17 ms·
Outbox vs. USPS: How the Post Office Killed Digital Mail
- jstalin 13y agoI presumed this story was going to be about the USPS monopoly on first-class mail and would involve an armed raid to shut down competition, as has happened in the past. "The monopoly is well enforced. The USPS can conduct searches and seizures if it suspects citizens of contravening its monopoly. For example, in 1993, armed postal inspectors entered the headquarters of Equifax Inc. in Atlanta. The postal inspectors demanded to know if all the mail sent by Equifax through Federal Express was indeed "extremely urgent," as mandated by the Postal Service's criteria for suspension of the Private Express Statutes. Equifax paid the Postal Service a fine of $30,000. The Postal Service reportedly collected $521,000 for similar fines from twenty-one mailers between 1991 and 1994." http://www.aei.org/papers/economics/opportunities-for-anticompetitive-behavior-in-postal-services/ http://www.aei.org/papers/economics/opportunities-for-antico...
- pessimizer 13y ago“You mentioned making the service better for our customers; but the American citizens aren’t our customers—about 400 junk mailers are our customers. Your service hurts our ability to serve those customers.” The article blows right past this like it's insignificant. Junk mailers sort their own mail, drop ship it to the local BMC, and pay the post office for the privilege. This subsidizes the regular mail. If you can get rid of junk mail with a mouse click, it's not worth it. The post office getting upset about ways to prevent junk mail from being delivered is just like a website complaining about Adblock.
- untog 13y agoThe post office getting upset about ways to prevent junk mail from being delivered is just like a website complaining about Adblock. Yeah, they're both the paid subsidies that allow you to use a service for the price you currently do.
- fps 13y agoExcept I can choose to not visit an ad supported website, yet I cannot stop getting postal mail. I get literally zero benefit from postal mail deliveries (it's all, 100%, junk) and am forced to pay serious money every month to drop off ~30lbs of postal mail at my town's recycling center. Whatever service they claim to provide would be better done by UPS and FedEx for a lower overall cost to the recipient. Let the junk mailers all go out of business.
- devicenull 13y agoYou get a pound a day of junk mail? That's absurd.
- simbolit 13y agoin germany you get paid if you bring paper to commercial recycling centres. virtually nobody does it though, because the regular municipal waste disposal picks it up for free. and yes, it really is free, you only pay for disposal of unsorted waste, which goes in a different bin.
- vxNsr 13y agoMaybe just put the mail in the trash if you don't wanna pay the recycling cost; just saved you "serious money."
- samolang 13y agoDo you have a source on that? I've always heard the opposite, that we subsidize the junk mailers.
- jessaustin 13y agoWell, we pay them our time and attention, but the system wouldn't work if its biggest service operated at a loss: http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/20/business/seeking-revenue-postal-service-plans-to-deliver-more-junk-mail.html http://www.nytimes.com/2012/09/20/business/seeking-revenue-p...
- samolang 13y agoThat article states that 48% of all mail, or 84B pieces, is junk mail and corresponds to $17B in revenue (works out to 20 cents a piece). Seems to indicate that most revenue comes from non-junk mail. Also, it states nothing about profitability. The USPS as a whole operates at a loss, why couldn't junk mailing be operating at a loss?
- pessimizer 13y ago>The USPS as a whole operates at a loss, why couldn't junk mailing be operating at a loss? Because there's no earthly reason to take a loss on advertising? What you're not accounting for here is the cost to pick up individual envelopes from your house, and the cost of dropping a presorted bundle shipped to the BMC into the truck.
- JoshTriplett 13y agoDoes anyone have more-or-less precise numbers for how much the post office is subsidized via junk mail? How much would a stamp cost otherwise, or otherwise how much would the shortfall be?
- pyre 13y agoThey don't completely ignore it. It is mentioned at least two other times, including in the final paragraph of the article: > USPS declined to provide further comment, or respond to these questions, of any kind, despite repeated requests. USPS did not dispute Evan’s recollection of their USPS meeting in DC and did not comment on whether junk mailers are the Post Office’s customers versus average Americans.
- pessimizer 13y agoI mean that they completely ignore discussing the claim on its merits, and just use it without context to paint USPS as a bunch of Luddite rent-seeking goons, as with Uber and taxi laws, or AirBnB and hotel laws.
- XorNot 13y agoIt's become "the silicon valley model" for public policy it seems. Appeal to your audience's sense that they are definitely smarter then everyone else, to try and effect stupid changes in public policy in sectors they (and possibly [the general form of] you) don't really understand. Hell, LightPeak tried to do this with RF Engineering when they wanted permission to obliterate things like satellite SOS communications by using spectrum they knowingly acquired as satellite use only for terrestrial transmissions.
