4 ms·
> If I sell someone else my paper delivery route, is that an indictment of American capitalism? It is if your customers don't have the option to switch to anot
by lisper 13y ago
> If I sell someone else my paper delivery route, is that an indictment of American capitalism?
It is if your customers don't have the option to switch to another paper.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jpadkins 13y agoand the reason you don't have the option to switch to another service provider is your state and local governments granting comcast, et al local monopolies. Please direct criticism to the proper source: government interference.
- exelius 13y agoNo, the reason you don't have an option to switch to another service provider is that running a wireline provider is really expensive. Building one is even more expensive: you literally have to run cables to every household in a city thanks to the FCC's equal access laws (i.e. you can't ignore the poor parts of town when providing service). Each household probably has a fully-loaded cost of around $1000 (this includes switches, routers, a few thousand miles of cable, teams of guys in trucks to run the cable across the poles, etc), so for a small city of 500k households (~1 million people), you're looking at a ballpark of $500 million. Even if the regulation allowed you to start your own cable company, what investor in their right mind would put up the money to do so? Trying to VC pitch a startup ISP would be the worst pitch ever. "Why am I going to give you a billion dollars for a 10% margin business that you're not even guaranteed to be successful in?"
- pdonis 13y agoIn other words, the reason you don't have options for service providers is that it's expensive to be a provider; and the reason it's expensive to be a provider is...government regulations.
- exelius 13y agoI think even without the government regulations you'd have a similar situation: it's expensive enough to serve even an affluent area that the market can't really support much more than 2 companies (which already exist in the form of Comcast/TimeWarner and FiOS/U-Verse in most wealthy areas). You'd probably also find that some middle-class suburbs would have no providers available at all. Though I do agree that subscriber pricing is much better in areas where you see both a cable company and a telco video provider like FiOS or U-Verse.
- pdonis 13y ago> it's expensive enough to serve even an affluent area that the market can't really support much more than 2 companies I would state this with a key qualifier: it's expensive to serve even an affluent area the way our society currently works. The way our society currently works is that local municipalities are strongly discouraged from doing local development sanely--where "sanely" means that when a new subdivision goes in, say, all the easements for running wired high-speed Internet go in as well. The best way of doing this would be for the local developer to simply run the cables, and have them owned in common by the municipality, homeowner's association, or whatever entity owns the common areas in the development. That entity then leases access to the cables to all Internet providers on an equal basis. The next-best way would be for the local developer to put in all the cable trenches, space for connection hubs, etc. in while the development is being constructed, right along with the water lines, gas lines, storm sewers, and other utilities, and with all the permits, easements, etc. already in place. Then an Internet provider just has to do a cable pull, which is only a small fraction of the cost of installing high-speed Internet in our actual society. When municipalities actually try to do either of the above, however, they find themselves embroiled in lawsuits and negative publicity from the large Internet providers, who can't stand the idea that nobody really wants to buy their overpriced services, and if a way of routing around them became common, their business would be kaput.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> and the reason it's expensive to be a provider is...government regulations. If by government regulations you mean "the fact that running cable means acquiring access rights across large numbers of privately held properties, and government protection of property rights makes you have to negotiate with each of them for the right to access unless you can piggy back on someone else that already has an easement without exceeding the scope of the existing easement", then, sure, its about government regulations. But its the kind of government regulations that even the people who complain about government regulations generally support (often, support most emphatically).
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- mullingitover 13y ago> and the reason you don't have the option to switch to another service provider is your state and local governments granting comcast, et al local monopolies. The real reason is the FCC doesn't require the infrastructure businesses to sell wholesale access to competitors. Once upon a time, Comcast et al would've leased you the line, but you would've had choice in your ISP service. A stroke of the pen eliminated all serious competition in the ISP game, and made it so Comcast owns the entertainment pipeline all the way from movie studio lot to your internet connection. Odd that the studios aren't allowed to own movie theaters [1], but they're heading straight for the same end result by controlling your internet access. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Paramount_Pictures,_Inc http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Paramount_Pict....
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 13y agoGranting exclusive cable franchises has been illegal under federal law since the early 1990's.
- wycx 13y agoPlease direct criticism to the proper source: regulatory capture
- exelius 13y agoWhat if there's not another paper because the margins are so low that neither of you would make a profit if you had to compete for customers (and your service was mutually exclusive)? And the government says that you have to drive by every house when delivering papers whether they subscribe or not? Even if telecom/cable were fully deregulated, this is the situation you would face. A cable company may make $1 billion in revenue off of a city, but it probably costs them $900 million to serve the city. If someone else comes in and is able to radically undercut their costs at $600 million while simultaneously winning 50% of the market, both companies would still only make $500 million and lose money. The incumbent cable company probably has enough of a war chest to wait out the challenger's funding. Infrastructure businesses are very expensive. There is no easy solution short of the government seizing the cable infrastructure, which would set such a dangerous precedent that it would probably destroy our economy.
- mullingitover 13y ago> There is no easy solution short of the government seizing the cable infrastructure, which would set such a dangerous precedent that it would probably destroy our economy. Sure, I mean, there's no way that the government could simply recognize the monopoly and regulate it as such.
- exelius 13y agoWhat does that regulation look like to you? It's easy to say "regulation is the solution" but regulation can mean a lot of things. What's the easy regulatory solution?
- mullingitover 13y agoExactly like it did before the cable companies were allowed to kick out all their competition. In 1998, when I leased a DSL line I had a full page listing all the ISP options I had. Now that we're 'deregulated' and have a 'free market,' I have exactly zero choice in broadband ISPs.
- 13y ago
- bane 13y agoThere's plenty of alternatives for internet everywhere in the country. Saying "but they only have 1 broadband provider" isn't the same as having only one internet provider. The home I grew up in still doesn't have any broadband cable provider and can't get DSL. Yet somehow my non-tech savvy parents figured out how to navigate finding, competing and buying a high-speed internet provider after years of dial-up. They've had "always on" 24/7 internet in their house since about 1997-98 if I'm not mistaken.
- PhasmaFelis 13y agoWhat service do they use, exactly? I think most of us would be interested to hear about a high-bandwidth, low-latency option that isn't cable or DSL. The only things I can think of are satellite and cellular, both of which have huge hosts of problems for regular home use.
- bane 13y agoOh your want high bandwidth and low latency? Just like Tesla doesn't have a dealership in my neighborhood, providers aren't available in their area that offers both of those things either. They use to use pairbonded dial-up, then ISDN. Been on Satellite (high-band down, dial-up up then bi-directional) for the last 10 years or so. They've been thinking of switching to a 4g hotspot recently, which is similar bandwidth and half the latency (and similar cost for their uses).
- baddox 13y agoThey always have the option to stop paying for the paper.
- smsm42 13y agoIf you lack the option because local government banned all other papers from the city (and courts approved this since it's "public interest") then it's really not right to lay this at capitalism's doorstep. Capitalism didn't do it, voters that elected politicians who approved it did.