4 ms·
> (The 83 is mandatory in U.S. education and sometimes distributed for free, all American High Schoolers use it, and did so for at least the last 10 years.) It
by jacobolus 17y ago
> (The 83 is mandatory in U.S. education and sometimes distributed for free, all American High Schoolers use it, and did so for at least the last 10 years.)
It's a bit off the subject, but this has always struck me as a terrible scam. For the material it is used for (introductory calculus) and the way it is used, one of these TI calculators hurts student learning and understanding more than it helps, and there is no excuse for schools to force students to purchase a $100 piece of electronics without a damn good reason. That these devices are absurdly overpriced compared to the state of the art (~$100 multipurpose netbooks, for instance), and that the models required are made by a single company with monopolistic coordination with standardized tests and textbooks, only make things worse.
Learning how to use a calculator is perhaps a useful skill, but it's one that can be learned quickly if needed and should not be pervasively required: for most math done for math's sake (that is, as opposed to computations for some engineering problem), students would be better off if teachers instead made problems that could easily be worked with pen and paper.
(Personally, I made it through high school and then up through upper-level undergraduate mathematics, physics, econometrics, etc. courses without ever buying a graphing calculator, so it’s clearly not strictly mandatory for current curricula, but students and parents get the impression that it is essential, and the vast majority of students do buy them, so the effect is about the same.)
- dan_the_welder 17y agoAnd now a cracked OS allows cheating since they have an approved 'test mode" to prevent access to stored files. http://education.ti.com/educationportal/sites/US/homePage/nspire-press-to-test.html http://education.ti.com/educationportal/sites/US/homePage/ns... So blinking the led without any access blocking will be an early task for the subversive TI hacker.
- jacquesm 17y agoCue the next round of profits for TI, after all, now everybody will have to buy a new and more secure model.
- icefox 17y agoCrazy what they have these days. Back when I was in high school (first year they required the 83) our teachers simply required we showed every step. So we could get the answer with a few key presses, but unless we showed how to get the answer we wouldn't get credit. Of course I wrote programs to solve the problems step by step and print out the answer, but I guess the system works because in the process of being clever and writing the programs I of course learned how to solve the problems step by step.
- euroclydon 17y agoI had a nice and crazy little Chinese professor for numbers theory in college. I never knew what he was saying, but he would tell us the questions for the exam the day before. I asked him if I could use my ti-92+ and he said yes, so I just programmed in brute force algorithms, entered in the data, then sat back while the 10MHz processor crunched.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- jcl 17y agoHowever, it looks like that test mode doesn't apply to the model that was cracked.
- duskwuff 17y agoOr, at least, it would if anyone used the Nspire. I've never heard of a school using them - everyone has standardized on the 83 / 84.
- jrockway 17y agoYeah, I never saw the point of the TI-83. The TI-89 is nice, but there is no point in having your CAS running on a handheld device anymore. Might as well give everyone a computer with Mathematica.
- rflrob 17y ago>(Personally, I made it through high school and then up through upper-level undergraduate mathematics, physics, econometrics, etc. courses without ever buying a graphing calculator, so it’s clearly not strictly mandatory for current curricula, but students and parents get the impression that it is essential, and the vast majority of students do buy them, so the effect is about the same.) It's actually much harder to make it through high school math without a calculator than the upper-level stuff. At the end of my senior year in college, I tried to fire up my TI-89, only to discover the batteries had run out, and I had no clue when that happened.
- skolor 17y agoI'm not so sure about this. In high school, I spent the first two years doing everything using a TI-83+ (Algebra II and Pre-Calc). However, when my TI-83 stopped working (and got a TI-89), I stopped using a calculator almost all together. For both years of Calculus, I did all the work by hand, turning to the calculator only at the end when I needed a final result (and usually tried to do that in my head/with pen and paper anyway). I would say the that helped me immensely with understanding not only understanding the material, but being able to work it out faster. I'm now able to roughly estimate (within a decimal point or two) most basic math problems in only slightly longer than it does for most students to do it on a calculator. In fact, I tend to work problems out significantly faster than most students who simply punch everything into a calculator and get the results from there, if only because I understand the problem better from working it out by hand and know better how to approach it. Being able to estimate square roots in my head has been vastly beneficial, and would be a skill well worth knowing.
- charlesju 17y agoI have the exact opposite reaction to graphing calculators. I used them to ace my SAT IIs back in the day simply because I understood all the functions of my calculator than every other non-hacker in the room. I even used to program small BASIC games on it when I was bored in class. There still isn't a good device to program on that is inconspicuous in the classroom.