7 ms·
“You mentioned making the service better for our customers; but the American citizens aren’t our customers—about 400 junk mailers are our customers. Your servi
by pessimizer 13y ago
“You mentioned making the service better for our customers; but the American citizens aren’t our customers—about 400 junk mailers are our customers. Your service hurts our ability to serve those customers.”
The article blows right past this like it's insignificant. Junk mailers sort their own mail, drop ship it to the local BMC, and pay the post office for the privilege. This subsidizes the regular mail. If you can get rid of junk mail with a mouse click, it's not worth it.
The post office getting upset about ways to prevent junk mail from being delivered is just like a website complaining about Adblock.
- untog 13y agoThe post office getting upset about ways to prevent junk mail from being delivered is just like a website complaining about Adblock. Yeah, they're both the paid subsidies that allow you to use a service for the price you currently do.
- fps 13y agoExcept I can choose to not visit an ad supported website, yet I cannot stop getting postal mail. I get literally zero benefit from postal mail deliveries (it's all, 100%, junk) and am forced to pay serious money every month to drop off ~30lbs of postal mail at my town's recycling center. Whatever service they claim to provide would be better done by UPS and FedEx for a lower overall cost to the recipient. Let the junk mailers all go out of business.
- devicenull 13y agoYou get a pound a day of junk mail? That's absurd.
- simbolit 13y agoin germany you get paid if you bring paper to commercial recycling centres. virtually nobody does it though, because the regular municipal waste disposal picks it up for free. and yes, it really is free, you only pay for disposal of unsorted waste, which goes in a different bin.
- vxNsr 13y agoMaybe just put the mail in the trash if you don't wanna pay the recycling cost; just saved you "serious money."
- samolang 13y agoDo you have a source on that? I've always heard the opposite, that we subsidize the junk mailers.
- jessaustin 13y agoWell, we pay them our time and attention, but the system wouldn't work if its biggest service operated at a loss: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/20/business/seeking-revenue-postal-service-plans-to-deliver-more-junk-mail.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/20/business/seeking-revenue-p...
- samolang 13y agoThat article states that 48% of all mail, or 84B pieces, is junk mail and corresponds to $17B in revenue (works out to 20 cents a piece). Seems to indicate that most revenue comes from non-junk mail. Also, it states nothing about profitability. The USPS as a whole operates at a loss, why couldn't junk mailing be operating at a loss?
- pessimizer 13y ago>The USPS as a whole operates at a loss, why couldn't junk mailing be operating at a loss? Because there's no earthly reason to take a loss on advertising? What you're not accounting for here is the cost to pick up individual envelopes from your house, and the cost of dropping a presorted bundle shipped to the BMC into the truck.
- JoshTriplett 13y agoDoes anyone have more-or-less precise numbers for how much the post office is subsidized via junk mail? How much would a stamp cost otherwise, or otherwise how much would the shortfall be?
- pyre 13y agoThey don't completely ignore it. It is mentioned at least two other times, including in the final paragraph of the article: > USPS declined to provide further comment, or respond to these questions, of any kind, despite repeated requests. USPS did not dispute Evan’s recollection of their USPS meeting in DC and did not comment on whether junk mailers are the Post Office’s customers versus average Americans.
- pessimizer 13y agoI mean that they completely ignore discussing the claim on its merits, and just use it without context to paint USPS as a bunch of Luddite rent-seeking goons, as with Uber and taxi laws, or AirBnB and hotel laws.
- XorNot 13y agoIt's become "the silicon valley model" for public policy it seems. Appeal to your audience's sense that they are definitely smarter then everyone else, to try and effect stupid changes in public policy in sectors they (and possibly [the general form of] you) don't really understand. Hell, LightPeak tried to do this with RF Engineering when they wanted permission to obliterate things like satellite SOS communications by using spectrum they knowingly acquired as satellite use only for terrestrial transmissions.
