5 ms·
Does anyone know if it would be legal to use something like this if it was sufficiently clear with big signs? I'm thinking movie theaters or coffee shops that
by grecy 13y ago
Does anyone know if it would be legal to use something like this if it was sufficiently clear with big signs?
I'm thinking movie theaters or coffee shops that have huge signs "Your cell phone will not work in there. If you don't agree, don't come in", etc.
- kelnos 13y agoCertainly not without FCC approval, which I'd doubt would be easy to get. The big issue (as described in the article) as that the chance of interfering with a legitimate emergency communications system is fairly high.
- dublinben 13y agoThe FCC does not even allow cell phone jammers at prisons. The Secret Service protecting the President is probably one of the few authorized users of cell phone jammers anywhere in the country.
- zo1 13y agoGuess the "pigs"# are indeed more equal than the rest of us. #And no, I don't mean pigs as in the derogatory term for the police.
- hsod 13y agoAre you arguing that it's wrong for the President's security team to be given special privileges under the law?
- zo1 13y agoNo, I'm saying we're not all equal if such "special privileges" are granted to some special few individuals for one reason or another. Overall, it was a reference to the Animal Farm book. But if you want to know if I think it's wrong for us to have inequality in the form of non-universal applications of morality or "law", then I'll answer with Yes.
- hsod 13y agoInteresting. Is this essentially an anarchic worldview? I can't see how a government could function without privileging certain individuals.
- baddox 13y agoAs long as people recognize that, it's a good start. But I suspect a lot of people would do mental gymnastics to avoid accepting that governments privilege certain individuals.
- ajcarpy2005 13y agoDefinitely not. It would be hard to guarantee that jamming stopped at the perimeter of the property. Maybe interference is allowed under exception for industrial cases where there is no real way to prevent it but it is not acceptable for your given use cases.
- Phlarp 13y agoNo. It is illegal to jam frequencies or spectrums whose use is otherwise governed by the FCC
- DanBC 13y agoIn England (and probably many other countries) Passive (blocking signals using faraday cages) is fine. Active (blocking signals by sending other signals) is very much not fine and will attract legal attention. England is currently changing (or at least thinking of changing) the law to allow prisons to use cell-phone jammers. They can't do it at present.
- fleitz 13y agoYes it would be, however, you don't need clear big signs, you need a small piece of paper authorizing the transmission from the FCC. If you have the right piece of paper you can push 100,000 watts. (Note, if you're pushing 100,000 watts, then you do need a clear big sign outlining the dangers of standing near a 100,000 watt microwave)
- b_emery 13y agoIt's almost certainly not legal to transmit in cellular bands without a license (other than for the intended use). FCC licenses I've seen have a 'do not interfere' clause, so even if you rigged your handset as a jammer it would likely be illegal.
- mikestew 13y agoPutting a sign up is not the equivalent to an FCC license. And if you're going to transmit radio waves, you'll need an FCC license (yes, there are exceptions and I'm vastly simplifying for this specific topic). Good luck with getting the FCC to grant you that license. That's not to say that a movie theater or coffee shop couldn't passively attenuate cell phone signals with metallic paint or other equivalents to a giant Faraday cage. But ensuring that you're not being an ass with your radio transmissions is the FCC's specific task.
- baddox 13y agoIf you could ensure that the interference didn't extend pass your own property, I don't think there should be a problem. That's probably not how the FCC works though.
- drewcrawford 13y agoThis is like trying to exert control over the airspace (e.g. for airplanes) on your property. It is completely unworkable.
- baddox 13y agoI don't see why it's like that at all. Am I not allowed to create a small faraday cage in my garage, and inside that test out a cell phone jamming device? Why does it matter if there's literally no measurable effect on the surrounding property?
- gpcz 13y agoI think that falls in a "it's not illegal if you don't get caught" scenario -- that is, unless you make an incomplete Faraday cage, the FCC would have no real means to catch you doing that. Also, since you wouldn't be jamming anyone else's signals, nobody would report you. You'll find out real quick if you screwed up your Faraday cage design, though.
- drewcrawford 13y ago
- sean-duffy 13y agoAs other people have said, jamming would certainly be illegal because of the potential for interference. However, they could fairly easily implement some kind of passive signal blocking. I know that a few schools, including the one I went to, install aluminium foil in the ceiling for this exact reason.
- sukuriant 13y agoSo school shootings and medical emergencies go unreported?
- freehunter 13y agoDoesn't every school have a landline somewhere in the building?
- sukuriant 13y agoIt does, yes. Actually schools have several of them. What i said was a knee jerk reaction to "actively attempting to make it impossible to use cell phones in a school", because two obvious good use-cases of them are 'school shooting and reporting it instantly'; and 'my teacher just collapsed, help'. But yes, footwork could help fix a medical emergency (run to the nurse / another teacher); and chances are, someone heard a gunshot somewhere or someone can get to a place where they can report the shooting.
- baddox 13y agoLike every school shooting and medical emergency before 20 years ago.
- elwell 13y agoSo that no one can use their cell to call 911 if there is another movie theater shooting? That would be very bad.
- kalleboo 13y agoI'm so glad to live in a country where "movie theater shootings" aren't a reason not to disable mobile phones in an single room.
- darkarmani 13y agoWhy not shield your store instead of blasting more radio waves?