3 ms·
Nope. At least where I see from the simulator. Either it's gone completely -- escape velocity -- or it falls right back down. I think the problem is that orbiti
by DanielBMarkham 17y ago
Nope. At least where I see from the simulator. Either it's gone completely -- escape velocity -- or it falls right back down. I think the problem is that orbiting bodies are continually "falling over the horizon", ie, there is a high degree of speed parallel to the ground underneath them for orbiting to work. (Or a low speed with a small pull of gravity, etc. But always some significant forward motion)
You can do some interesting things with packages that have thrusters on them. If I remember correctly you could have a 300-400km railgun shoot boxcar-sized payloads into orbit with very little additional thrust. It's a helluva cheap way to send mass into space -- once you spend a couple hundred billion for the railgun setup (which is still a good deal, btw)
- pg 17y agoThe arguments about why it wouldn't work to shoot a projectile into orbit sound convincing, so I suspect they're right. But what actually happens as you launch a projectile at a 45% angle with increasing velocities?
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI couldn't find the simulator, but as I recall, from any point on the surface, whatever initial velocity you give a projectile will impact the surface at some time later, if it doesn't achieve escape velocity. A good way to think of it is this way: if you were able to point the cannon tangential to the ground, ie horizontal, and you were to fire the projectile at exactly orbital speed for that elevation, then you would achieve orbit at ground level. If, however, you elevate the cannon at all from horizontal, you create an oblong orbit that intersects the surface at some point (even if the orbit extends thousands of miles up into space) That's because all orbits are elliptical to some degree. No matter what the angle or power, you're just creating an orbit with some degree of stretch that eventually comes back around to where you launched. A 45-degree launch from one place would just be the same as launching at 90-degrees from another place on the globe. BTW, this makes for a nice hobby program to write over the weekend. I ended up adding angle, initial velocity, and projectile thrust. I also added scaling where you could either go very small, like a model rocket launch, or zoom out to include the moon. I was very surprised at the sizes of the earth and moon and the distances between them.