2 ms·
Completeness gives you limits, the simplest workable definitions of the derivative and integral, and the differentiability of many important classes of function
by jjoonathan 13y ago
Completeness gives you limits, the simplest workable definitions of the derivative and integral, and the differentiability of many important classes of functions. It gets you 3/4 of the way there. It also doesn't fundamentally require any particularly sophisticated definitions of infinity, even though in a modern curriculum this is usually when infinity is first properly discussed. Yes, we stick the infinity symbol below many a limit, but re-phrase the limit into epsilon-delta language and the infinity disappears along with the associated philosophical difficulty.
The extra 1/4 is where the trouble starts. Proving that, e.g. piecewise continuous functions are integrable, is by far the most philosophically complicated bit of elementary calculus. It's the place where the problem of breaking a uncountably infinite domain into pieces and putting it back together again enters the picture.
Compactness is the modern answer. The historical mechanisms for rigorously solving the problem (that I've seen) look more or less equivalent to proving the compactness (or "almost" compactness) of their domain.
> This seems to be an unusual claim, especially since the real numbers, the traditional domain of calculus, are not compact.
R might be the traditional domain of derivatives, but it's certainly not the traditional domain of integrals. Integrals are an important part of calculus, so I don't see how you can claim that R is the traditional domain of calculus.
- JadeNB 13y ago> Completeness gives you limits, the simplest workable definitions of the derivative and integral, and the differentiability of many important classes of functions. Nit-picking can be continued endlessly, but, as a final salvo, the definitions of limits, derivatives, and integrals don't depend on completeness (which is a good thing in the first case, since the (uniform-space, as opposed to order-theoretic) notion of completeness depends on that of limits). As you say, the existence of certain limits and integrals needs completeness. (I don't know off the top of my head any derivatives that one needs completeness to compute—rather nice consequences of derivatives, like that only constant functions have 0 derivative—but that's probably my ignorance, rather than a genuine lack.)