5 ms·
> If he wants to show that r > g has any effect on inequality, he needs to do a LOT more than he's done. I am not sure what you mean by this. 'r' is the rate
by saalweachter 13y ago
> If he wants to show that r > g has any effect on inequality, he needs to do a LOT more than he's done.
I am not sure what you mean by this.
'r' is the rate of return of capital, 'g' is the rate of growth of the economy. If 'r' is greater than 'g', than money continuously invested with a rate of return of 'r' will grow faster than 'g', by definition.
Are you disputing the basic match? Are you disputing that 'r' is ever greater than 'g'? Are you disputing that a diversified portfolio will return at a rate of 'r' when the average rate of return of all capital investments is 'r'?
- yummyfajitas 13y agoI mean exactly what I said - r > g does not have any intrinsic relationship with inequality. All it means is that (capital stock) / (yearly income) will grow. There is no reason why a society with capital/income = 10 years has more or less inequality than one with capital/income=5 years.
- jgalt212 13y agoI definitely think there is. The bigger the difference between r and g with r > g the more wealth gets concentrated in the hands of a few as time increases (as long as there is some variability in income levels at t0). If everyone earns the same exact money, it makes no difference what the return on capital is--everyone's income and wealth will be exactly the same for all t (as long as savings rates are equal). I will attempt to google an answer for you
- riffraff 13y agoit depends on how the r is distributed doesn't it? Suppose there is Alice who owns 1M in bonds and doesn't work while Barbara and Charlie own a 100K house and are blue collars. If the houses price goes up ten times while the bonds pay only 110% than total inequality goes down even if Alice still hasn't worked a day.
- jgalt212 13y agoyes, that's definitely true, but if there's only 1 r and all assets return r, I'd say the bigger r is relative to g, the higher the wealth concentration as t increases. most of this math is above me (differential equations and finite difference methods), but the models are pretty easy to experiment with if you employ Monte Carlo methods. In fact, that would be a nice side project: Piketty web app where the user can mess with various permutations of r and g and their distributions.
- danielweber 13y ago'r' is the rate of return of capital, 'g' is the rate of growth of the economy. If 'r' is greater than 'g', than money continuously invested with a rate of return of 'r' will grow faster than 'g', by definition. Using these definitions of r and g, How can the return on capital exceed the growth of the economy in the long term? If the return on capital is so good, governments should invest their pension funds in the stock market and then sit back and relax while all the free money pours in.