3 ms·
I have some issues with this ballot proposition, but you take it too far. The "property owners should be free to do as they please" thing is a good slogan, but
by wpietri 13y ago
I have some issues with this ballot proposition, but you take it too far.
The "property owners should be free to do as they please" thing is a good slogan, but it ignores negative externalities. E.g., I shouldn't be able to open up a paper mill or a hog farm in my condo, because the effects of that extend beyond the bounds of my property.
That's why we have zoning, for example. We zone an area residential because many people don't want to live in a commercial zone. Saying, "You can't run a hotel in this neighborhood" is something we already do, so it's not crazy to say, "You also can't use AirBnB to run a hotel-like-thing in this neighborhood."
- arebop 13y agoSegregation by use into residential/commercial/industrial zones is a characteristic of suburban rather than urban planning. An alternative to zoning by use is to zone by intensity or pattern of activity. You can consider externalities such as traffic generation or noise or chemical pollution explicitly rather than assuming that e.g., every manufacturing process generates noxious fumes. The more urban neighborhoods of SF including Pac Heights, Russian Hill, Nob Hill, SOMA, the Mission, the Castro, and Civic Center all include hotels right next to or above or below residential and other, complementary, uses [https://www.google.com/maps/search/san+francisco+hotel/@37.7577,-122.4376,13z/data=!3m1!4b1 https://www.google.com/maps/search/san+francisco+hotel/@37.7...].
- wpietri 13y agoI agree what I said was more simple than the full reality, but even San Francisco has a lot of space that is zoned purely one or the other: http://www.sf-planning.org/index.aspx?page=1569 http://www.sf-planning.org/index.aspx?page=1569 I also agree that some people like living next to hotels, but some don't. And in the case of apartment buildings, it's not so much "next to a hotel" as "in a partial hotel". So I think my broad point, that zoning regulations aren't some sort of pointlessly Orwellian government regulation, and are in fact rooted in reasonable preferences of residents, still stands.