9 ms·
Circle of fifths and roots of two
- esquivalience 13y agoThis is very interesting indeed. They say music goes hand in hand with maths, but it's never taught that way... and musical theory (at least in the UK) teaches what exists but not the principles behind it.
- fyrabanks 13y agoLots of information out there, but you have to have an idea of what to look for. Sit down with this 63 part series and you'll have a very good understanding of the mathematics and physics behind sound: http://www.soundonsound.com/sos/may99/articles/synthsec.htm http://www.soundonsound.com/sos/may99/articles/synthsec.htm. You'd probably come to a lot of those realizations just working with computer audio software. Tons of papers out there on the maths behind, say, phase-vocoder techniques (same maths behind autotune): http://www.ee.columbia.edu/~dpwe/papers/LaroD99-pvoc.pdf http://www.ee.columbia.edu/~dpwe/papers/LaroD99-pvoc.pdf The average music student is more interested in the music than what's behind it. Not at all a knock on them, just how it is.
- jessaustin 13y agoReally clear explanation! Linked in the comments is a natural sequel, which I wouldn't have understood without reading this first: http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/music_box/2010/04/the_wolf_at_our_heels.single.html http://www.slate.com/articles/arts/music_box/2010/04/the_wol...
- dmlorenzetti 13y agoI once went with a friend to price electric pianos. The models she was looking at sampled traditional pianos to get their notes, and had a switch to toggle between different sampled instruments. She asked why there was such a price difference between models, based on the number of keys (unfortunately I don't remember the numbers anymore, but basically some of the models had shorter keyboards). The response was that, for models with a smaller number of keys, they could just sample one octave of the original instrument, and scale the frequencies electronically. However, once you go beyond a certain range, straight scaling didn't work anymore, so they had to sample the whole range of a traditional piano-- hence more electronics needed in the electric piano.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- colanderman 13y agoI don't buy it. Sampling isn't typically done for an entire octave and then scaled 2× or ½×; that would sound terrible. Rather, usually every 3rd note (or so) is sampled, and the "missing" notes are scaled from those. More likely the reason is that keyboard size is used as a proxy to discriminate between amateurs (who can play most anything they care to on, say, a 61-key keyboard) and professionals (who would look like fools trying to fit certain pieces into 61 keys when they are meant for the full 88).
- baddox 13y agoYou might be surprised at the results you can get these days. There are even "soft pianos" that are almost completely synthesized rather than sampled. They can sound amazing: http://www.truepianos.com/demos.php http://www.truepianos.com/demos.php
- coldtea 13y agoAnalog modelling ("the soft pianos" you mention) don't have much to do with stretching samples for several octaves the OP described.
- tobr 13y agoI don't think any of the models sampled one full octave and then resampled that for the other octaves. When you change the pitch of a recorded piano note through resampling, it's going to sound very artificial if you go beyond a couple of semitones. Typically you spread the samples out so you have 3, 4 or 6 per octave. Also, most electric pianos support transposing the whole keyboard, which means that even when you just have four or five physical octaves, you can play notes lower than or higher than that. So that explanation for the price difference is not very realistic.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoTypically keyboard instruments come in '60 key' (aka 5 octave) as budget models, and 88 key (7+ octaves, piano equivalent) 'pro' models. Budget samplers sometimes sample a single octave and use integral sampling changes to fill in the rest of the octaves. That used to be to save memory (which was expensive) although it is less of an issue now. That said, it had nothing to do with being even tempered or not, it had to do with cost. But as Yamaha and others also point out, the harmonics on every key of a piano are slightly different because the keyboard is constructed with all those hammers and strings, one for each key.
- tunesmith 13y agoThe thing that might not be clear from this article is that if you tune with Pythagorean Tuning, you'll run into cases where an Ab reached from one route is different than an Ab reached from another route. Since instruments like the piano need to have only one Ab in a particular octave, that is why they'll be tuned as equal temperament, or some other method that guarantees only one Ab for a particular octave. Otherwise, you'll run into phenomena where an instrument will sound totally awesome if played in one key, but really awful if they try to play the same tune transposed to a different key. This is also why those with sensitive ears are frustrated by their inability to make a guitar sound in tune for both G major and E major chords.
