3 ms·
> It's pretty unthinkable that we still wouldn't have calculus at this point. I'm not so sure. Several ancient Greeks, notably Archimedes, came tantalizingly c
by pdonis 13y ago
> It's pretty unthinkable that we still wouldn't have calculus at this point.
I'm not so sure. Several ancient Greeks, notably Archimedes, came tantalizingly close to the theory of infinitesimals. If that had panned out, we could have had calculus two thousand years sooner. Since we didn't, a few hundred years' more delay in a slightly altered history doesn't seem all that unlikely.
(I agree that the stuff about democracy is unwarranted, though.)
- PeterWhittaker 13y agoNot to mention ideas that bore striking parallels with QM. It's been a while and I cannot recall the book that suggested this to me, so I have no hope of providing a reference, but after Democritus and the atom, there were arguments around the might-bes and maybes of atomic time and space. I love my life and times, I really do, but there are times I wonder what might have been had the theory-and-practice Greeks prevailed over the copy-and-perfect Romans. Of course that whole Dark Ages thing was a bit of a bitch as well, but.... (Bought Infinitesimals just before posting, looking forward to bedtime reading tonight!) (Yes, geek. Why do you ask? :->)
- judk 13y agoAre you thinking perhaps of Scott Aaronson's Quantum Computing since Democritus? Even if not, that's a great book, free online.
- PeterWhittaker 13y agoNo, a much older book that was much more on the history of mathematics. My undergrad was in physics and I recognized a lot of parallels between modern math and QM on the one hand and what the Greeks were doing on the other. Aaronson's book is in my pile. I love his work, but that for popular audiences and the more technical stuff. While we're here: Read Valiant's Evolvability.
- psychometry 13y agoJust because Archimedes used infinitesimals doesn't mean he was anywhere close to inventing them, which would have required constructing the hyperreals and all of the necessary math to do that. His proofs depended on an informal notion of infinitesimals that doesn't resemble the modern definition at all.
- pdonis 13y ago> His proofs depended on an informal notion of infinitesimals that doesn't resemble the modern definition at all. To the extent this is correct, the same goes for Newton's proofs, but he was able to do calculus in a practical sense with them. However, I'm not sure what you say is correct; didn't Archimedes give a rigorous definition of infinite numbers as numbers that are greater than all natural numbers? (I.e., a number I is infinite if I > n for all natural numbers n.) And then didn't he define infinitesimals as numbers x such that x is not zero and 1 / x is infinite?
- psychometry 13y agoArchimedes had that conceptual argument, but the modern definition is based on a lot of math Archimedes didn't have, including model theory and the algebra of ordered fields.
- pdonis 13y agoYes, but do you need the modern definition to do calculus, in a practical sense? I don't think so. The way things actually went, practical computations using calculus, by Newton and others, came a couple of centuries, at least, before the modern rigorous foundations were developed. So if some other development had intervened, in the sort of alternate history postulated in the article, to prevent the practical computations from being taken further, that could have prevented the modern rigorous foundations of calculus from being developed. To put it another way, if other developments had not intervened, the next couple of centuries after Archimedes could possibly have seen something like our modern rigorous foundations for calculus being developed.
- 13y ago