5 ms·
NASA mulls plan to drag asteroid into Moon's orbit
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoWhy go all that way (to the asteroid belt) and back, and stop two doors down? Bring it into earth orbit! Or is that not politically correct? Because the risks are indistinguishable.
- ColinWright 13y agoMy thoughts ... Having it in Earth orbit is no great challenge - better to have it further out of the gravity well to be a better staging post, and there's more to be learned from having to go back and forth to it further out. Look at the Mercury, Gemini, and Apollo missions. Each one was specifically designed to learn something new that was essential for the Moon landing. This seems designed for maximum learning and not just for the individual challenge.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoDoing it at all is so near impossible at current technology levels as to be a pipe dream. To dream of putting further obstacles in our path is pointless. You want to practice remote mining, do it on the moon, or at the bottom of the sea, or in a deep-core mineshaft here on earth. All simpler than going to the asteroid and bringing back gigatons of rock.
- ColinWright 13y ago> We choose to go to the moon in this decade and > do the other things, not because they are easy, > but because they are hard, ... This won't happen in one step anyway, just as going to the Moon used many missions, each learning the next thing(s) necessary.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoHard? Its beyond our current level of civilization. We have projected only milliwatts to any distance beyond the moon. Moving asteroids proposes sending maybe terawatts. That's a lot of zeroes. Then propose autonomous robots to select an asteroid, navigate to it, attach to it, propel it and do course correction - aiming at good ol mother earth but trying to miss by a hair, with the biggest projectile mankind has ever launched. Many other obstacles present themselves, but these two are huge enough.
- keenerd 13y ago> Its beyond our current level of civilization. We have projected only milliwatts to any distance beyond the moon. We have a 2kW nuclear reactor rolling around Mars at the moment. 400 watts in the interstellar neighborhood. 200W currently en route to Pluto. Maybe you think nuclear is cheating? Solar might make more sense for this mission anyway, since it is in the Earth-Venus neighborhood. The Rosetta probe would generate almost 10kW at that distance from the sun.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoCuriosity has a 110 watt capacity. Ok, larger than milliwatts but nowhere near kW. What are those other sources you mention?
- keenerd 13y agoVoyager 1 and New Horizons. You are ignoring heat output. Curiosity's reactor produces 2kW of heat and 125W of electricity. The heat is more important - it is what keeps the rover from dying at night. Heat output is really useful for propulsion - more useful than electric if you need large amounts of thrust. Something like NERVA would help get astronauts to Mars before the radiation dose gets too high. Or if you wanted to give an asteroid the biggest push possible. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NERVA http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NERVA
- Crito 13y ago
- serf 13y agowhen someone at MIT recollected the requirements that NASA kept hidden regarding the computer that MIT was to designe for the apollo program, they said that their team would have dismissed it as technologically impossible at the time (the early 60s), and that it was the contractual obligation that forced them to come up with the ideas and technologies which were required for the flight.[1] I don't disagree with you entirely, it is simpler to emulate an environment. [1] http://history.nasa.gov/computers/Ch2-2.html http://history.nasa.gov/computers/Ch2-2.html
- Zikes 13y agoI'm not sure mining at the bottom of the sea is very analogous to mining an asteroid. One is traveling at breakneck speed, the other is (relatively) stationary. One is at negative pressures, the other at ~15,000 psi. One requires you to burn millions of gallons of fuel to access, the other only requires a brief jaunt out onto the ocean and then hopping off the boat.
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoYeah they're different; the sea-floor one is lots easier. Remote control is in seconds not hours; spare parts are 5 miles away not 300,000,000. You can tether seafloor devices. Etc.
- rtkwe 13y agoOne has a gigantic ecological impact from mining activities, the other there's no ecology to speak of to be impacted.
- rtkwe 13y agoThey're not going all the way out to the asteroid belt, 1999 AO10 orbits between Venus and just beyond Earth's orbit. As for the risks there's significantly less expensive equipment in Lunar orbit and the distance from Earth and Earth orbit would make an abort simpler. http://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/sbdb.cgi?sstr=1999+AO10&orb=1 http://ssd.jpl.nasa.gov/sbdb.cgi?sstr=1999+AO10&orb=1 (Requires Java applet to view)
- jarin 13y agoI think you have a warped sense of what "politically correct" means. Just based on how many times I've seen misuse of the term from friends and people on the internet, I give it 90% odds that you're a Republican. :)
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoYou'd be wrong.
- crapiola 13y agowhy?
- JoeAltmaier 13y agoThe trillions in metals mined from an asteroid for an investment of billions, all while avoiding ecological disruption.
- ColinWright 13y agoIt can be done by robot, it several new abilities, it acts as a staging post for deep space missions, it lets NASA examine an asteroid close up and repeatedly, and it can be mined, again demonstrating abilities needed for deep space missions and for long-term possibilities for resource acquisition and management. Also, why not?
- ddt 13y agoI think the second reason you listed to be much more compelling than the first. It could be argued that the space race was about ensuring that the US had missile superiority over the USSR, but I'd wager a significant number of the aeronautical engineers and astronauts involved were much more interested in going to the moon because it was there.
