3 ms·
On the bright side, it opens opportunities for off-shore (in relation to the U. S.) Dropbox clone startups. I fully expect MSFT to drag this all of the way to
by mikestew 13y ago
On the bright side, it opens opportunities for off-shore (in relation to the U. S.) Dropbox clone startups.
I fully expect MSFT to drag this all of the way to the Supreme Court. I'm curious to see how it shakes out from there.
- Shish2k 13y agoAlternatively for file syncing, peer to peer? If a company doesn't have your data in the first place, they can't give it up. It does require the user to supply their own always-on internet-connected device, but that's increasingly becoming a thing that people have (for modestly sized files, even a smartphone would do)
- einrealist 13y agoHow do you convince user to store arbitrary data? Usually, when I chose a cloud service, I want data off my computer. And I think, ISPs will not be fond of such a service. They already suffer from existing peer to peer services like Bittorrent.
- mikestew 13y ago> Alternatively for file syncing, peer to peer? I really just don't...want...to...maintain another server, or even P2P setup. However, things like this ruling are piling up to the point that I may have to take another look at what it would take to get my Synology box to use their "Dropbox" functionality (Synology's dynamic IP->static IP mapping service has proven to be flakey at best, though there are other options). Either that, or that bittorrent P2P thingy. Another problem is that Dropbox and the like have really gained traction, so that other apps use them as a synchronization store. So there's the problem of keeping, for instance, all of my 1Password stores in sync. I'm sure there's a solution, but I need to overcome inertia and go look for it.
- tombrossman 13y agoI think moving off-shore is an avoidance tactic, not a solution. I live in Jersey which is an offshore finance centre, and some local companies are already marketing 'offshore data warehousing'. These are smart people but they are absolutely no match for the US government when it comes to securing cloud data here. They cannot possibly be attracting savvy customers. Jersey already hands over banking data to the US and UK and they will have to hand over stored 'cloud' data, too. Best practice is to eliminate third-parties from the trust chain by encrypting locally prior to syncing. This is what I do and I wish it were simpler to set up. I can keep my private key on my machine(s) and mobile devices and securely access my decrypted content, but it's not simple enough yet that I can walk my parents through the steps over the phone. Once this gets easier the cloud providers are just 'dumb pipes' (for lack of a better term) and can be used interchangeably. It seems they are stuck between two difficult positions here - you need to trust them with your unencrypted data, and they and you need to trust the US government not to snoop too much. Neither is likely so we're back to eliminating the companies and the US government from the trust chain.