- wpietri 13y agoThe interesting thing here to me is how people get captured by business models. The post office started out as an important public service. "Neither snow nor rain nor heat nor gloom of night stays these couriers from the swift completion of their appointed rounds." The post office is mentioned in the US Constitution because at the time it was immensely important. But after enough time in bed with the junk mailers, they've abandoned all but a pretense of that. And it shows. They shifted from serving American citizens as a duty to serving American citizens on a platter. It happened inch by inch, I'm sure, but now they're trapped. Let that be a lesson to anybody who's starting a business: choose your business model wisely, because over time it will win out over everything else.
- Fomite 13y agoI'm an American citizen, and I get a tremendous amount of utility from the post office - and it's increased pretty much every year in recent memory.
- wpietri 13y agoSure. Veal calves are well cared for. And I'm sure some inclination to service remains. But when it comes down to a conflict between what you need and what the junk mailers need, you'll lose. Personally, I get less and less value from the post office. 90% of my physical mail goes immediately in to the recycle bin. At least here, they're bad at delivering packages. And my local post offices are depressing experiences: long lines, dispirited workers, grim surroundings.
- Fomite 13y agoI've had friendly service recently in DC, NC, NJ and VA, and flat-rate Priority mail has utterly changed my interaction with shipping things, to the point that I now no longer even have a good idea where the nearest FedEx or UPS is, and would actively prefer my packages come via USPS.
- cdcarter 13y agoMany many people in large cities would prefer USPS for all package delivery. USPS tends to have keys to apartment building vestibules, allowing them to leave packages in secured areas instead of on a stoop.
- lsc 13y ago>The post office getting upset about ways to prevent junk mail from being delivered is just like a website complaining about Adblock. That's the thing, though; some websites will let me pay them directly for an ad-free experience. The post office won't. I would be happy to pay the post office $5 a month just to say "resident doesn't live here" I'm always afraid a check or bill or something will get tangled up in the 'penny saver' - hell, you could probably get me to pay more for more sophisticated filters, but even $5/month has got to be a hell of a lot more than what the bulk mailers are paying to get into my inbox. And it's probably an even bigger win; I'm not the sort of person who reads the penny saver; the post office is making more money /and/ saving the penny saver people money if they let me pay them not to deliver said periodical. The fremium "Pay me money, or watch ads and the advertisers will pay me, your choice" model is an old one in internet terms, and one that most people seem to be pretty happy with.
- FollowSteph3 13y agoThe problem is if too many people opt out then the junk mail business model fails because advertisers won't advertise. It's not the loss revenue from a few houses they case about its the number of addresses the junk mailers can ship to.
- angersock 13y agoThis is a problem why? Fuck'em.
- lsc 13y agoThen let the post office charge enough to replace the advertising revenue. I also suspect your wrong in saying that advertisers will completely give up if the number of deliverable boxes shrink. I mean, sure, they will want to pay proportionally less, but I suspect post office revenue from advertisers would decline smoothly with the rise in revenue from the paid opt-outs, assuming you got the price right. My understanding is that fourth-class "to resident" mail is usually targeted at the most price sensitive customers; people for whom clipping coupons is often a good use of time. Exactly the people who are unlikely to pay money to sort their mailbox. Most of the higher-end mail, like those goddamn pre-approval notices from AmEx, are lovingly personalized, and ship out 'pre-sorted first class' or something. I'm only talking about opting out of the fourth class "penny saver" type junk.
- btown 13y agoIt seems the underlying assumption to advertisers here is that junk mail has a higher conversion rate than junk email. And that may very well be the case - anecdotally, you'll have more eyeball-time on that colorful supermarket ad lying on your counter than you will on an email-like message that you'll immediately delete. And additionally, there's the coupon use case which allocates existing customers' interest to overstocked items. Coupons can go digital, of course, and you can surface ads in a Gmail-like interface, but there's a chicken-and-egg problem: until the average shopper replaces their entire remember-to-go-shopping workflow with a digital one, there will still be utility from physically delivered coupons and advertisements. I'd even argue that at a national scale, junk mail promotes consumer spending (vs. saving) in an economically significant way by alerting people to limited-time offers. So even if the Post Office were to operate digitization and digital delivery themselves, and access all of the revenue from hosting digital advertisements, if the assumptions above are correct, it would be the "same slice of a smaller pie," since conversions could drop in aggregate. They serve an orthogonal segment of the advertising market from the Googles of the world; it would be like leaving your own perfectly-huge sandbox untended to go play in another kid's, and only get a small corner of it. Even if they weren't federally mandated to have the capacity to deliver mail to any address, it wouldn't be in their interest business-wise UNLESS those assumptions above are changed dramatically.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- inthewoods 13y agoProbably just me, but the line about 400 junk mailers being our customers seemed like a stretch of a comment from someone in the position of being postmaster general. I have trouble believing he or she would say that to these guys and not just give some other explanation.
- crusso 13y agoI don't have trouble believing it. People in positions of power like that often tremendously underestimate their danger of exposure. Often to flaunt their power or crush opposition, they will overplay their hands. Look at the photos that Congressman Anthony Weiner sent on his cell phone. You'd think that a repeated error in judgement like that would be damned near impossible... but there you have it.