- kevincennis 13y agoCan confirm the Gmaj/Emaj frustration. It's usually easy to get a decent compromise. But when a guitar is really consonant in E, it sounds like a train wreck in G.
- fhars 13y agoInstruments don't need to have just one Ab, there has been at least one that had more (as well as a rather uncommon B#): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archicembalo http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archicembalo
- mrbrowning 13y agoHaving a guitar be in tune across every key is not strictly impossible [1], but it sure isn't easy. [1] http://www.truetemperament.com/site/index.php?go=2&sgo=3 http://www.truetemperament.com/site/index.php?go=2&sgo=3
- osteele 13y agoI heard an interview with a world-class guitarist (forgot who, but not classical) where he said he bends every (presumably fretted) note; I wonder whether this is to play non-even temperaments from an even-tempered fret spacing.
- 13y ago
- icecreamguy 13y agoI had a music teacher who told us that when one of Pythagoras' disciples pointed out this discrepancy, Pythagoras threatened to kill him if he should ever reveal it to anyone else. Obvoisly hard to verify but a funny story nonethless!
- zb 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hippasus_of_Metapontum http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hippasus_of_Metapontum
- stephencanon 13y agoThe usage of “perfect fifth” to indicate only the just fifth (3:2 ratio) is slightly idiosyncratic (but not unheard of); more commonly in modern usage, “perfect fifth” refers to both the just (3:2) and equal-tempered (2^(7/12)) fifths, or to any other tempered fifth, for that matter (for reasons that aren’t entirely clear—or at least differ depending on who you ask—the unison, fourth, fifth, and octave are collectively called the “perfect” intervals in common parlance, regardless of temperament).
- mtinkerhess 13y agoA little more info for those who are curious: The perfect intervals (unison, 4th, 5th, 8ve) can be modified by being diminished or augmented, which shrinks or expands the interval by one half step. The other intervals (2nd, 3rd, 6th, 7th) can be either diminished, minor, major, or augmented. The major interval is what you'd get if you're measuring the intervals on a major (Ionian) scale; minor is -1 half step, dimished -2, augmented +1. My intuition about which intervals are major / minor and which are diminished comes from the intervals that create the differences between the major and minor scales. The major scale uses all major intervals; natural minor uses minor 3rd, 6th and 7th; Dorian minor has a major 6th, and harmonic minor a major 7th. That still doesn't account for why the 2nd is called major / minor -- you could argue that you use it in Phrygian mode, but then you'd have to acknowledge that you use the diminished 5th in Locrian mode, so why not call that the major / minor 5th? (But almost no music is written in the Locrian mode). Another intuition is that the fourth and fifth are the most consonant intervals (because the ratio of their frequencies is simplest) and so an adjustment of a half step is more of an increase in dissonance than a similar adjustment on another interval. Finally, non-perfect 4th and 5th intervals are simply encountered much less frequently than other intervals (with the exception of the tritone between the 3rth and 7th of a dominant V chord, the characteristic dissonance that sets up the V-I authentic cadence).
- HillOBeans 13y agoNotice also that in major keys, there is only a half-step between the 3rd and the 4th tones, meaning the diminished 4th interval will sound as a major 3rd. The augmented 4th (or diminished 5th - a.k.a tritone) perfectly splits the octave in this tuning system. You can go up or down by an augmented 4th or diminished 5th as many times as you want and only ever be playing the same two note-names.
