3 ms·
I am with those saying this is a bad idea. Karma no longer shows on individual comments. I understand that was goal oriented and accomplished it's goal. Greying
by Mz 13y ago
I am with those saying this is a bad idea. Karma no longer shows on individual comments. I understand that was goal oriented and accomplished it's goal. Greying out of comments is a non-numerical signal of negative karma. It isn't intended as censorship. Nor should it be.
I tend to be controversial everywhere I go. It is not uncommon for me to get one downvote and then one corrective upvote. I know for a fact that there are forum members who practice corrective upvoting. I suspect a lot of the downvotes I get are from folks who personally dislike me, not really based on the quality of that comment per se.
If you turn negative karma on a comment into censorship instead of signal, you start moving towards a situation where groupthink gets way out of hand. It isn't healthy to completely silence minority opinions or other kinds of outlier communication. Intentionally creating an atmosphere where you kill the messenger and force people to be yes-men will harm the health of the forum (and of YC, indirectly) not improve the civility of the community.