- inthewoods 13y agoIt's more than that - it's that I find it hard to believe that the Postmaster only considers junk mailers his or her customers - and doesn't pay any attention to anything else. So I don't doubt the arrogance, I doubt that they would have said something that excluded the ordinary consumer.
- jaybna 13y agoBased on my experience of working in the "junk mail" businesses I agree with you - the USPS had disdain for ALL customers, not just junk mailers. The certainly did not try to help in any way. I cannot imagine this quote being true. I want to defend them but cannot - postal mail is in secular decline but will survive as where you live will always be a useful key to your identity. Just get ready for change (and will take bigger ideas than Outbox to do it)
- pwg 13y ago> Junk mailers sort their own mail, drop ship it to the local BMC, and pay the post office for the privilege. This subsidizes the regular mail. Actually, some evidence shows quite the opposite, that first class mail costs are subsidizing the junk, because the price paid for junk is less than the savings by having the junk dealers do the auto-sorting and drop shipping. See: Title: Junk Mail's Endless Summer URL: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/todd-paglia/junk-mails-endless.. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/todd-paglia/junk-mails-endless.... Quote: "Our standard postage subsidizes junk mail. " Title: Why Do We Subsidize Junk Mail? URL: http://shuthimup.mitzenmacher.net/?p=252 http://shuthimup.mitzenmacher.net/?p=252 Quote: "So why do we pay 45 cents to mail a first-class letter while direct-mail advertisers pay only 18.5 cents? Can you say “crony capitalism?” Can you say “union busting?” This amounts to nothing more than a very costly subsidy given to the direct-mail industry, at the expense of first-class mailers," Title: Snail Mail Spam Subsidies Stuttering Towards A Stop URL: http://blogs.the-american-interest.com/wrm/2011/09/08/snail-.. http://blogs.the-american-interest.com/wrm/2011/09/08/snail-.... Quote: "the USPS loses billions of dollars each year so that advertisers can send out billions of pieces of spam at below market costs."
- rgbrenner 13y agofirst link: 404 second link: site unavailable third link: 404
- pwg 13y agoCorrected links (here because HN is no longer allowing edits to the original): Junk Mail's Endless Summer: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/todd-paglia/junk-mails-endless-summer_b_201928.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/todd-paglia/junk-mails-endless... Second link, seems to simply have disappeared. Snail Mail Spam Subsidies Stuttering Towards A Stop: http://www.the-american-interest.com/wrm/2011/09/08/snail-mail-spam-subsidies-stuttering-towards-a-stop/ http://www.the-american-interest.com/wrm/2011/09/08/snail-ma... Found another link in searching for the new URL's of these three: Subsidizing Junk Mail in the Great Recession: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/todd-paglia/subsidizing-junk-mail-in_b_442132.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/todd-paglia/subsidizing-junk-m...
- lgbr 13y agoWhat's strange is, USPS actually seems to be aware of such services and perhaps endorses them. When I signed up for Virtual Post Mail, and proceeded to setup a mail forward on the USPS website, I got this message: > Our records indicate that this address is a commercial mail receiving agency (CMRA). If you are forwarding your mail to a CMRA, please enter your private mailbox number (PMB) below. So what did Outbox do to upset USPS? Becuase what I fear is that my mail scanning service will suffer the same fate as Outbox, and suddenly leave me without a way to get mail. I don't live in the US anymore, but I'm still a citizen, I still pay taxes, and I still own property there. Without mail scanning there is no feasible way for someone in my position to receive my mail. How is the water company going to let me know that my bill is past due? How is the city going to let me know that my property taxes have changed? This isn't just a nuissance, this makes it impossible for me to do business in my own country.
- Spooky23 13y agoYou have a contract with a third party to receive your mail. I don't think they care about that. Sounds like Outbox wanted to divert mail being delivered to one physical address to another for individuals.
- garrettgrimsley 13y agoI don't think that the point at which the mail is diverted is the issue here. The article leads me to believe that the USPS took issue with mass-unsubscribing from junk-mail, not with having mail diverted before reaching the addressee.
- Spooky23 13y agoThe article was written from the POV of the guy who blew through alot of investor money on an idea that wasn't really thought through. The USPS has a legal obligation to provide universal service to every physical address. They unsuccessfully tried to hack around it, while ignoring the multitude of solutions available to do so in a real (but perhaps inconvenient to them) way.
- 13y ago
- Spooky23 13y agoThey didn't think about the corner cases that are part of mail. What do you do with Certified Mail? Registered Mail? Different classes of mail have different security and other business requirements, and involving some random "disruptive" third party has many potential consequences. I'm not sure that I understand why this was necessary for the company anyway. I subscribed to a service in 1999 that did this -- you had bills sent to a PO Box and they would scan/PDF everything for you (even ship copies on CD-ROM). They would also pay your bills for you if desired.
