3 ms·
I have played with this question in the past, and never found a better "formula" than a search along the following lines: For each n, find the closest interval
by analog31 13y ago
I have played with this question in the past, and never found a better "formula" than a search along the following lines:
For each n, find the closest interval to a perfect fifth (3/2 ratio), and write down the error in octaves. Graph error as a function of n, and you will see certain values of n with low error. On the same graph, do the 4/3 ratio, and so forth, for a small handful of small-numbered ratios.
Somehow 19 springs to mind as having reasonably consonant intervals, but I don't remember for sure.
12 is the smallest, and is also an auspicious number in ancient cultures.
- malexw 13y agoI built a tool to compare the relationship of different n-note equal temperment tunings a few years ago[1]. The UI is a bit obtuse, but it compares the frequencies of the n-note system with the frequencies of the older just intonation system. In 19 Tone Equal Temperment, the Eb and A are within 1 cent of what they would be in a just intonation tuning, which is pretty cool. I find 22 TET interesting as well. [1] http://www.eng.uwaterloo.ca/~mawillia/music/ http://www.eng.uwaterloo.ca/~mawillia/music/