2 ms·
I feel this is the least worrying database around, because of a the simple check on its accuracy and the biometric used. Facial recognition is what we humans a
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
I feel this is the least worrying database around, because of a the simple check on its accuracy and the biometric used.
Facial recognition is what we humans are all about - we have surprisingly strong taboos about covering up this very useful and universal biometric already and any flaws in the algorithm or software are much much easier to challenge than DNA tests (I can stand up to a jury all day and say it was not me, and they will most likely believe a DNA expert. show them a picture of someone who just looked like me and they will all use millions of years of evolution to set me free)
Yes it is worrying that any mass databases are being compiled, and yes we must debate as a civilisation how we are going to mitigate the downsides and promote the upsides, but this is not a disaster. not like PRISM.
- pessimizer 13y agoIf the only thing you're worried about concerning mass surveillance is that it could be inaccurate, I can see why you aren't worried.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoThat's a little disingenuous no? There are many things to be concerned about, but it is worth having a fuller discussion about the problem. I think we are all talking about passive surveillance - My views are that mass passive surveillance has always been with us. We are surveilled by our neighbours and strangers all day everyday. Until recently that was entirely based on the facial biometric recogniser "Human Eyeball v1.0". Generally our neighbours do/did nothing with their metadata collections - maybe some salacious gossip, occassionally criminal behaviour. Privacy has till now been the politeness of our neighbours. However on the Internet everyone is now a neighbour. A Good Thing mostly but it has implications for that metadata store. PRISM shows what a meta-metadata store looks like, and history shows us what will be done with it. It is worth noting that what in civilian circles is called "private" most governments see as "secret". They are going to freak when we really start handling Big Data. Even now I would be surprised if the Chinese / Russian intelligence services have not hoovered up all Facebook and LinkedIn. Those PhD Students from MIT 10 years ago will be doing some interesting work for the government now, and thier connections will map the halls of weapons researchers and government quite well. OpenMapping, satellitte and UAVs, a flood of data will pierce everyone's privacy. Anyway, people now are able to monitor others not physically close to them. Some like NSA are going for total knowledge, others like Tesco or Walmart have a more narrow focus but deeper focus (I am pretty sure the NSA will not know my wife is pregnant before I do. Or that Gen. Alexander is really in for it!) But we have no framework for dealing with this, no laws or even ideas of laws we want. The idea of Big Data will give us such benefits that "stop progress" is not a viable response. But what is? Data cannot be labelled. So ...
- wahsd 13y agoPlease recall the recent announcement that algorithms have surpassed human fidelity in facial recognition. On top of that recall a somewhat overlooked NSA/CIA/DIA project called TRAPWIRE that taps into all surveillance systems to allow facial recognition triggered surveillance. Now take a look at those cameras in the McDonalds drive-through that are perfectly trained on your face and will also capture your license plate as you drive up. There is no legitimate reason that warrants that at McDonalds. It obviously is a factor at all kinds of places like ATMs and store surveillance, but I could easily see how McDonalds would be a great partner to roll out the system; global reach, cultural draw, nourishment (somewhat), driver-vehicle association, etc.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoBut McDonald's knows who I am when I hand over my credit card, the server recognises me as the fat one. Really its not about how and where we will be recorded - the answer is everyhow and everywhere. The problem is what can someone do with that information, and how do I know they are doing it?