5 ms·
The worst case scenario for global warming is that it's an extinction-level event and civilization ends. The worst case scenario for antibiotic resistance is th
by justin66 13y ago
The worst case scenario for global warming is that it's an extinction-level event and civilization ends. The worst case scenario for antibiotic resistance is that people live with the medical uncertainties our grandparents and great-grandparents lived with.
Assuming everyone understands that, it's an interesting case study in psychology as to why the second one might be scarier than the first one.
- doktrin 13y ago> The worst case scenario for global warming is that it's an extinction-level event and civilization ends. > Assuming everyone understands that, it's an interesting case study in psychology as to why the second one might be scarier than the first one. It doesn't make sense to base decisions on a worst case scenario without taking probability into account.
- alexeisadeski3 13y agoIndeed. I am also not aware of how climate change could lead to human extinction.
- mooreds 13y agoThis book outlines various geopolitical climate change reactions. http://www.amazon.com/Climate-Wars-Fight-Survival-Overheats/dp/1851688145 http://www.amazon.com/Climate-Wars-Fight-Survival-Overheats/... The last scenario talks about, if I recall correctly, the oceans becoming more welcoming to bacteria that produce hydrogen sulfide. Sorry, I don't remember the details, but will update tonight from the book at home if I remember.
- fixermark 13y agoSounds like you're thinking of the Permian-Triassic Extinction Event (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permian%E2%80%93Triassic_extinction_event#Anoxia http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permian%E2%80%93Triassic_extinc...) Thumbnail sketch of the event: something (possibly massive volcanic eruptions near in time to a significant meteorite impact) deoxygenated the water enough to cause a substantial marine life die-off. The death of so much marine life in such a short time encouraged sulfate-reducing bacteria, which would have released significant amounts of hydrogen sulfide into the atmosphere. Hydrogen sulfide would have killed plant (and, therefore, animal) life and weakened the ozone layer, exposing the suriving flora and fauna to further UV radiation. "96% of all marine species[5] and 70% of terrestrial vertebrate species becoming extinct." There is some concern regarding a risk (I have no idea how big the risk is) that anthropogenic global warming could "tip the scales" of the global ecology towards the conditions that allow for a Permian-Triassic-style cascade.
- mooreds 13y agoThat seems to jive with my memory. Thanks!
- danielweber 13y agoWhat is the IPCC's worst-case scenario? I'm sure you can find some individual scientists who want to get in front of a camera tot ell us it's the end of the world, just like you can some individual scientists who say it's all crap. I want to see what's in the IPCC's 99.9th percentile of things going wrong.
- todd3834 13y agoI would bet that most people feel like global warming is a problem for their great grandchildren but antibiotic resistance could actually have a negative effect on themselves.
- musicaldope 13y agoPossibly because antibiotic resistance is seemingly imminent, and global warming is only a threat over a much longer timeframe. I can't say definitively whether this accurately reflects reality, but intuitively it makes sense for people to feel this way.
- PeterisP 13y agoCan you cite about that worst case scenario? All that I've heard of global warming consequences is a metre or two rise in sea level, flooding of the related areas + changes in agriculture (currently fertile areas suffer, but northern countries may even increase fertility) i.e., a major pain, but nothing near extinction or civilization ending. It would happen slowly enough (over a century) and require some migration further inland (or infrastructure megaprojects - we can have cities below sea-level, see Netherlands for example), but in the long term we would have the same quality of life, just for a smaller global population due to agricultural changes. Antibiotic resistance, on the other hand, kills our wellbeing and lifespan by making common medical procedures/surgeries impossible, and does so permanently.
- differentView 13y agoThe worst case scenario for both is extinction.
- vonmoltke 13y ago> The worst case scenario for global warming is that it's an extinction-level event and civilization ends. I don't buy that. Beginning of a new dark age with a breakdown of civilization and loss of advancements? Yes. Extinction-level event? No. > The worst case scenario for antibiotic resistance is that people live with the medical uncertainties our grandparents and great-grandparents lived with. No, actually the worst case is that the antibiotic period breeds superbugs that are both more virulent and harder to kill than those that came before. Antibiotic resistance comes about because of unintentional selective breeding of bacteria. We don't really know what other traits we are unintentionally selecting for. We could potentially be breeding a wordwide pandemic and not realize it. Which could bring about a new dark age with a breakdown of civilization and loss of advancements.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoI don't know how you plan to live in a world where outside its hot enough to melt lead.
- doktrin 13y agoPlease point to a single climate model that predicts air temperatures will rise to 300+ degrees celsius.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoVenus.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- vonmoltke 13y agoWhile Venus' atmosphere is worth study, due to the theory that it underwent some sort of hyperactive climate change a few billion years ago, there are limits to the comparison: - Venus is about 3/4 the distance from the Sun as Earth. - Venus has slow, retrograde rotation that leaves a given portion of the surface exposed to the Sun for 56 Earth days at a time. - Venus has no magnetic field, which causes the loss of water vapor and other light gases due to the solar wind
- ars 13y ago> The worst case scenario for global warming is that it's an extinction-level event and civilization ends. WHAT?? What kind of nonsense have you been reading? The worst case is coastal flooding, some people have to move inland, and some plant and animal species go extinct. Perhaps some areas become desert (but people live in incredibly hot areas now, so those places will still be habitable). Other plants and animals will move into the now vacant environment niches. Yes, it's a loss of a species, and yes, a loss of coastal land. But civilization ends??
- dannypgh 13y agoWhere's your pessimism? Climate change can no doubt be considered a factor in stoking conflicts over resources. It's quite possible we'll start seeing larger and more dangerous conflicts being fought over water, going into the future. This is true regardless of climate change, but climate change and food shortages aren't going to help. It really only takes one war to escalate too far to bring about a nuclear conflict, which could clearly have significant effects on the viability of civilization.
- justin66 13y ago> The worst case is coastal flooding, some people have to move inland, and some plant and animal species go extinct. Perhaps some areas become desert (but people live in incredibly hot areas now, so those places will still be habitable). The distinction between "best case" and "worst case" is meaningful and I'm not sure you understand it. What you're describing is a credible best case scenario - basically a very gentle extrapolation of what's happening right now into the future - and not the worst case. Something like the clathrate gun effect playing out in one of the very bad ways that's hypothesized (or one of the many other hypothesized killers which we believe we've observed in the fossil records, in the earth's crust, in ice, and so on - there's too much to discuss here), and the subsequent effects of that on our environment and later on our politics as the bottom falls out of everything, represents a worst case. If you just go ahead and decide all those hypothesis are bullshit, well, ok. In that case the notion of a worst case doesn't have a lot of meaning.
- ars 13y ago
- Houshalter 13y agoWell human populations have gotten significantly larger, more dense, and we have far more/faster travel. The worst case is a plague that also ends civilization.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 13y agoThis probably won't change your religion, but malaria is worse than global warming [0]. The author is a democrat btw. [0] http://www.ornery.org/essays/warwatch/2014-03-20-1.html http://www.ornery.org/essays/warwatch/2014-03-20-1.html