3 ms·
"And we all know how that's gone in America with the simple roundabout." Roundabouts are not unpopular, and exist in cities like DC with no one complaining. T
by dnautics 13y ago
"And we all know how that's gone in America with the simple roundabout."
Roundabouts are not unpopular, and exist in cities like DC with no one complaining. The reason why roundabouts are unpopular is because city meddlers often put them in places where their purpose is not to mitigate accidents but to attempt to limit speeding through side streets, with negligible (if not negative) effect on traffic safety.
- to3m 13y agoOf course, speeding through side streets is to be much preferred, the purpose of such streets being solely to permit the swift passage of motorized traffic ;) The ages of the naysayers in the article were interesting, though this could simply reflect people the journalist and their colleagues knew. To be revisited in 20 years, I think...
- peatmoss 13y agoSome terminology about circular traffic features: Big things that you can travel quickly into, which are most commonly found on the U.S. East Coast (e.g. Washington, D.C.) are called rotaries, and are generally considered to not be particularly good or safe. Mid-sized things with splitter islands preceding the entry, and that have an angle of entry that prohibits entering at speed are called roundabouts, and generally are considered a good thing from a speed / efficiency perspective. Small things with no splitter islands preceding, that are usually put on quiet residential streets (common in Seattle among other places), are called traffic circles. Confusingly, rotaries are sometimes called traffic circles too (see Dupont Circle). I disagree with your assessment about traffic circles being placed by city meddlers, as well as the assertion that they don't have a positive effect on safety. First, in Seattle and elsewhere, they are typically requested by residents of the street (not us meddling urban planners), and are built where a speeding problem is confirmed, as resources become available, and according to some geographic equity criteria. Second, though I haven't done an exhaustive review of traffic circle literature, this summary review article is bullish on traffic calming features generally, and specifically on traffic calming circles as well: http://jpl.sagepub.com/content/23/4/347.short http://jpl.sagepub.com/content/23/4/347.short
- dnautics 13y agoThanks for the terminology clarification. I grew up in the DC area, so to me a 'traffic circle' is all of the above, but thinking of places like dupont circle as the archetype of the 'working' circle. I didn't say urban planners, I said city meddlers, i.e. select residents of the street. And all the complaints I have ever heard about the (small) traffic circles have been from the residents themselves. There could be a sample bias: I'm a lyft driver; the complaints come from passengers getting dropped off at their homes, usually from nights of drinking.
- judk 13y agoYou are hearing complaints from the troublesome speeders and drunk drivers. Thank you for Lyfting them out of there own cars!
- bsder 13y agoThe reason why roundabouts don't work in America is that roundabouts solve the wrong problem. Roundabouts are more efficient when faced with non-extremal traffic densities. American traffic densities vary from near-zero to near maximal with very little time spent in the middle. Roundabouts are NOT more efficient in that kind of traffic regime.