- taiki 13y agohttp://thinkprogress.org/economy/2011/09/28/330524/postal-non-crisis-post-office-save-itself/ http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2011/09/28/330524/postal-no... There's a reason why the post office is going broke, and it's not necessarily bungling on their part. Blame Congress for this one. I'm kind of shocked with how stark the PMG was though.
- throaway1984 13y agoI really doubt that these chaps talk to the PMG. He has a lot bigger fish to fry than talk to 2 tech dweebs.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- quinndupont 13y agoI was reading with great interest until I came to the heading about "disruption" at DC. Defending "ask later" practices is neither disruptive in the proper sense, nor particularly ethical. The reporting here attempts to paint a picture of a slow, outdated USPS (and they surely are, to some extent) by way of obviously false comments ("digital is a fad"? Really? I'm supposed to believe someone at the USPS actually said this, in context? Let's critique the USPS, but let's not fabricate silly positions.) Too bad, really, it sounds like a great idea and excellent technology, but marred by a shameful ideology.
- michaelt 13y ago"digital is a fad"? Really? I'm supposed to believe someone at the USPS actually said this, in context? I agree it's unbelievably that anyone would say digital is a fad, but digitisation of physical postal mail might be a fad; it'll last as a market only as long as recipients want their letters digitally, but senders insist on sending physical mail. Haven't all the senders caught up already? All my bills etc are electronic these days, and very few people send letters in the age of e-mail. Amazon purchases I don't want digitised. Maybe christmas and birthday cards?
- XorNot 13y agoThis sounds much more likely, and would as you say, be a completely accurate statement. Mail that can be digitized will eventually be digitized by its senders, whereas stuff that can't, well, that isn't changing. I know in Australia the bulk of the mail I receive these days is ebay orders from overseas - my bills are digital, my statements are digital. The physical things that go in regular envelopes tend are stuff like new credit cards or registered mail like my passport of things. So yeah, it does seem like an implicitly shrinking space.
- forgottenpass 13y agoThere was so much praise thrown at "disruption" in this article I could barly finish it. I'm not going to make some statement about "news writers" in general, but I'm suprised that this one latched onto such a transparently gross talking-point. It's public face is delivering end users better interactions with the world around them, typcially through technology. An obviously laudable goal, but one that doesn't require disruption nor does disruption neccisarily provide.
- misterbwong 13y agoI may be being too naive, but what's to stop a startup like outbox from opening up a digital version of Mailboxes Etc? Instead of forwarding mail from current addresses or physically picking up mail from peoples' mailboxes, they'd get a new address managed by the digitization service.
- forgottenpass 13y agoI was thinking the same thing as I read the article, they MUST have had that idea, right? There must have been something preventing that model from working, why else would they try something as insane as "undelivering" mail.
- chime 13y agoIt's just like a PO box. You can use it for most casual things but the hassles aren't worth it for services that require proof of physical address like driver's license, bank accounts, mortgages etc. Also using non-physical address for personal transactions raises your fraud score. E.g. your credit card goes to a PO and you ask vendors to ship to your physical address that may not even be in the same zip code or city. The true benefit of a service like Outbox is that I don't miss important paperwork like auto registration and home insurance renewals. But the more important the service, the more stringent the requirements of proving you live at the physical address on file. I own a rental property and it is a pain to make sure all the bills and paperwork related to the property come to my primary residence. Yet I keep finding mail from different companies going to the rental address even though I have set the Billing / Contact address to my primary residence. Companies just do a "SELECT address, city, state, zip" when doing a mail merge, which usually brings up the physical address instead of the billing / contact address.
- forgottenpass 13y agoSure, there are hassles with using a PO box, I've had one 8 of the last 10 years. I think you're overestimating the hurdle they pose in day to day life and to the service Outbox could provide. I occasionally have to use my physical address, but since my most recent move haven't had provided proof of my current address to anybody nor received a single piece of post there. The one item I could use to prove my address has left my safe deposit box exactly once in all 16 months, but the DMV was OK with a PO Box on my drivers license and didn't scan the lease (like they did when I used my old place as the address). It would be a limitation to the services that Outbox could provide with a PO Box system but practically speaking the vast majority of mail for the vast majority of users is a very good start. Just because the USPS isn't handing you your ideal business model on a silver platter, that's not a reason to give up is it?
- bitJericho 13y agoThis makes no sense. They could have circumvented this by having customers give out their addresses as: Joe Schmo c/o Outbox PO Box whatever Closest Outbox Facility, CA 90210 Sounds like some details are missing here.
