4 ms·
The guy's tone may be somewhat shrill, but that doesn't make his argument bogus. With all due respect to the X developers, it's nearly 2010. It seems reasonab
by idlewords 17y ago
The guy's tone may be somewhat shrill, but that doesn't make his argument bogus.
With all due respect to the X developers, it's nearly 2010. It seems reasonable to demand that resizing a window not crash every open app.
- rbanffy 17y agoHis only argument is "X clients should not crash when the X server crashes". I can't see a real reason, linkbait excepted (very effective linkbait, BTW), for such an inflammatory article. X is light years ahead of Windows in many regards. I do daily work that would be very uncomfortable to perform without being able to forward X requests over ssh. To do that on Windows servers, I would be required to run a tsclient inside another tsclient. The mere idea terrifies me.
- pohl 17y agoThe one thing that makes the argument bogus is its false premise, best illustrated by this sentence: "Let's take a look at operating systems with a modern, advanced, and robust graphics stack: Windows Vista and Windows 7." Isn't there something conspicuously missing from that list? While Windows 7 may be better than its predecessor Vista, which itself was a step forward in graphics architecture, why conclude that X needs to learn from them in particular? I mean: if Thom Holwerda's thesis is "X.org, start your photocopiers," he could find better inspiration.
- apotheon 17y ago"Crash every other app"? Tell us what distribution you're using. I want to avoid it.
- apotheon 17y agoI just noticed a weird typo. s/other/open/
- astine 17y agoI could not agree more. However, I've used Linux and the X stack for a while now, that has never happened to me. I've had applications killed that way, but never a whole X server.