It seems many people think any kind of QoS means we no longer have a completely dumb pipe and ergo we have now lost network neutrality. I agree with you that t

It seems many people think any kind of QoS means we no longer have a completely dumb pipe and ergo we have now lost network neutrality. I agree with you that the ISP should not care about who is on the other end of my connection. VoIP packets for Skype or for Vonage or for my ISP's phone service should all get the VoIP bit set and all be treated the same. These are more complicated rules than the water company has, but the Internet is more complicated that the water company. Water usage in a household doesn't double every N years.