- wpietri 13y agoThe interesting thing here to me is how people get captured by business models. The post office started out as an important public service. "Neither snow nor rain nor heat nor gloom of night stays these couriers from the swift completion of their appointed rounds." The post office is mentioned in the US Constitution because at the time it was immensely important. But after enough time in bed with the junk mailers, they've abandoned all but a pretense of that. And it shows. They shifted from serving American citizens as a duty to serving American citizens on a platter. It happened inch by inch, I'm sure, but now they're trapped. Let that be a lesson to anybody who's starting a business: choose your business model wisely, because over time it will win out over everything else.
- Fomite 13y agoI'm an American citizen, and I get a tremendous amount of utility from the post office - and it's increased pretty much every year in recent memory.
- wpietri 13y agoSure. Veal calves are well cared for. And I'm sure some inclination to service remains. But when it comes down to a conflict between what you need and what the junk mailers need, you'll lose. Personally, I get less and less value from the post office. 90% of my physical mail goes immediately in to the recycle bin. At least here, they're bad at delivering packages. And my local post offices are depressing experiences: long lines, dispirited workers, grim surroundings.
- Fomite 13y agoI've had friendly service recently in DC, NC, NJ and VA, and flat-rate Priority mail has utterly changed my interaction with shipping things, to the point that I now no longer even have a good idea where the nearest FedEx or UPS is, and would actively prefer my packages come via USPS.
- cdcarter 13y agoMany many people in large cities would prefer USPS for all package delivery. USPS tends to have keys to apartment building vestibules, allowing them to leave packages in secured areas instead of on a stoop.
- lsc 13y ago>The post office getting upset about ways to prevent junk mail from being delivered is just like a website complaining about Adblock. That's the thing, though; some websites will let me pay them directly for an ad-free experience. The post office won't. I would be happy to pay the post office $5 a month just to say "resident doesn't live here" I'm always afraid a check or bill or something will get tangled up in the 'penny saver' - hell, you could probably get me to pay more for more sophisticated filters, but even $5/month has got to be a hell of a lot more than what the bulk mailers are paying to get into my inbox. And it's probably an even bigger win; I'm not the sort of person who reads the penny saver; the post office is making more money /and/ saving the penny saver people money if they let me pay them not to deliver said periodical. The fremium "Pay me money, or watch ads and the advertisers will pay me, your choice" model is an old one in internet terms, and one that most people seem to be pretty happy with.
- FollowSteph3 13y agoThe problem is if too many people opt out then the junk mail business model fails because advertisers won't advertise. It's not the loss revenue from a few houses they case about its the number of addresses the junk mailers can ship to.
- angersock 13y agoThis is a problem why? Fuck'em.
- lsc 13y agoThen let the post office charge enough to replace the advertising revenue. I also suspect your wrong in saying that advertisers will completely give up if the number of deliverable boxes shrink. I mean, sure, they will want to pay proportionally less, but I suspect post office revenue from advertisers would decline smoothly with the rise in revenue from the paid opt-outs, assuming you got the price right. My understanding is that fourth-class "to resident" mail is usually targeted at the most price sensitive customers; people for whom clipping coupons is often a good use of time. Exactly the people who are unlikely to pay money to sort their mailbox. Most of the higher-end mail, like those goddamn pre-approval notices from AmEx, are lovingly personalized, and ship out 'pre-sorted first class' or something. I'm only talking about opting out of the fourth class "penny saver" type junk.
