5 ms·
Big kudos for doing this but I feel like they are ripping up a wound that was healing just fine. I mean. Most people already forgot this. The people who want
by ThomPete 13y ago
Big kudos for doing this but I feel like they are ripping up a wound that was healing just fine.
I mean.
Most people already forgot this.
The people who want to make this a bigger issue than it is not going to be convinced.
I think most people didn't think they needed to explain more than they already had.
- Aqueous 13y agoI think this is an example of Wanstrath kow-towing to a small, outspoken subset of GitHub's employees to avoid bad PR. This has happened before. At some point a group of GitHub employees were offended by a rug that said something to the effect of "United Meritocracy of GitHub." This rug strikes me as being not at all divisive - not even subtextually, not even under an extremely charitable reading of the argument. I'm very familiar with knee-jerk reactions of this kind - I went to an extremely politically liberal, East Coast university that reacted to every conceivable slight with a blizzard of sometimes phony outrage, the kind that makes even people who agree with them (such as myself) completely unsympathetic to their argument. Interestingly, the "divisiveness" of this rug was apparently turned into an issue by none other than Julie Ann Horvath. (http://www.businessinsider.com/githubs-ceo-ditches-meritocracy-rug-2014-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/githubs-ceo-ditches-meritocra...) Now I absolutely think that Preston-Werner's wife and Preston-Werner himself acted extremely inappropriataly towards Horvath. But, since it appears that Horvath's other claims do not seem to have a basis, she has yet again taken a situation where she had a legitimate point to make and completely blew it out of proportion. Wanstrath will learn eventually that he sometimes just has to say no more. There are more important goals for his organization to accomplish than to be accommodating to every single grievance.
- gruntmaster9000 13y agoNegative reaction to “meritocracy” is hardly knee-jerk. In fact, the word was coined as criticism of the concept: http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment http://www.theguardian.com/politics/2001/jun/29/comment
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- Aqueous 13y agoThen the rug is a declaration of values. The US has often failed to live up to its own founding values - should we shred the preamble and the declaration of independence? No - those two documents have shaped US history, mostly because we're more and more trying to live up to them. It just seems awfully silly. The legitimate point here - that there should be more female engineers - seems a) not specific to GitHub and b) to be lost under a shroud of phony outrage over a rug.
- gruntmaster9000 13y agoMissing the point. Meritocracy is not something to aspire to. In practice it masks and reinforces power structures, increasing inequality: > The main finding is consistent across the three studies: when an organization is explicitly presented as meritocratic, individuals in managerial positions favor a male employee over an equally qualified female employee by awarding him a larger monetary reward. From: http://asq.sagepub.com/content/55/4/543.short http://asq.sagepub.com/content/55/4/543.short Which was recognized by Chris Wanstrath when they removed it: > @defunkt: We thought ‘meritocracy’ was a neat way to think of open source but now see the problems with it. Words matter. We’re getting a new rug. https://twitter.com/defunkt/status/426104782894284800 https://twitter.com/defunkt/status/426104782894284800
- Aqueous 13y agoThe problem wasn't the meritocracy it was the failing to live up to it. Meritocracy is absolutely something we should aspire to. In these examples the men who were paying other men more were simply not being meritocratic - if they were, then they would have hired/given raises to just as many equally qualified women as they did men. That calling something a meritocracy when it isn't may have a paradoxical effect may be true. But I'm not sure it warrants getting rid of meritocracy as the guiding principle of an organization. We should just be doing a better job of being meritocratic.
- golden_apples 13y ago>> Interestingly, the "divisiveness" of this rug was apparently turned into an issue by none other than Julie Ann Horvath. I get that you're trying to take a cheap shot, but that wasn't the story as I remember reading it. There was bitterness about the "meritocracy" meme from a lot of people in tech who felt that it discounted their marginalized status. JAH ran into that response while trying to do outreach for the Passion Projects series, and relayed it back to the Github leadership, who responded respectfully. There's a more complete retelling of that issue here: http://readwrite.com/2014/01/24/github-meritocracy-rug http://readwrite.com/2014/01/24/github-meritocracy-rug >> Horvath and other women at GitHub began to feel as if they were “bearing the brunt” of the rug’s message as well as “being excluded from other communities as a result.” >> One employee, Horvath says, thought she was rejected for membership in Double Union, a feminist hackerspace, because of the rug. Double Union did parody the rug on its crowdfunding page, but denied that it would reject a possible member because of the rug.
- Aqueous 13y agoI'm not trying to take a cheap shot. The fact that meritocracies are 'messy' doesn't mean you get rid of the central message - which is that people are awarded commensurately with their talent and effort. That seems completely in line with the 'justice is fairness' version of liberal democracy - which is what I thought most progressives were fighting for. And this idea that someone rejected the employee in question because of a rug sounds very implausible.
- b0nz 13y agoIf JAH didn't believe that Github is a meritocracy than she should have quit.
- evanmoran 13y agoI was at a conference this weekend, and let me assure you that most people have not forgotten.
- jacalata 13y agoMost people? What kind of evidence do you have for that? Do you mean 'most people in the world' or 'most people who cared at the start' or 'most people I am friends with' or 'most people that I think are reasonable enough to care about anyway'?
- ThomPete 13y agoDoes it matter? If enough people really care Github is not going to be able to hire people and they are going to loose customers. Do you have any evidence of the opposite? Why so pedantic?
- nuser 13y agoAh yes, another barely literate post from the always bigoted ThomPete.
- jacalata 13y agoI don't have any evidence, that's why I haven't made any claims. I am pedantic because I see no value to broad, baseless speculation posing as facts, and I think calling such statements out is likely to discourage their presence.
- ThomPete 13y agoI clearly stated it as a personal opinion (I think) not a fact so I still don't understand what your grief is. All I can say is that most people I talk with are no longer talking about it and are still using Github, still likes the company so I don't think my view is that far off, but of course it's a personal opinion. If you don't believe that is the case you are free to disagree but I hardly see any reason for the pedantic voice or the downvotes (not saying that's you).