- throaway1984 13y agoI call BS on this article. We're not getting the full story. (Using a throwaway account since I'm travelling, and on a public computer; this article pissed me off so much that I had to respond right away) Background: I used to work for a research lab which got a majority of its funding from USPS. Worked there for ~10 years. Interacted with the USPS engineering folks in Merrifield, VA very closely. I can assure you: the USPS has some very good engineers (in the true "engineer" sense of the word). None of them would call digital "a fad". Not one. Now, to the article: "but the American citizens aren’t our customers—about 400 junk mailers are our customers." .... wrong! No postal employee will call it "junk mail". They all call it "bulk mail". I know, because I was corrected myself. :-) "Digital is a fad"... wrong again. At one time, the USPS was the largest user of Linux; all of their mail sorting machines were running OCR on Linux boxes (they also were a huge SGI shop, with racks and racks of Octanes and O2s). Today, when mail cannot be sorted automatically, its image is sent to a remote data-entry site, where operators enter the address by hand. See the fluorescent barcode at the back? That's used to tag the mail and barcode it later, all digitally. And finally: we, in our research lab, actually had proposed this "Outbox" style electronic mail forwarding to them back in 1998 or 1999 (the Internet was new). I don't remember the details, but there were some legal issues surrounding it that prevented it from taking off. Remember: the USPS is governed by laws (passed by Congress) that were written around the time of Ben Franklin. Fun fact: the average speed of letter sorting by hand (800 pcs/hour) was established by Ben himself, and is still the target for manual sorting. Plus: I doubt the PMG would become personally involved in such small nonsense. I know everyone wants to make fun of USPS; but for the price, they do a phenomenal job. People want them to compete with "the market", but don't realize that the USPS' hands are tied: they can't raise rates without approval from the Postal Rate Commission; they can't close post offices that have no customers; etc. etc. After the Civil War, when Congress wanted to give the veterans jobs, where did it send them? To the Post Office! I've heard (rumor) that even today, the USPS cannot use your discharge status against you for a job.
- don_draper 13y agoThey drop junk at my house every day without any easy way to opt out. Do they deserve scorn? Absolutely.
- cjoh 13y agoWhat's wrong with this story is that Outbox didn't want to do the one thing that would keep it in business: make its customers fill out a form that allows a third party to accept mail on their behalf. There are plenty of businesses digitizing mail right now -- travelingmailbox.com, earthclassmail.com, amongst others. Why Outbox.com refused to go this route and instead decided to go out of business was their decision. There was a workaround (http://travelingmailbox.com/usps-form-1583-ca http://travelingmailbox.com/usps-form-1583-ca) -- they just opted not to take it. That's not the USPS's fault.
- ma2rten 13y agoSince I came to US, I've been thinking about actually using one of those. These providers seem much cheaper than their equivalents in Europe. Does anyone here have experience with any of those providers?
- rubyrescue 13y agoI use Earthclassmail extensively. It can be expensive. However, it provides some incredibly valuable services. Mail scanning is great, but check deposit is better. However, it's only worth it if you really need a US address, move a lot, or have enough mail or check volume to justify $80/month.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoI assume you write that $80/month off as a business expense, correct?
- blago 13y agoI live on 3 continents and my life would't be possible without https://www.postscanmail.com/ https://www.postscanmail.com/ Much cheaper then Earth Class Mail.
- spacehome 13y agoYea, but they give you a PO Box, which can be troublesome for certain purposes.
- al2o3cr 13y ago"Maintaining a fleet of vehicles to go to every person’s house every day was costing them a fortune" Funny, that's just what the USPS is constitutionally mandated to do (Article I, Section 8, Clause 7).
- jstalin 13y agoMandated? "The Congress shall have Power To . . . establish Post Offices and Post Roads" The constitution permits congress to establish post offices and post roads, but it certainly does not mandate it.
- tanzam75 13y agoNo, the USPS is not constitutionally mandated to deliver to your house. The Post Office Department did not begin delivering mail to city addresses until 1863. Rural Free Delivery did not begin until 1893. Before free delivery, you went to the Post Office yourself and asked for your mail. ("Caller service" or "General delivery", both of which still exist.) Since the 1970s, the Postal Service has been delivering to clusterboxes. Grandfathered areas get to keep their individual mailboxes, but new greenfield development must be built with clusterboxes. If mail volume keeps decreasing, we'll see greater contraction in free delivery. It all depends on how the politics go.
- mcroft 13y agoWhat a WASTE.
- vibrolax 13y agoDon't Ever Antagonize The Horn
- Theodores 13y agoYou do wonder why post offices - everywhere - not just in the US - have not done something with electronic delivery. If I was Postmaster General I would like to see a post office ISP that only accepted mail from government departments, local authorities, banks, hospitals, doctors, schools and other agencies. From there people could setup a forwarding address - if people wanted to just check their mail from one account, e.g. gmail, they could have the 'important stuff' rolled into it. Or they could setup POP/IMAP. There could also be a webmail where you would be able to have highest accessibility standards. Clearly the cryptography would have to be in place so only the sender and the recipient could read the mail - a 'virtual envelope'. Naturally there would be tracking tags so they knew if someone had read that 'final demand'. As a competitive service for banks etc. wanting to send out statements it could work very nicely. Good for trees, too.
