4 ms·
The general criticism focused on here is "mechanical processes". At first I misread this as a focus on literally mechanical machines that did something. But now
by barrkel 13y ago
The general criticism focused on here is "mechanical processes". At first I misread this as a focus on literally mechanical machines that did something. But now I understand it as demonstration of performing an algorithm used to solve a particular pattern of problem. And the core of the criticism is that knowing the algorithm doesn't mean you understand the algorithm, and could modify it to solve related problems.
However, that criticism doesn't have much power for me, based on how I understand I learn. I like to learn from two ends; one, from above, with an overview of the space, so I know where the next bit fits in. And from below, with concrete examples - yes, mechanical examples - of the individual steps. I infer the deeper structure of what's being taught as more and more variants of the mechanical process are shown.