2 ms·
We need a modern-day equivalent that works over existing phone technology. I should be able to call anyone on their cellphone and have a secure call. With data
by MichaelGG 13y ago
We need a modern-day equivalent that works over existing phone technology. I should be able to call anyone on their cellphone and have a secure call. With data it's straightforward (ZRTP or VPN), but not for voice channels. I wonder if its possible to get enough data throughput over GSM compressed audio for encrypted voice to work.
- rdl 13y agoI really don't see the point, given how ubiquitous data is, at least at EDGE speeds, and how expensive international long distance remains. I'd rather have something which degraded to half duplex voice messages (and IM) relaxing hard realtime on the slowest data links. I also want wideband audio whenever possible (which is frequent). There were open source systems which used CSD/HSCSD on Windows CE ("cryptophone", in early incarnations), and systems which did used analog phone lines and then modems and slip/ppp (I think a plugin for speak freely), but neither analog lines nor HSCSD are particularly common these days. Even the military stuff moved to ISDN, largely.
- mnw21cam 13y agoSpeak Freely was pretty good, and had plugins for all sorts of compression and encryption systems. It could quite happily compress and encrypt intelligible voice sufficiently to be carried over a 1995-era modem. But then Skype swept it away. Shame, really.
- fredgrott 13y agoZRTP can be used for voice.. Zimmerman's new startup does exactly that
- MichaelGG 13y agoZRTP is for VoIP, Silent Circle offers a VoIP service. It doesn't help me if I don't have IP transit. I talked to Phil for several minutes about this but he wasn't convinced you could get enough bandwidth. As rdl said, data is becoming prevalent everywhere so maybe it's not worthwhile.