3 ms·
Yeah, I've noticed that with my kid, too. When he learned to sit up and crawl, he would be nearly asleep, presumably in that part of sleep where your brain is w
by jerf 17y ago
Yeah, I've noticed that with my kid, too. When he learned to sit up and crawl, he would be nearly asleep, presumably in that part of sleep where your brain is wandering but you're not quite asleep yet, then suddenly, bam, flip over and get on all fours to crawl, then start standing up on the bed. Once when I let him finish the task, he even visibly woke up, looked at me with some surprise, and then started crying again because he was tired, wanted to sleep, and clearly did not want to be standing up. Probably blamed me for it, too. No intentionality, it's just the "standing program" fired at an inopportune time.
Another funny one (from an AI perspective) dates from when he was about 4 months old; we were sticking our tongues out at him and he was starting to try to copy us, and I swear, you could see his leg jerk, then his left arm, then his neck, until finally he got his tongue out, just like there was a little man in his head pushing buttons until he found the right one.
On the parent's side: We have a dog and two cats, and our child just passed a year old. My wife was just telling me that she's caught herself being surprised a few times over the past few days, as my son does things like "puts the lid back on the container". She said she realized that up to this point she'd been subconsciously applying the "pet" template to our son, since that roughly matched his capabilities for the past few months (non-word vocalizations for needs, limited manipulation skills, understands only a few words, etc.), which she didn't even realize until suddenly he started to do a few things that didn't fit the template, like put a lid back on a container, or spontaneously use a keyring to mime locking the door (to the best of his ability). Kind of an interesting conceptual problem on the adult side.
- andreyf 17y agoShe said she realized that up to this point she'd been subconsciously applying the "pet" template to our son, since that roughly matched his capabilities for the past few months This really surprised me, also. Especially so, because first "human" things my daughter did was to start offering to feed us when we fed her (~7 months). It would seem social reciprocation was her first social instinct - long before speech, feeling of ownership, etc.
- jerf 17y agoMy child is a boy. I already had little sympathy for the idea that we're born a blank slate and that society imposes gender templates, but what little sympathy I had for the idea is now gone. He's not hostile or asocial or anything, but he'd much rather hit his head on something, cry, and crawl right back over to try again in 5 minutes. Note that we know it's not a matter of being dumb, because there are other things like that he learns from. He's just... a boy. I think perhaps boys could fit into the "pet" template a bit longer, since girls are more humanly social, earlier, on average. (He's perfectly within normal parameters for his age and gender; he loves people, plenty of eye contact, etc., but girls are definitely different on average.)
- JabavuAdams 17y agoActually, I think your observations show the opposite: i.e. the strength of socialization. Suppose I didn't know your child's gender. The behaviour you described would not sound particularly male or female to me, given my biases. On the other hand, I infer that for you this appears to be typically "boyish" behaviour, and you use this as evidence of strong in-born gender traits. I.e. my daughter does exactly the same thing, but I didn't consider it "girlish". More "babies are duuuumb." One interesting thing about raising an infant is that everyone seems to project different things on to the child, and to have different interpretations of the same events. For instance, my wife and I focus on the fact that our daughter seems strong and smart. Others keep telling us how pretty she is. If she makes certain facial expressions, friends tell us it means one thing, while various relatives all have their own interpretations, that differ from our own interpretation. I don't think your observations confirm anything except your own biases. In case that sounds harsh, I think this is true of all of us. Note that I'm not making the strong claim that there are no gender differences. I just observe that there's much larger variation between individuals than between genders. Finally, I observe that parents treat girls and boys subtly differently even from before birth, and that this can't help but have an effect on their development.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- Radix 17y agoShe said she realized that up to this point she'd been subconsciously applying the "pet" template to our son, since that roughly matched his capabilities for the past few months Wait, where did guys meet your wives? Where do you meet someone who is aware of their templating of things in casual conversation?