- btown 13y agoIt seems the underlying assumption to advertisers here is that junk mail has a higher conversion rate than junk email. And that may very well be the case - anecdotally, you'll have more eyeball-time on that colorful supermarket ad lying on your counter than you will on an email-like message that you'll immediately delete. And additionally, there's the coupon use case which allocates existing customers' interest to overstocked items. Coupons can go digital, of course, and you can surface ads in a Gmail-like interface, but there's a chicken-and-egg problem: until the average shopper replaces their entire remember-to-go-shopping workflow with a digital one, there will still be utility from physically delivered coupons and advertisements. I'd even argue that at a national scale, junk mail promotes consumer spending (vs. saving) in an economically significant way by alerting people to limited-time offers. So even if the Post Office were to operate digitization and digital delivery themselves, and access all of the revenue from hosting digital advertisements, if the assumptions above are correct, it would be the "same slice of a smaller pie," since conversions could drop in aggregate. They serve an orthogonal segment of the advertising market from the Googles of the world; it would be like leaving your own perfectly-huge sandbox untended to go play in another kid's, and only get a small corner of it. Even if they weren't federally mandated to have the capacity to deliver mail to any address, it wouldn't be in their interest business-wise UNLESS those assumptions above are changed dramatically.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- inthewoods 13y agoProbably just me, but the line about 400 junk mailers being our customers seemed like a stretch of a comment from someone in the position of being postmaster general. I have trouble believing he or she would say that to these guys and not just give some other explanation.
- crusso 13y agoI don't have trouble believing it. People in positions of power like that often tremendously underestimate their danger of exposure. Often to flaunt their power or crush opposition, they will overplay their hands. Look at the photos that Congressman Anthony Weiner sent on his cell phone. You'd think that a repeated error in judgement like that would be damned near impossible... but there you have it.
- inthewoods 13y agoIt's more than that - it's that I find it hard to believe that the Postmaster only considers junk mailers his or her customers - and doesn't pay any attention to anything else. So I don't doubt the arrogance, I doubt that they would have said something that excluded the ordinary consumer.
- jaybna 13y agoBased on my experience of working in the "junk mail" businesses I agree with you - the USPS had disdain for ALL customers, not just junk mailers. The certainly did not try to help in any way. I cannot imagine this quote being true. I want to defend them but cannot - postal mail is in secular decline but will survive as where you live will always be a useful key to your identity. Just get ready for change (and will take bigger ideas than Outbox to do it)
- pwg 13y ago> Junk mailers sort their own mail, drop ship it to the local BMC, and pay the post office for the privilege. This subsidizes the regular mail. Actually, some evidence shows quite the opposite, that first class mail costs are subsidizing the junk, because the price paid for junk is less than the savings by having the junk dealers do the auto-sorting and drop shipping. See: Title: Junk Mail's Endless Summer URL: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/todd-paglia/junk-mails-endless.. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/todd-paglia/junk-mails-endless.... Quote: "Our standard postage subsidizes junk mail. " Title: Why Do We Subsidize Junk Mail? URL: http://shuthimup.mitzenmacher.net/?p=252 http://shuthimup.mitzenmacher.net/?p=252 Quote: "So why do we pay 45 cents to mail a first-class letter while direct-mail advertisers pay only 18.5 cents? Can you say “crony capitalism?” Can you say “union busting?” This amounts to nothing more than a very costly subsidy given to the direct-mail industry, at the expense of first-class mailers," Title: Snail Mail Spam Subsidies Stuttering Towards A Stop URL: http://blogs.the-american-interest.com/wrm/2011/09/08/snail-.. http://blogs.the-american-interest.com/wrm/2011/09/08/snail-.... Quote: "the USPS loses billions of dollars each year so that advertisers can send out billions of pieces of spam at below market costs."
- rgbrenner 13y agofirst link: 404 second link: site unavailable third link: 404
- pwg 13y agoCorrected links (here because HN is no longer allowing edits to the original): Junk Mail's Endless Summer: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/todd-paglia/junk-mails-endless-summer_b_201928.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/todd-paglia/junk-mails-endless... Second link, seems to simply have disappeared. Snail Mail Spam Subsidies Stuttering Towards A Stop: http://www.the-american-interest.com/wrm/2011/09/08/snail-mail-spam-subsidies-stuttering-towards-a-stop/ http://www.the-american-interest.com/wrm/2011/09/08/snail-ma... Found another link in searching for the new URL's of these three: Subsidizing Junk Mail in the Great Recession: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/todd-paglia/subsidizing-junk-mail-in_b_442132.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/todd-paglia/subsidizing-junk-m...