3 ms·
My thoughts ... Having it in Earth orbit is no great challenge - better to have it further out of the gravity well to be a better staging post, and there's mor
by ColinWright 13y ago
My thoughts ...
Having it in Earth orbit is no great challenge - better to have it further out of the gravity well to be a better staging post, and there's more to be learned from having to go back and forth to it further out.
Look at the Mercury, Gemini, and Apollo missions. Each one was specifically designed to learn something new that was essential for the Moon landing. This seems designed for maximum learning and not just for the individual challenge.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoDoing it at all is so near impossible at current technology levels as to be a pipe dream. To dream of putting further obstacles in our path is pointless. You want to practice remote mining, do it on the moon, or at the bottom of the sea, or in a deep-core mineshaft here on earth. All simpler than going to the asteroid and bringing back gigatons of rock.
- ColinWright 13y ago> We choose to go to the moon in this decade and > do the other things, not because they are easy, > but because they are hard, ... This won't happen in one step anyway, just as going to the Moon used many missions, each learning the next thing(s) necessary.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoHard? Its beyond our current level of civilization. We have projected only milliwatts to any distance beyond the moon. Moving asteroids proposes sending maybe terawatts. That's a lot of zeroes. Then propose autonomous robots to select an asteroid, navigate to it, attach to it, propel it and do course correction - aiming at good ol mother earth but trying to miss by a hair, with the biggest projectile mankind has ever launched. Many other obstacles present themselves, but these two are huge enough.
- keenerd 13y ago> Its beyond our current level of civilization. We have projected only milliwatts to any distance beyond the moon. We have a 2kW nuclear reactor rolling around Mars at the moment. 400 watts in the interstellar neighborhood. 200W currently en route to Pluto. Maybe you think nuclear is cheating? Solar might make more sense for this mission anyway, since it is in the Earth-Venus neighborhood. The Rosetta probe would generate almost 10kW at that distance from the sun.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoCuriosity has a 110 watt capacity. Ok, larger than milliwatts but nowhere near kW. What are those other sources you mention?
- keenerd 13y agoVoyager 1 and New Horizons. You are ignoring heat output. Curiosity's reactor produces 2kW of heat and 125W of electricity. The heat is more important - it is what keeps the rover from dying at night. Heat output is really useful for propulsion - more useful than electric if you need large amounts of thrust. Something like NERVA would help get astronauts to Mars before the radiation dose gets too high. Or if you wanted to give an asteroid the biggest push possible. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NERVA http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NERVA
- Crito 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_generator#Space http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radioisotope_thermoelectric_gen... Those are just RTGs. You can also put a proper fission reactor into space as well. This has been done in the past several times to power active radar surveillance satellites. They've been around since the early 70s, the TOPAZ-II from the early 90s could put out around 10kW. TOPAZ-I[aka TOPAZ] could do 5kW. As you would expect, they put out even more power as heat. Those 5kW-10kW numbers are just what you get in electrical power, through the thermionic converters, which are not particularly efficient. TOPAZ reactors are about half the mass of Voyager I. The upper bound on mass that we've already put into interplanetary space is probably the five S-IVB stages in heliocentric orbit right now, each with a dry mass of about 10,000kg. That's about 10 TOPAZ-II's or 30 TOPAZ's. There was a proposed manned Venus flyby mission using a wet-workshop S-IVB, which would have been much heavier.
- serf 13y agowhen someone at MIT recollected the requirements that NASA kept hidden regarding the computer that MIT was to designe for the apollo program, they said that their team would have dismissed it as technologically impossible at the time (the early 60s), and that it was the contractual obligation that forced them to come up with the ideas and technologies which were required for the flight.[1] I don't disagree with you entirely, it is simpler to emulate an environment. [1] http://history.nasa.gov/computers/Ch2-2.html http://history.nasa.gov/computers/Ch2-2.html
- Zikes 13y agoI'm not sure mining at the bottom of the sea is very analogous to mining an asteroid. One is traveling at breakneck speed, the other is (relatively) stationary. One is at negative pressures, the other at ~15,000 psi. One requires you to burn millions of gallons of fuel to access, the other only requires a brief jaunt out onto the ocean and then hopping off the boat.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoYeah they're different; the sea-floor one is lots easier. Remote control is in seconds not hours; spare parts are 5 miles away not 300,000,000. You can tether seafloor devices. Etc.
- rtkwe 13y agoOne has a gigantic ecological impact from mining activities, the other there's no ecology to speak of to be impacted.