5 ms·
>> Separate address and search bars is old-fashioned. As a user, I don't want to have to make this distinction, and it's hard to imagine most users-on-street wo
by nailer 13y ago
>> Separate address and search bars is old-fashioned. As a user, I don't want to have to make this distinction, and it's hard to imagine most users-on-street wouldn't find this confusing
> Use the customizer.
Most users-on-street don't want to customise either.
Edit: The moderation on this is baffling. Does anyone genuinely believe users want to customise to achieve reasonable defaults?
HN should ban new users from moderating for a year.
- drewblay 13y ago> Most users-on-street don't want to customize either. Most users on the street aren't on the hacker news forum. Also if you are going to play the "most users on the street" game, then most users on the street aren't going to install a browser that didn't come with the OS.
- nailer 13y ago> Most users on the street aren't on the hacker news forum. I don't think anyone said they were. > then most users on the street aren't going to install a browser that didn't come with the OS. That's true. So it's even more important to retain them by having sensible defaults.
- drewblay 13y ago>That's true. So it's even more important to retain them by having sensible defaults. Not really. What is wrong with having a product that caters to a power user, or a niche group? Why does everything have to be dumbed-down for the "user on the street"? If you want dumbed-down then use the browser that came with your OS. If want something that isn't dumbed-down then you most likely have the know-how to customize your toolbar.
- nailer 13y agoThere is absolutely nothing wrong with a product for power users. Again, nobody in the thread said there was. Firefox is a browser for everyone. It focuses on freedom and privacy. The browser that came with your OS most likely does not. There is no minimum level of technical expertise required. The UX is designed to be simple.
- drewblay 13y agoI still have to disagree with you. I don't buy into your "street person" argument at all. I don't think you give people enough credit. Just about anyone born in the U.S. (or any first world country) in the late 80's and after will probably know how to customize a tool bar in a web browser. Even if they grew up poor and didn't own a computer it would be hard to not have this knowledge after going thru a public school system. If your "street person" happens to be a baby-boomer, then maybe.
- nailer 13y ago> Just about anyone born in the U.S. (or any first world country) in the late 80's and after will probably know how to customize a tool bar in a web browser Agreed, but nobody in the thread is debating whether people know to customise a tool bar in a web browser. The only thing that has been questioned is whether most people want to customise a browser to achieve defaults they find reasonable.
- josteink 13y ago> That's true. So it's even more important to retain them by having sensible defaults. What's sensible about mixing three things (location, history and internet-search) into one location? In Chrome I can't find anything in my history because the browser starts searching the internet instead. It's a horribly frustrating user-experience. Which you cannot even customize. In Firefox you can customize the behaviour. I know which browser I prefer.
- simlevesque 13y agoI want my bars separated for safety reasons
- nailer 13y agoI definitely understand this. I'm just responding to a comment saying 'customise it'. if the simplicity argument is true, then 'customise it' is not an appropriate suggestion. The simplicity argument, of course, could not be true, since simplicity may threaten safety in this particular implementation.
- mccr8 13y ago> HN should ban new users from moderating for a year. You actually need quite a bit of karma (maybe 500?) on Hacker News before you can downvote things, so anybody downvoting you can't be that new of a user.
- Jtsummers 13y ago> so anybody downvoting you can't be that new of a user. IME, you can earn a lot of karma quickly with links. I'd say 1/3 of my karma came from links, and initially that's what pushed me over the top. So they're most likely not new users, but anyone with a month of submissions could have crossed that threshold. It makes me wonder if the two karmas, and the features that get enabled, should be separate things.
- nailer 13y agoThen I'm baffled. There seems to be a recent trend where non controversial things: - the documentation and character support issues can be 'bugs' - defaults that fit most users are good - reminding someone being personal of the HN guidelines ...get moderated up, then down to -3 or -4, then back up to 1 again.
- chc 13y agoI think it's that your response sounded like a lazy dismissal. Reasonable defaults are good, yes. That's pretty uncontroversial. But nobody has established that Firefox's behavior is less reasonable than the alternative — for example, the comment you were replying to noted that both approaches have their fans — so your out-of-hand rejection on behalf of "users-on-street" sounded imperious.
- nailer 13y agoThe only reason I didn't question the behaviour is that the parent didn't either: they just mentioned that most users could customise. Which, as mentioned, they wouldn't want to do. Noticing the folk in the conversation there's lots of newish accounts, and some are replying before they've actually read what they're replying to. Downmods for 'I disagree' are more popular now as well.
- chc 13y ago> Most users-on-street don't want to customise either. Since we're talking about one person's preference rather than the results of a user study, that hardly seems relevant.
- nailer 13y agoI suspect the 'people find a single entry field for both search and URLs to be a simpler' could be proved by a study.
- baddox 13y ago> Most users-on-street don't want to customise either. I can't imagine that most users-on-street would want or benefit from separate address and search fields either.
- josteink 13y ago> Edit: The moderation on this is baffling. Does anyone genuinely believe users want to customise to achieve reasonable defaults? They might find your position unreasonable, and your absolutism not contributing to the discussion. It's absolutely not given that Chrome's behaviour is the "reasonable" default.