3 ms·
Google considers this a feature, not a bug, and that you are the product and the carrier is the customer: http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=3856
by davidgerard 13y ago
Google considers this a feature, not a bug, and that you are the product and the carrier is the customer: http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=38563#c105 http://code.google.com/p/android/issues/detail?id=38563#c105
- bad_user 13y agoQuote from that email: > IS NOT A BUG. IT IS A FEATURE. It's not a feature for users like you and me, it's a feature for manufacturers like Samsung and HTC, so they can in turn build devices that carriers can have more control over. The reason why I switched to Android was precisely the control I have with it, with the primary annoyance I experienced with iOS being that the carrier has to give approval for tethering (amongst other bullshit precisely like this one). This happens for Windows Phone too. Was pleased with Android precisely because it's the only OS in which the feature cannot be turned on/off by the career. Apparently this is no longer true. A bug BY DESIGN is still a bug. UPDATED: corrected sentence, iOS is not a carrier :-)
- jacquesm 13y ago> iOS being the carrier that has to give approval for tethering What do you mean by that?
- lsaferite 13y agoYou quoted the post out of context. They were saying they experienced that with iOS devices the carrier was the only one who could enabled tethering while with android devices that was not always the case.
- jacquesm 13y agoIt's a literal quote of a part of the comment, I simply don't understand how iOS could be a carrier in any context.
- kbutler 13y ago> iOS could be a carrier No, it couldn't. (See what I did there?)
- squintychino 13y ago> No
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- dahart 13y agoI see where the confusion started... bad_user was mis-quoted... "iOS being that the carrier has to give approval for tethering"
- zimpenfish 13y agoAlthough the carrier can still block tethering regardless of whether the device purports to let you use it.
- blueskin_ 13y agoIf they can detect it. If the user is sensible, they can't.
- bad_user 13y agoNo they can't. Devices can have apps on them, apps can have the same usage pattern as your laptop. It wouldn't work even if they did deep packet inspection, like reading the browser's headers or things like that, because then it would break in-app functionality for apps that allow you to fake your connection to make the server respond as if you were a desktop (also thinking about browsers).
- zimpenfish 13y agoI don't think telcos are all that fussed about the minority of people who use faking apps compared with the amount of money they can sting people for by charging extra to allow tethering. UK telcos certainly manage to block tethering when you've not paid for it - or even when you have paid for it but exceeded your monthly allowance.
- thefreeman 13y agoeven so, that problem is just as easily worked around with a browser extension to mimic mobile browser user agent or headers. Granted that could result in our receiving content formatted for a mobile browser but im sure someone could work around that. Also if the site is designed responsively which I believe is the best practice (I think user agent sniffing is discouraged) then this won't be an issue.
- thefreeman 13y agowhat exactly about this comment is downvote worthy?
- antsar 13y agoI'm guessing what he meant was: the primary annoyance I experienced with iOS being [that] the carrier that has to give approval for tethering
- jacquesm 13y agoAh good one. Thank you, that fits.
- kllrnohj 13y agoYou do realize the person you quoted isn't a Google employee or someone working on Android at all, right? That was just from some random joe schmoe. Nobody from @android.com or @google.com has commented on the bug at all. And you do still have control, you are free to compile AOSP for a handful of supported devices directly, and you are free to use CM or whatever. Well, except CM has this bug/feature, too.
- userbinator 13y agoThis has to be one of the most explicit mentions of "if you're not paying for it, you're the product being sold" I've seen. Normally companies tend to be somewhat more subtle about that kind of thing.
- personZ 13y agoiOS, Windows Phone, Blackberry OS -- they all flag and honor carrier tethering usage allowances. Therefore, by this simplistic logic, to all of them you are the product? I doubt Google's intentions are quite as simple. It's entirely possible that they're honoring the "carrier code" to ensure competition is robust. If your carrier has a problem with tethered data, get a different carrier. As an aside, it's pretty bizarre to see a comment by some random person (the "IT'S A FEATURE NOT A BUG!") being used as if it's a statement by Google. Bizarre.
- untog 13y agoI actually find it refreshing - at least they're honest about it. And I'm sure you can find a ROM without it.
- nailer 13y agoYou're the product being sold here, but you pay GBP 600 for an Android flagship phone, and more if you need a contract.
- preinheimer 13y agoIs this really "google" considering it so? The poster identifies themselves as working for a carrier, not google.
- mncolinlee 13y agoThe fact that Android staff later fixed the bug in 4.4.2 implies you are wrong. The carrier is not the customer in Google's market. The advertiser is. I thought that was pretty clear. The carrier merely delivers product.
- mcguire 13y agoIs it "fixing a bug" or "removing a feature that is causing product shrinkage"?
- mncolinlee 13y agoDo you want the official answer or the paranoid answer? The problem with all these extreme explanations is that all the evidence here is not evidence. It's just one irate carrier employee mouthing off on Google's bug forum. This should be obvious, but a gmail.com email address != android.com email address.
- shawnz 13y agoAndroid is a product which is used by carriers to produce phones. They ARE the customer. If you don't agree with the choices your carrier made with their distribution of android, you have alternate options like Cyanogenmod.
- kllrnohj 13y agoJust because you aren't the customer doesn't mean you are the product. Google's customers are BOTH end users AND carriers.