- leephillips 13y agoArticle 2nd paragraph: "Suppose a string of a certain tension and length produces an A when plucked. If you make the string twice as tight, or keep the same tension and cut the string in half, the string will sound the A an octave higher." This is not even dimensionally correct. The frequency is proportional to the square root of the tension. Later: "The ratio of 3/2 is called a “perfect” fifth to distinguish it from the ratio 1.498." I don't think so. The interval is called a "perfect" fifth to distinguish it from the "diminished" or "augmented" fifth. Nothing to do with tuning.
- stephencanon 13y agoThe usage of “perfect” to mean “just” is uncommon, but not really wrong. It’s somewhat more common in older (19th century), AFAIK.
- brownbat 13y agoExamples of four temperaments using Mozart's Piano Sonata No. 11: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XbGq43Ol0tk http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XbGq43Ol0tk I also found this short essay on Bach and tuning informative: http://historicaltuning.com/Overview.html http://historicaltuning.com/Overview.html
- _nato_ 13y agoWow. I went my entire life thinking with complete error that J.S. Bach's The Well-Tempered Clavier was a musical dossier celebrating modern tuning (of keyboards). I was 100% wrong. Thank-you for sharing that essay!
- osteele 13y agoRelated is that going four steps around the circle of fifths, for a total of five pitch classes, produces the pentatonic scale (e.g. the black keys). This is the longest sequence that doesn't contain any half steps. Continue for a total of seven notes and it's the diatonic scale (e.g. white keys†). This is the longest sequence that doesn't contain consecutive half-steps. Finally, continue for a total of twelve notes, as the article describes; the resulting chromatic scale is either (in just temperament) the longest sequence where every step is at least a half step, or (in even temperament) the longest sequence before the pitch classes repeat. † Annoyingly, the tonic (tonal center) of the diatonic scale is the second note in the sequence of fifths (e.g. C in FCGDAEB). I believe this is so you depart the tonic by a fifth in either direction, since fifths sound so good.
- acjohnson55 13y agoYep. In other words, the common scales are the number of consecutive perfect 5ths to "almost" land back on the first note, with "almost" defined progressively stricter. This exercise could be extended to make longer scales, but the additional notes would be close enough to the first 12 to just sound to human ears more like knockoffs of notes in the first 12 than new notes in their own right. Instead, the standard of modifying the 11 notes after the first in various ways to make instruments sound good in more keys proved to be more worthwhile.
- throwaway13qf85 13y agoIt's tough for someone who's not a professional musician to tell the difference between a just fifth (3:2) and an equal tempered fifth (2^(7/12):1) but it's not impossible. Probably the easiest way is to go to a piano and play a fifth with the base note at middle C. The sound noticeably changes after a couple of seconds. That's because the ratio isn't exactly 3:2 and the frequencies of the pure notes start to get out of alignment (the same phenomenon causes 'beats' when two similar but not exactly equal frequencies are played together). It's even more pronounced when you play a C major chord (C-E-G) because the major third (C-E) isn't exactly 5:4 and the minor third (E-G) isn't exactly 6:5 either.
- theOnliest 13y agoThe equal-tempered major third is 14 cents higher (1 semitone = 100 cents) than a just-tempered third, which is pretty noticeable even for non-trained musician.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoThere is a great book, "Musical Applications of Microprocessors" [1] which has an excellent treatment of this. In my early experiments the floating point accuracy of 8bit micros was poor enough that even tempered scales were pretty hard to do. That said, the article describes the different techniques exceptionally well. [1] http://www.amazon.com/Musical-Applications-Microprocessors-Hayden-microcomputer/dp/0810457539 http://www.amazon.com/Musical-Applications-Microprocessors-H...
- beefman 13y agoSee the xenharmonic wiki for more music math than you can shake a stick at http://xenharmonic.wikispaces.com/Mathematical+Theory http://xenharmonic.wikispaces.com/Mathematical+Theory
- pflanze 13y agoI've calculated the values according to the described circle of fifths and drawn a plot comparing it to equal temperament (x is the pitch steps 1..13, y is the frequency 0..2, the curve at the bottom is the difference, magnified 10 times, the gray line at the bottom is the x axis). Done quick and dirty, i.e. I manually filled in the slots for the 12 pitches. I felt a bit disappointed when I reached the end of the article and was told that this isn't actually what's normally done... http://christianjaeger.ch/scratch/octave/ http://christianjaeger.ch/scratch/octave/ (The code is written in Scheme with some libraries that I haven't published so far.)
