3 ms·
Regarding the RFS 1: The Future of Journalism, and specifically the "So what will the content site of the future look like? And how will you make money from it?
by huhtenberg 17y ago
Regarding the RFS 1: The Future of Journalism, and specifically the "So what will the content site of the future look like? And how will you make money from it?" part.
The answer to latter appears to be something along the lines of http://contenture.com http://contenture.com. I.e. pay in one place, reap the benefits in many. The definition of benefits may vary, but this is the most consumer-friendly model that involves explicit paying.
But even if one has a good understanding how it's going to work, it is not clear how to get there. This project is going to be more of a business development and sales effort rather than anything else and so it is unrealistic to expect a random startup with no existing ties into the news industry to succeed.
So while I understand where this RFS comes from, I am not sure if it's realistic. It seems to be a very long shot. Correct me if I'm too pessimistic.
- mofey 17y agoAnother obstacle to worry about is micropayments!
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- pg 17y agoIt's not so much that you're pessimistic as that you're assuming too much about the solution.
- huhtenberg 17y agoWell, I am pessimistic in that I don't think there is a simpler solution :) Assuming the consumer of the content is paying.
- thunk 17y agoBut the solution is simpler, and the consumer's definitely not paying. I mean, everyone's a stringer now, right? Sites run on ads and buy content from stringers through an auction market that takes a cut of each transaction. You are that auction site. Competitive bidding for genres of content; reputation indices to incentivise quality journalism -- most of the details have been worked out already in other contexts. I mean, it's so brain-dead it must've been tried already, right? What am I missing?
- euroclydon 17y agoI see a few things holding it back right now and once they are dealt with, online journalism can move on. 1) The big content providers have much of the established talent sewn up in contracts. 2) There is no single go-to place for content, like there is for music (itunes). 3) The current newspapers and magazines still think of themselves as content distributors rather than content providers. If you are a developer or advertiser, sure you can rig up advert auctions and RSS feeds, but the average user, just wants to read an interesting piece and needs a central place to go look for it. A new paradigm would involve content-makers who are organizations and freelancers. We will always need organizations to front money for expensive journalism, and to provide some journalists who need the security, with a steady paycheck. In the future, if journalists work for someone, it will be a virtual newspaper with no delivery network of their own, and which only exists as a brand.
- thunk 17y agoI think this would actually produce higher quality and better paid journalism than the current system. Since there's no formal approval process required to enter the market, good journalists who were previously stymied by old-style institutional filtration will have their day. And since journalism under this system is essentially free-agency, the possibility of bidding wars for pieces by (forgive me) "rockstar" journalists is highly probable, and provides a powerful incentive to do groundbreaking work. A journalist who's scored a comfy gig under the current system has no such incentive.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- brandnewlow 17y agoHow the heck do you get access to closely guarded sources when you write for "j-auction.com"?
- thunk 17y agoHrm. Well, you don't write for the auction site any more than eBay sellers work for eBay. You're your own brand, and win or lose source-cred on your own merits. And it's called "stringerbell.com" :)
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- qeorge 17y agoI read RFS1 too, and contenture.com is not at all what I got out of it. Honestly I'm confused as to why that RFS led you to such a specific conclusion, not to mention one that doesn't match the RFS (why would contenture need a good writer?). On contenture itself, I just don't think this is a good idea. Its been discussed on HN before, but my basic problem with it is that you'd have the top tier sites (i.e. NY Times) subsidizing the less known sites. No matter how the pot is distributed, you'd have the top tier site sharing revenue with the less known sites. Why would they join in? I've got a lot of other issues with the contenture model, but that's the obvious dealbreaker. Also, micropayments are so boring, I don't understand why they are thought of as a panacea. A more interesting approach is the Hulu model. Try searching for a show Hulu doesn't have, like South Park. They'll still show search results for it, and direct you offsite to watch the episode. As a result, the user learns that Hulu is the place to find online TV shows, regardless of the network. In this manner they've inserted themselves between the product makers and their customers, which is a recipe for $texas. And should they later arrange a syndication deal for South Park they can seamlessly change from offsite links to onsite links. A key point with the Hulu model is that they still control a huge chunk of the best content. As much as possible, they're only "outsourcing" the long tail, low ROI content. Its not a particularly new idea. Google largely operates the same way. Google has become the starting place for the web, even if your destination is offsite. When they find areas where they can replace offsite content with their own they do so (think Gmail, Youtube, and the ill-fated Knol). Blockbuster video does the same thing (owned by Paramount, who makes films), and so does your grocery store (with in-house brands where they see high-margin opportunities).