2 ms·
> The worst case scenario for global warming is that it's an extinction-level event and civilization ends. WHAT?? What kind of nonsense have you been reading?
by ars 13y ago
> The worst case scenario for global warming is that it's an extinction-level event and civilization ends.
WHAT?? What kind of nonsense have you been reading?
The worst case is coastal flooding, some people have to move inland, and some plant and animal species go extinct. Perhaps some areas become desert (but people live in incredibly hot areas now, so those places will still be habitable).
Other plants and animals will move into the now vacant environment niches. Yes, it's a loss of a species, and yes, a loss of coastal land.
But civilization ends??
- dannypgh 13y agoWhere's your pessimism? Climate change can no doubt be considered a factor in stoking conflicts over resources. It's quite possible we'll start seeing larger and more dangerous conflicts being fought over water, going into the future. This is true regardless of climate change, but climate change and food shortages aren't going to help. It really only takes one war to escalate too far to bring about a nuclear conflict, which could clearly have significant effects on the viability of civilization.
- justin66 13y ago> The worst case is coastal flooding, some people have to move inland, and some plant and animal species go extinct. Perhaps some areas become desert (but people live in incredibly hot areas now, so those places will still be habitable). The distinction between "best case" and "worst case" is meaningful and I'm not sure you understand it. What you're describing is a credible best case scenario - basically a very gentle extrapolation of what's happening right now into the future - and not the worst case. Something like the clathrate gun effect playing out in one of the very bad ways that's hypothesized (or one of the many other hypothesized killers which we believe we've observed in the fossil records, in the earth's crust, in ice, and so on - there's too much to discuss here), and the subsequent effects of that on our environment and later on our politics as the bottom falls out of everything, represents a worst case. If you just go ahead and decide all those hypothesis are bullshit, well, ok. In that case the notion of a worst case doesn't have a lot of meaning.
- ars 13y agoMaybe I should say worst realistic case? Otherwise things like: Atmospheric expansion from heat could increase the drag on the moon causing it to fall on us, could be considered worst case scenario too. People really really love thinking of all possible things that could go wrong - the more disastrous the better (see: Hollywood; black holes from the super collider; or the atmosphere igniting from nuclear tests). But the earth is rather large, it's rather resilient, it's been through a lot and it's still here and working.
- corin_ 13y agoEven if the fact that the earth has survived until now proved it will keep surviving forever (I'm still alive and kicking but I don't think that means I'll live forever), looking at history shows plenty of species going extinct..