- dobbsbob 13y agoCanada has epost which is a crypto vault to hold bank or gov mail you can give other people access . Nobody here proposed the scheme of this article's opening of all mail though, that's illegal to do without a warrant due to hundreds year old laws. A nice reminder that once upon a time our ancestors rejected state surveillance.
- YokoZar 13y agoWhy not just start with "virtual" PO boxes? Instead of addressing letters to a physical mailbox, people who want to send me mail should address them to some unique identifier that means me the person. I would then go and tell the post office what address that identifier maps to, and I would never have to worry about forwarding mail when I move or updating my address whenever I buy something. You need the post office involved here so you don't end up shipping packages twice, like with traditional forwarding services. Once you have THAT infrastructure, creating a service to digitize mail becomes much simpler - whether done by the post office or third parties.
- bsder 13y agoCongress prevented it. The Post Office tried to become a sort of "digital hub" for rural areas (bill paying, faxing, etc.). That got quashed. Congress is not interested in a good Post Office. Quite the contrary. They want the Post Office to go bankrupt so that they can get their hands on all of the really expensive real estate it is sitting on.
- saurik 13y agoIf someone wants a service like this, in my opinion Earth Class Mail is a better alternative. They are not in any way "hip" or "web 2.0" and they would never in a million years talk about "disrupting" some established legal regime: but frankly, I'm not just "ok" with that, that makes me ecstatic. I thereby see this "how the post office killed digital mail", a dream I've been successfully living now for years through one of their "less disruptive" competitors, and can do nothing but laugh. Instead, Earth Class Mail is a service that has been in business since 2006 and they operate within the existing legal framework of mail: they are effectively the kind of service that is required to live in an RV, where a third-party receives your mail on your behalf. To make this work, you sign forms from the post office that you send to Earth Class Mail, which are then kept on file to demonstrate they can legally open your mail. Maybe Outbox used the same process, maybe they didn't, but this article made it sound like Outbox is responsible for this legal framework: wrong, the ability to assign "open my mail" rights has existed for a long time. Rather than having to have cars driving around attempting to "undeliver" your mail with some ludicrous three-day delay as Outbox did (at extreme cost to the service that calls into question whether their business model would even succeed, a fact mentioned in this article linked today, and limiting them to only even being able to think about operating in high-density regions of the country), you simply have your mail delivered to them. You can initially set this up with your local post office as you work on "moving" to ECM, and you can even do it temporarily if you just want to try it out (the post office will happily forward mail for as little as 15 days: again, this is a use case they actively support). But frankly it is so amazingly relaxing once you "commit" and outsource your physical address. I have a lot of friends that move every couple years, and the idea that they have to change their address at the same time is silly: that is the most stressful moment to be trying to move mail delivery and you can't usually overlap the old and new addresses to buffer mistakes. In the most extreme situations, people who are traveling a lot (for whatever reason; maybe they have a job that requires them to be in random locations for weeks on end a lot, or maybe they are just kind of nomadic and stay with friends a lot as they travel the country) will tell you to send things to their current location. Outbox sort of helped with this, but the three-day delay sounded really irritating: ECM just solves this problem outright; you don't even need a real physical address at all. Indeed, I seriously have now switched to using my Earth Class Mail address for everything: my drivers license even has that address on it (and yes, I verified with the people at the California DMV that there was no issue with this, and they technically do have my physical address on file; but their policy is to print the mailing address of the driver on the card), which makes it really easy for me to never get into an argument with anyone about what my address is: I effectively now live at Earth Class Mail in Los Angeles. The only people who know my real address are the US government (DMV and voting registration, though they happily send my voting materials to ECM), the power/cable/phone services to my apartment (again, bills go to ECM), and my health insurance company (they base pricing on where you physically reside). They offer multiple locations around the country, so you can get an address vaguely near you or opt for one that "looks good" for your purpose (maybe you want your startup to look like it has an office in San Francisco, for example). With some of the addresses they are legitimate "street addresses" that can receive packages on your behalf, and you can either have the package forwarded to you or you can go pick it up from them if you need it now and live near enough to the location. (Though, with packages, I normally just one-off deliver those to my apartment.) (I wonder if you can have them open the package and take a picture of the contents... I never asked ;P.)
- maresca 13y agoI hate to be that guy but if you popup a dialog as soon as I visit a site, I immediately click the back button.
- krallja 13y agoAnti-Post Office hatchet job: > So having worked on the Hill they knew of the USPS’s well-documented inefficiencies. As they describe it, they “knew that the USPS would not be able to work out its own problems, so perhaps naively, we hoped to partner with USPS to provide an alternative to the physical delivery of postal mail to a subset of users, hoping this would spur further innovation and cost savings.” The Post Office is insanely efficient. The only reason it has budget problems is because Congress causes the budget problems. http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2011/09/28/330524/postal-non-crisis-post-office-save-itself/ http://thinkprogress.org/economy/2011/09/28/330524/postal-no...
