3 ms·
Distribution is not several. Kinkos already ran into this.
by protomyth 13y ago
Distribution is not several. Kinkos already ran into this.
- anigbrowl 13y agoIf you're talking about Basic Books v. Kinko's, that seems like a completely different question because Kinko's pre-emptively copied the course materials and offered them for sale to students. Furthermore, Kinko's solicited professors teaching classes to place orders on behalf of their students, offering a 10% discount to professors who got their orders in early (presumably in the slow weeks before classes start). But the discount was not offered on the production of the course packets - rather, it was a discount (in the form of a faculty discount card) on the professors' own use of Kinko's services. Students paid individually to buy the course packets designed by their professors and unilaterally produced and distributed by Kinko's, based on professors' advice of how many students were taking the class and would (presumably) require the course packets. How do you get from this that distribution is not several? I see no such conclusion of law in the judgment. I wouldn't rely on on a law dictionary as the sole source, but it is of recent vintage and if distribution were not considered to be several that would be a pretty significant error.
- protomyth 13y ago"How do you get from this that distribution is not several?" I cannot really add to what you said, and I wasn't thinking of that case, but more the terms of service and training Kinko's has. "Playboy Enterprises, Inc. v. Frena"[1] is the specific case that I thought made the rules that this service would fall under and how distribution doesn't require multiple receivers. also: http://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1113&context=iplj http://ir.lawnet.fordham.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=111... That case has a quote that would seem to nuke this business model: "There is no dispute that Defendant Frena supplied a product containing unauthorized copies of a copyrighted work. It does not matter that Defendant Frena claims he did not make the copies itself." and "Intent or knowledge is not an element of infringement, and thus even an innocent infringer is liable for infringement". 1) http://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=994289757272580461&q=839+F.+Supp.+1552&hl=en&as_sdt=2,5 http://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=9942897572725804...
- anigbrowl 13y agoWe'll have to agree to disagree on this. I think the severality and pre-emption aspects of this case are also very different. In a nutshell (and quoting from the judgment): Subscribers can upload...material onto the bulletin board so that any other subscriber, by accessing their computer, can see that material. To me that's obviously distribution because a) multiple downloaders had access to uploaded material (severality), and b) when a subscriber logged into the BBS, the copyrighted material was already there, listed as available for download (pre-emption). What I think is different about this new service is that (as far as I can tell) if I use it to generate printed copies of, say, a New Yorker article and 3 Techcrunch articles, the resulting document is sent only to me, is not offered for download or printing to others, and is not retained on the server after the hard copy has been printed and mailed out. Furthermore, I can't select these copyrighted works on the site itself, but must submit URLs of my own choice. So what's being offered here is a reformatting and printing service for an individual only. My use of the service as described above would not make the content in question accessible to you. Now, if I collected 50 articles into a 'magazine' othat reflected my interests, and that was made available to other customers, then it would certainly be a case of distribution and blatant copyright infringement. Incidentally, although this situation has superficial similarities to the Aereo case before the Supreme Court at present, I think a key difference is that Aereo pre-emptively stores broadcasted content for later download, and likewise has buolt an infrastructure of receiving antennae which they essentially rent out to customers. In my view Aereo is relying on a flawed post-hoc rationalization of their action, whereas personalpaper.me (as far as I know) didn't hit up any URL until someone requested it to be added to a print queue.