4 ms·

I don't like word clouds either (and I'm one of the authors!). You'll notice there is no cloud in the actual paper, just in the blog post. Do you have any refe

I don't like word clouds either (and I'm one of the authors!). You'll notice there is no cloud in the actual paper, just in the blog post. Do you have any references about human perception of blue-red versus monochrome gradients? Would be interested to have good recommendations for such cases.

endersshadow 12y ago
I'm not GP, but the problem, in my colorblind opinion, is not the hue of the gradient. The extremes of your gradient are way too close together. Nothing really stands out. At least with blue/red, you can make it one extreme or the other (as opposed to white or black...on a white background). That said, once they got to purple, I'd barely be able to distinguish them, anyway.
hfsktr 12y ago
My first thought when they mentioned it was the optical illusion where the color looks different because of the colors around it[0]. Maybe having distinct colors (red/blue) would help with that. [0] Bad at explaining so an image: http://i.imgur.com/oyWO4IP.jpg http://i.imgur.com/oyWO4IP.jpg
1wheel 12y ago
Robert Simmon has a good intro to color perception for data visualization http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/blogs/elegantfigures/2013/08/05/subtleties-of-color-part-1-of-6/ http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/blogs/elegantfigures/2013/0... . Cynthia Brewer's work is currently the gold standard http://colorbrewer2.org/ http://colorbrewer2.org/ https://canvas.uw.edu/courses/891359/files/25713244/download?wrap=1 https://canvas.uw.edu/courses/891359/files/25713244/download...
pygy_ 12y ago
Hijacking the thread, since you're around: Regarding the last graph, the observed data looks like it matches a log-normal distribution, not a power law... Is this correct? Not sure how to interpret it, though. How did you compute your estimation?
- deaneckles 12y ago
  I think log-normal distributions usually fit this kind of data as well as power laws do. Anyway, such a plot is not the best way to choose between those two models (see http://arxiv.org/abs/0706.1062 http://arxiv.org/abs/0706.1062). We don't actually do any such test in the paper though (or say that it is a power law or log-normal). You might want to check out the paper for more details. https://www.facebook.com/publications/244240069095667/ https://www.facebook.com/publications/244240069095667/

endersshadow 12y ago

I'm not GP, but the problem, in my colorblind opinion, is not the hue of the gradient. The extremes of your gradient are way too close together. Nothing really stands out. At least with blue/red, you can make it one extreme or the other (as opposed to white or black...on a white background). That said, once they got to purple, I'd barely be able to distinguish them, anyway.

hfsktr 12y ago

My first thought when they mentioned it was the optical illusion where the color looks different because of the colors around it[0]. Maybe having distinct colors (red/blue) would help with that. [0] Bad at explaining so an image: http://i.imgur.com/oyWO4IP.jpg http://i.imgur.com/oyWO4IP.jpg

1wheel 12y ago

Robert Simmon has a good intro to color perception for data visualization http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/blogs/elegantfigures/2013/08/05/subtleties-of-color-part-1-of-6/ http://earthobservatory.nasa.gov/blogs/elegantfigures/2013/0... . Cynthia Brewer's work is currently the gold standard http://colorbrewer2.org/ http://colorbrewer2.org/ https://canvas.uw.edu/courses/891359/files/25713244/download?wrap=1 https://canvas.uw.edu/courses/891359/files/25713244/download...

pygy_ 12y ago

Hijacking the thread, since you're around: Regarding the last graph, the observed data looks like it matches a log-normal distribution, not a power law... Is this correct? Not sure how to interpret it, though. How did you compute your estimation?

deaneckles 12y ago
I think log-normal distributions usually fit this kind of data as well as power laws do. Anyway, such a plot is not the best way to choose between those two models (see http://arxiv.org/abs/0706.1062 http://arxiv.org/abs/0706.1062). We don't actually do any such test in the paper though (or say that it is a power law or log-normal). You might want to check out the paper for more details. https://www.facebook.com/publications/244240069095667/ https://www.facebook.com/publications/244240069095667/