- pervycreeper 13y agoCan anyone give a mathematical explanation of how to find n such that equally tempered divisions of the octave into n parts give rise to consonant intervals? I have read that 53 works even better than 12, but I wonder if there are more (infinitely more, I would imagine) exponents, and how this sequence (the next number is the lowest n that is better than the previous one) can be found.
- analog31 13y agoI have played with this question in the past, and never found a better "formula" than a search along the following lines: For each n, find the closest interval to a perfect fifth (3/2 ratio), and write down the error in octaves. Graph error as a function of n, and you will see certain values of n with low error. On the same graph, do the 4/3 ratio, and so forth, for a small handful of small-numbered ratios. Somehow 19 springs to mind as having reasonably consonant intervals, but I don't remember for sure. 12 is the smallest, and is also an auspicious number in ancient cultures.
- malexw 13y agoI built a tool to compare the relationship of different n-note equal temperment tunings a few years ago[1]. The UI is a bit obtuse, but it compares the frequencies of the n-note system with the frequencies of the older just intonation system. In 19 Tone Equal Temperment, the Eb and A are within 1 cent of what they would be in a just intonation tuning, which is pretty cool. I find 22 TET interesting as well. [1] http://www.eng.uwaterloo.ca/~mawillia/music/ http://www.eng.uwaterloo.ca/~mawillia/music/
- ArkyBeagle 13y agoThe "most consonant" is Pythagorean for the simple fractional intervals, so you'd have to weight somehow against that. I'm using "minimum number of beats" as the definition of "consonant".
- sopooneo 13y agoI expect it is obvious, but why is the ratio of 3/2 called a "fifth"? It's not because 3 + 2 = 5 is it?
- joblessjunkie 13y agoIf you walk up the notes of the major scale starting from your reference pitch, the fifth note in the scale will be the one that has the 3/2 pitch ratio.
- salmonellaeater 13y ago"In classical music from Western culture, a fifth is the interval from the first to the last of five consecutive notes in a diatonic scale."[1] CDEFG -> CG is a fifth [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_fifth http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_fifth
- madcaptenor 13y agoThe 3/2 ratio is called a "fifth" and the 5/4 ratio is called a "third". I can't make this stuff up.
- ArkyBeagle 13y agoEqual Temperament is an abstraction - different instruments will have an entire discipline of temperament. One of the more complex suites of temperament regimes are the temperament regimes used on pedal steel. Getting a steel to "do" ET is actually an achievable engineering problem, but players may prefer the sound of something more akin to Just intonation and older guitars may not be able to be in ET. Guitars with all the parts to achieve ET are relatively obscure.
- danelectro 13y agoC, E-flat, and G walk into a bar. The bartender says, "Sorry, but we don't serve minors." So E-flat leaves, and C and G have an open fifth between them. After a few drinks, the fifth is diminished, and G is out flat. F comes in and tries to augment the situation, but is not sharp enough. D comes in and heads for the bathroom, saying, "Excuse me; I'll just be a second." Then A comes in, but the bartender is not convinced that this relative of C is not a minor. Then the bartender notices B-flat hiding at the end of the bar and says, "Get out! You're the seventh minor I've found in this bar tonight." E-flat comes back the next night in a three-piece suit with nicely shined shoes. The bartender says, "You're looking sharp tonight. Come on in, this could be a major development." Sure enough, E-flat soon takes off his suit and everything else, and is au natural. Eventually C sobers up and realizes in horror that he's under a rest. C is brought to trial, found guilty of contributing to the diminution of a minor, and is sentenced to 10 years of D.S. without Coda at an upscale correctional facility.