3 ms·
1) His post made it to the first page of HN. So, either the ranking system for HN is completely broken and a terrible post made it to the first page, or some ot
by greenChillies 13y ago
1) His post made it to the first page of HN. So, either the ranking system for HN is completely broken and a terrible post made it to the first page, or some other people didn't consider it to be a "rant" and did have some idea as to what it was about.
2) Your repeated use of the phrases "bizarre rant" and "non-ranty" makes it clear that your comment is really a character attack. For that reason, it's hard to take your comment seriously.
3) I'll summarize it. The activities that broadly fall under the name of "hellbanning" are not consistent with democratic values. They are in fact antithetical to democratic values. Further, these same values are broadly exhibited by those in the "hacker" community. Further, because of the increasing importance of IT in our society, that is bad for our society at large. He is thus not reading HN any longer. And, finally, he dropped an awesome reference to The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy.
4) His post was removed because someone didn't like it. He was not notified why. There was no transparency in the process. In some circles this is called censorship.
- ColinWright 13y ago> Your repeated use of the phrases "bizarre rant" and "non-ranty" > makes it clear that your comment is really a character attack. > For that reason, it's hard to take your comment seriously. It's a specific comment about the text that was submitted. I have no axe to grind, and it's not intended to be an attack on the character. I've just re-read it. Again. It still seems like a bizarre rant. Quite possibly the person behind it is clear, rational, well-spoken, whatever. My comment is about that text, not about the character. > I'll summarize it. The activities that broadly fall under the > name of "hellbanning" are not consistent with democratic values I offer the suggestion that this is not intended to be a democracy. I've never regarded it as such. PG has specifically said it's an experiment to see if it's possible to have an on-line forum that remains civil. Largely I think the experiment is succeeding. We are guests in the Y-Combinator forum. They set the rules, and we behave as we choose. > He is thus not reading HN any longer. That's his choice. > ... he dropped an awesome reference to The Hitchhiker's Guide > to the Galaxy. Well, a reference I've heard many times before. Perhaps if you haven't heard it before you might think it's awesome. > His post was removed because someone didn't like it. He was not > notified why. There was no transparency in the process. In some > circles this is called censorship. Yup. Of course, if you're around for a long time and pay attention to these things you learn what works, what doesn't, and how the rules play out. People who post things that are non-constructive generally get flagged to deletion, and if not, they will sink without trace anyway. Sometimes they even get removed by moderators. And here's the thing: they're allowed to do that. If you choose to play here, you play by the owner's rules. You don't have to play here, and that's also fine. He's not the first to cry "CENSORSHIP" and storm off, and I have no doubt that he won't be the last. Added in edit ... It looks like it got flagged dead by other HN members. If you look at the comments there[0] you'll see people saying the same things I have, so I suspect it just got flagged to death. Further edit: Now confirmed[1] [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7672853 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7672853 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7675075 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7675075
- greenChillies 13y agoChrist. It pains me to respond to this. But, here it goes. Personally, I 100% agree that you can have your own "playground". It's America. But you're no News outlet. And you're definitely censoring. I mean, if Google News did what you're doing, heads would roll. "PG has specifically said it's an experiment to see if it's possible to have an on-line forum that remains civil." definition - civil: a) of or relating to citizens b) of, relating to, or based on civil law c) of, relating to, or involving the general public, their activities, needs, or ways, or civic affairs as distinguished from special (as military or religious) affairs definition - censor: a) a person who examines books, movies, letters, etc., and removes things that are considered to be offensive, immoral, harmful to society, etc b) an official who examines materials (as publications or films) for objectionable matter Oh, snap! Democracy isn't even a prerequisite! If I can invalidate your argument by double checking definitions, I'm not going to even bother examining your logic. I could go on, but my boss is gonna kill me for spending all afternoon on this.
- ColinWright 13y agoBriefly: Firstly, it's not a news site, it's a link-sharing and discussion site. Secondly, your friend's post wasn't news, so if it were a news site, your friend's post wouldn't belong. Civil: Courteous and polite[0] Your definition of "censor" is right, but in this case it's plausible that the HN readers themselves flagged the item to death.[1] That's not censorship, that's just the way the site works. > If I can invalidate your argument by double checking > definitions, ... You haven't. [0] http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/civil http://www.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/civil [1] Added in edit: Now confirmed by a moderator: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7675075 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7675075