3 ms·
>It may be that Hitler's obsession with these things actually spared the world from a far more effective Nazi Germany, and thus an even longer and bloodier war.
by trhway 13y ago
>It may be that Hitler's obsession with these things actually spared the world from a far more effective Nazi Germany, and thus an even longer and bloodier war.
are you really sure that a far more effective Nazi Germany would lead to even longer and bloodier war? Lets imagine that Germany won Battle of Britain and occupied it in 1940 (with resulting full control of North Atlantic) and took Moscow in the Fall of 1941 and Stalingrad - summer of 1942 with resulting control over Caucasus and the plains until Mongolia. What war we would be talking about after that? The world would look of course completely different. In some sense having that bloody war we were spared from living in that different world.
- nkoren 13y agoI doubt it. I'm not a historian, but my sense is that absent the death camps and and silly wonder weapons, Germany would have been perhaps 10% or 20% more effective -- not 100% more effective. Stalingrad would probably have wrapped up a bit more quickly -- but Moscow, London, and points beyond would all have become the new Stalingrads. Which would not have been a happier outcome, on the whole. [Edit]: Also, it's not entirely clear who would've been the "bad guys" in this alternate-history. The German death camps were certainly the evilest single element of the war -- but the Allied policy of mass-firebombing civilian population centres was arguably the second evilest element of the war, and the Russians were very nearly as nasty as the Nazis to whomever they occupied. Absent the death camps, the moral clarity of that war would have become significantly muddier -- although Germany would certainly still have been the aggressor.
- trhway 13y agoin big picture, at very coarse grain, we can see that one of the main themes of the 20th century was the battle between totalitarian and democratic states. WWII was a huge piece of it. Totalitarian approach was defeated, though as we clearly see today only specific forms of it were defeated while the approach itself was dealt only temporarily setback and starts to emerge in new shapes today. Btw, obligatory to our discussion http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1034314/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1034314/ . No technical prowess can defeat a society build on principle "Yes, she can" :)