- ewzimm 13y agoThere's even more to it. Business is good for the USPS as more people shop online. They carry a lot of packages for FedEx and UPS to places they won't go. Their pensions are overfunded by billions. This source estimates $82 billion. The article is from 2011, but the process to reclaim the money is ongoing. http://www.pionline.com/article/20110627/PRINT/306279976/usps-return-82-billion-to-sender http://www.pionline.com/article/20110627/PRINT/306279976/usp...
- rescripting 13y agoAre you sure about that? It seems like there is nothing 'insanely efficient' about physically sending paper across the country when the recipient has indicated that no, you actually don't need to do that. It's like the USPS has an insanely optimized implementation but inefficient algorithm for delivering mail. Change the algorithm and you can throw all your micro optimizations out the window. The important quote from the article is this one: > ‘You mentioned making the service better for our customers; but the American citizens aren’t our customers—about 400 junk mailers are our customers. Your service hurts our ability to serve those customers.‘ This sure makes it sound like the USPS isn't so much a 'public good' as it is a private, tax payer funded business whose primary business model is advertising.
- msandford 13y agoI don't think you understand how junk mail works. There are a few hundred companies in the US who print junk mail. They are located in the cities that the junk mail will eventually be delivered in. They receive huge discounts to pre-sort the mail by zip code and palletize it in such a way as to cleanly slip into the USPS's system at the last possible logistic point. It might cost a regular human being $0.49 to send a letter. A presort mailer might pay $0.12 or $0.09 or $0.07 (or less) to send a letter. But that's because the USPS provides only the last mile rather than cross-country transport. The reason this revenue stream is so important to the USPS is logistics, overhead vs marginal cost. As long as you're delivering a couple of pieces of mail to each house every day you can price those items marginally. Average Mail Per Address (AMPA) needs to be at least 3-5 for the USPS's pricing to work. If everyone opted out of junk mail AMPA would drop into a range more like 0.5-1.5 and then there's proportionally much less in the way of marginal cost and it's all the overhead of driving/walking from one address to the next. And then the USPS has to change all the pricing to go up by 200% or more and that'll never fly in Congress. The other problem is that reducing the mail volume by 50%-90% would result in massive layoffs of workers (which won't look good for Congress) and it would reduce influence and power for those in charge of things. Few people ever willingly accept their diminishing importance. I'm not in favor of the USPS continuing to assault my mailbox with junk mail. But I don't think there's any hope of things getting fixed until they have such an awful year that mail stops for a while and Congress reforms their mandate. I give it maybe 20% odds of happening in the next decade.
- stellar678 13y agoCan't Outbox just provide me with a c/o address, and I can update my address with anyone who intends to send me mail?
- jrochkind1 13y agoUm, the existing industry doesnt use "disruption" negatively because they "don't speak the same language." Theyuse it negatively because you are talking quite literally about disrupting their business and probably putting them out of it. Not talking about outbox and usps specifically so much as the fetishization of "disruption" the OP author buys into without question, as if the only reason to be scared of "disruptio " is a cultural misunderstanding, you're not with the program. Rather, quite obviously its bad for some existing business interests -- but also it's certainly possible to challenge the religious belief that disruptionof markets always leads to better outcomes for consumers or society as a whole.
- XorNot 13y agoNo at this point it's used negatively because the silicon valley startup crowd have been using the word constantly for the past 10 years now, in reference to every conceivable sector of industry, which, as this article perfectly highlights, they frequently don't understand in the slightest.
- jeffbr13 13y agoCan anyone vouch for any similar services in Europe (specifically in the UK)? I change address fairly regularly, as a student, and it'd be great if I could cut out paper mail entirely.
- bowlofpetunias 13y agoThis is such bull. How could any postal service in good conscience (or legally for that matter) co-operate with a service which consists of opening other people's mail? Any postal service should deliver mail to the addressee, unopened and unchanged. Any deals that put that mail in the hands of third parties should be a no-go to start with. And they also shouldn't be offering this themselves. Closed envelopes stay closed. If that means postal services are not profitable, so be it. That was never the reason they existed in the first place.
- DEinspanjer 13y agoI've seen several people mention Earth Class mail as a working alternative here. I am not sure if even their lowest monthly charge would provide enough value to be worth it for my own use case, but I do have a few questions regarding it for their users.. Do you still have a mailbox at your home? If so, do you still check it regularly? If so, do you still receive bulk mail drops from postal carriers in that mailbox? I'm talking about the ones that typically are addressed to "Current Resident" and such. Unless you are in a position that you can confidently forgo ever checking that mailbox again, it seems that you would still be receiving those and be forced to deal with them. That would take a lot of the potential out of the service for me.
- joshuaheard 13y agoDid these guys really think a government monopoly that has operated the same way for over 200 years was going to change their procedures to accommodate their startup idea?
