3 ms·
In response to your footnote, this was an interesting quote I read about Germany in WW2 : "Historians have generally thought of the Type XXI—along with other s
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
In response to your footnote, this was an interesting quote I read about Germany in WW2 :
"Historians have generally thought of the Type XXI—along with other systems like the Me 262, V-1 and V-2 rockets, and the Tiger tank—as an example of Wunderwaffen, wonder weapons. Since 1945 many have fixated on the revolutionary
military technologies that the Third Reich developed in the last two years of the war. The cultural impetus behind the concept, as implicitly or explicitly acknowledged by historians in the uneven and largely enthusiastic literature on the subject, was an irrational faith in technology to prevail in operationally or strategically complex and desperate situations. a conviction amounting to a disease, to which many in the Third Reich were prone in the latter years of the Second World War. To the extent that it shaped decision making, faith in the Wunderwaffen
was a special, superficial kind of technological determinism, a confidence in the power of technology to prevail over the country’s strategic, operational, and doctrinal shortcomings"
From this: http://www.usnwc.edu/getattachment/dd165021-2812-40ba-847f-d5b4c3e4ac4e/Innovation-for-Its-Own-Sake--The-Type-XXI-U-boat.aspx http://www.usnwc.edu/getattachment/dd165021-2812-40ba-847f-d...
When I read it, it reasonated with a lot of the narrative I hear in policy circles about China as a military power. The reasoning goes like this; The US as an insurmountable technological edge over China, todays wars are technology heavy, therefore the US has an insurmountable military edge over China.
Personally, I expect that reasoning to prevail until the Chinese are sending people to the Moon and getting them back alive. Such a situation will deny that China is just "re-using old soviet gear" and "they can't mount a complex technological development program" in one stroke (both arguments I hear from the 'paper tiger' camp). Interesting times.