will edit the GP.
- nkurz 13y agoThat makes much more sense, and wasn't an interpretation I'd considered. Thanks!