- Fomite 13y agoI was able to get a package sent across the country in three days, delivered to someone's door, and watch its progress online for $5.60 in 1814?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- joshuaheard 13y agoWell, it would take 3 months and your would get your progress by telegraph, but otherwise, yes.
- anigbrowl 13y agoThis is one of the most disingenuous articles I've read in a while. I expected something a bit more subtle from a Yale alumnus. They believed that their technology could actually save the Post Office money. If consumers started to opt-in to Outbox, or other services like Outbox, then the Post Office could receive the full benefits of the stamped envelope but never have to deliver those packages, which is one of the biggest costs for the Post Office. In fact, if properly implemented, when a customer sends a letter from Austin, TX to Alaska, if the Post Office knew that they weren’t going to receive the letter anyway, then the Post Office could forward the letter from Austin directly to Outbox, and never have to ship the letter across the continent. This, for example, is just laughably wrong. Marginal cost isn't the bugbear of the USPS; universal service obligations are. As long as there's one person in Alaska who doesn't want to sign up for digital mail (possibly because they can't reliably connect to it in Alaska), then the USPS has to fly planes or sail boats up there to deliver the mail anyway. And as Outbox themselves discovered, moving mail around for individual customers is hideously expensive. It can be made efficient in cities where there is sufficient population density, but something like 1/3 of US addresses are on rural routes and of course delivery to those is more expensive. Even if half the customers on rural routes sign up for a service like Outbox, there's no promise that they'll be the ones farthest away from sorting offices, so mail carriers will need to travel more or less the same routes even if they are serving a lower number of customers, plus all customers will want packages delivered because packages have physical rather than purely informational content. Unfortunately, the profit margin on Package elivery is only about 1/3 that of first class mail delivery, which continues to decline in volume at about the same rate that demand for package delivery increases, leaving the USPS in a now-in situation which requires it to balance the books through cuts rather than investment and growth for the foreseeable future: http://about.usps.com/strategic-planning/five-year-business-plan-2012-2017.pdf http://about.usps.com/strategic-planning/five-year-business-... I loathe junk mail with a passion and it really irritates me that I have no way to opt out from it, that the USPS is required to inefficiently front-load all its fiscal obligations as if they were payable tomorrow, and a whole bunch of other things. But by ignoring the legal operating constraints imposed by Congress on the USPS and the resulting necessity of dealing with bulk mailers, the author is doing his readers a huge disservice by offering trite solutions to knotty problems, essentially arguing that the USPS should pick up the costs of mail forwarding on behalf of a service which reduces the utility (and thus revenue) of the USPS's largest income stream (bulk delivery). In 2014 Derek was selected for Forbes' top 30 under 30 list for law and policy and as a 2014 Global Leader of Tomorrow, for thought leadership and activism on NSA surveillance and innovation policy. I'm pretty sure that if the USPS had been offering to open, scan, digitally archive, and destroy your physical mail for the last decade as Derek says they should have been, he'd be writing a similarly indignant rant about big government overreach and the crowding out of private competitors, regardless of assurances about strict siloing or privacy controls.
- rjf1990 13y ago>the American citizens aren’t our customers—about 400 junk mailers are our customer Yup, I used to work for one of the country's largest mailers, doing direct mail strategy. Outbox, if it became widespread, would have killed this marketing channel.
- lamontcg 13y agoFuck the USPS. Seriously. Its been obvious for at least a decade that the customers are direct mail advertisers and we're the product and we can't really opt out (I've signed up for a several opt-out services and I still get junk mail).
- bsder 13y agoThese guys are doing the classic startup shuffle--pick off the profitable people and leave the some chump (aka the government) with the unprofitable ones. Although, I'm a bit skeptical that they couldn't "undeliver" mail profitably in a city-density area like Austin. Focusing just on businesses and apartment complexes, $640/mo + mileage gets you a person twice a week, for 8 hours a day, at $10 an hour. At $5 per month per subscriber you need to collect about 150 subscribers per month to make your nut. Really? They couldn't get 150 subscribers serviced by 1 person over 8 hours? Sounds like they didn't control their rollout density or price correctly. This sounds more like "Waaaaaah, we're only going to be a $20 million company rather than a $2 billion company. I'm going to have to hang my head in shame at the next Skull-and-Bones barbeque. We should shut down."
- ghshephard 13y agoI haven't received physical mail where I live in 15 years. I have all my paper bills sent to paytrust, who scans them, and then pays them per automated rules (or allows me to manually approve.) Physical Mail just goes to 650 Castro Street in Mountain View, where I get a re-mail once a month wherever I am in the world. I lived in an apartment for about 18 months, but never asked for a key to my mailbox as there really was no reason for me to open it. The only packages I ever need to receive at my place of residence are via FedEx/UPS.
- chris123 13y agoSeinfeld covered this scenario over a decade ago, complete with visit from Postmaster General: http://youtu.be/JpUqLjjKk4Y?t=3m20s http://youtu.be/JpUqLjjKk4Y?t=3m20s