- BrandonMarc 13y ago... and heck, it gives us a reason to go back to the Moon ... or at least, send more probes, etc, there, which themselves might help give more reason to go back to the Moon.
- kumbasha 13y agoThis is Step A, where Step Z is one of "save the planet from a world-killing asteroid" or "everyone gets a solid gold toilet" (or "a few people get solid gold toilets larger than the existing moon")
- weavie 13y agoThe earth doesn't have an unlimited supply of resources. Asteroids are literally loaded with minerals. At some point we are going to deplete the earth and will have to start looking to the skies to get what we need.
- hornetblack 13y agoThey also worked with the guys at Kerbal Space Program to add an Asteroid retrieval mission to KSP.[1] [1] http://forum.kerbalspaceprogram.com/content/274 http://forum.kerbalspaceprogram.com/content/274
- danielweber 13y agoSuch work could help develop ways to use asteroid material for construction or spaceship fuels, making the captured asteroid a stepping stone for human missions to larger asteroids and eventually to Mars. This has nothing to do with Mars. NASA's current political climate is to say that Mars is their goal and everything is a stepping stone towards it, but this isn't providing any of the key technologies we need for a manned Mars mission (heavy lift, artificial G, Mars landing craft). EDIT: Not that this is without value. But sell it on its own merits. Saying "we need to mine asteroids to go to Mars" is making it harder to go to Mars.
- Zikes 13y agoThey're not saying that we need to mine asteroids to go to Mars, more like the experiences and new technologies involved will add a great deal of value to all future missions, including any potential missions to Mars.
- danielweber 13y agoThe things being done to capture an asteroid into lunar orbit are almost completely unrelated to what is needed for a manned Mars mission.
- Already__Taken 13y agoI would think anything to do with putting more hardware deeper into space will be helping a potential Mars mission. Especially research into mining the rocks / getting humans to do that.
- danielweber 13y agoWe don't need mining of rocks for a human Mars mission. We probably need in-situ resource production of fuel from the Martian atmosphere. Which this mission is not providing. In retrospect it's pretty clear what this is: 1. NASA wants to do an asteroid capture mission (Planetary got so much press, we can too) 2. NASA leadership says their goal is Mars 3. A bunch of post hoc reasons to say that this is moving us towards Mars. If you were designing a Mars mission, you would never put "let's go capture an asteroid and bring it into lunar orbit" into your schedule anywhere.
- k-mcgrady 13y agoFirst off I have to admit I know practically nothing about this but wouldn't there be some very serious risks to doing this (Edit: If it's only 7m across I'm guessing it wouldn burn up in the Earth's atmosphere so probably poses limit risk to us in the form of an impact)? If there are it raises some serious questions about how humanity decides whether or not to allow NASA or any other space agency to go ahead with such a plan.
- okasaki 13y agoThe burn would probably (deliberately) be done in such a way that the asteroid's trajectory would never intersect the earth just in case it failed. Once it's in orbit around the moon it's not going anywhere.
- danielweber 13y agoThings in lunar orbit do degrade and crash into the moon. NASA has put a lot of stuff into lunar orbit over the years and they all eventually crashed. There's essentially no atmosphere, but the Moon is not a perfect sphere and there are mascons that perturb orbits. It's a question of how high it is, too. NB: I didn't know this until I asked /r/space about it several years ago.
- BrandonMarc 13y agoI have to say, towing giant space-rocks around and getting them to follow a planned trajectory also sounds like a damn impressive weapon, if someone wants to use it that way. I'm not saying it's not worth doing; I'm just saying when humans see ___ can be done, enough of them get the idea of weaponizing ___ and we should keep that in mind. Perhaps we should simultaneously consider what defenses could be put in place ... this has the benefit of being useful planetary defense against "natural" earth-impacting rocks, too.
- user080 13y agoPersonally I would like to attain some of the gas giants athmosphere( Hydrogen ).
- danielweber 13y agoITYM Helium-3.
- mturmon 13y agoThis is an old article (January 2013) and is very interesting, but substantially out of date regarding a story that has developed a lot. The concept, as indicated in the article, was developed by a KISS (Keck Institute) study group, which is a fancy way of saying about 30 scientists/technologists who gathered in a room at Caltech to think up some new mission concepts. The concept caught some tailwind -- from the manned side of NASA -- and HQ started talking about it as a possible mission concept that would be a step on the manned roadmap. Such fast uptake of a mission concept is incredibly rare. Then the larger asteroid science community took interest, and was somewhat disgruntled because the concept had not been vetted by the community at large. Controversy ensued throughout 2013 -- partly centered on selection of an asteroid -- here is a good summary: http://news.sciencemag.org/space/2013/07/nasa-warned-go-slow-asteroid-capture-project http://news.sciencemag.org/space/2013/07/nasa-warned-go-slow... The concept is now called the "asteroid initiative" and I think it is also associated with enhancing NEO detection. The web site is here: http://www.nasa.gov/asteroidforum/#.U151pF7fPRo http://www.nasa.gov/asteroidforum/#.U151pF7fPRo