3 ms·
Starting out with a flawed analogy to placebos makes the whole article hard to swallow. Placebos are complicated, especially for drugs with receptors in the bra
by Zigurd 13y ago
Starting out with a flawed analogy to placebos makes the whole article hard to swallow. Placebos are complicated, especially for drugs with receptors in the brain. Stating that we know placebos "don't work" is outright incorrect. We know the opposite: placebos can produce real results, and there are physical mechanisms that explain those results. Nothing paranormal about it.
If the conclusion is that there is no magic wand in methodology that makes an experiment "good" - that's true. But the approach gets off to a rough start.
- pdonis 13y agoI don't think the analogy with placebos is flawed; it's just not quite the analogy you are describing here. The point is not that placebos "don't work"; it's that, if a placebo works as well as some drug, the drug itself doesn't work. That is, it adds nothing to what you can already get using the placebo effect. Which may indeed be a "real" result; but why pay extra for a drug to get it when you don't need to? Note, btw, that while placebos can indeed produce real results, and there are indeed physical mechanisms that explain those results, those mechanisms have nothing to do with what's in the placebo itself; they are entirely to do with what goes on in the mind and body of the person taking the placebo. In that sense, it's true that placebos "don't work": it doesn't matter what specific substance you put in the placebo pill--sugar, starch, gelatin, whatever--as long as it looks and tastes the same to the subject.