2 ms·
I can't get at the full text without paying $7, which is not quite something I'm willing to do, but I'd question the timeframe of the experiment. Low-carb diete
by jerf 17y ago
I can't get at the full text without paying $7, which is not quite something I'm willing to do, but I'd question the timeframe of the experiment. Low-carb dieters frequently report that the first two or three days of the diet are very rough days due to low-energy, but then they bounce back and feel much better, often reporting that they feel better than before. (Self-reporting caveat here, of course. Note that I have heard real people say this in real life, though, not just diet books making the claim, though of course placebo may be in play.) My point here is not that the self-reports should be "trusted", for some value of "trusted", but that there's already anecdotal experience that indicates that the timeframe matters, which I would consider enough experience that investigation across more than just the "short term" is fully warranted. I read the abstract carefully and all it says for the time-frame is "short-term".
In terms of trying to help me understand my diet choices scientifically, this isn't any help, as it doesn't bring any new information in (and then, if I am correct about the timeframe, over-interprets the results). Short-term effects aren't the same as long-term effects in a self-correcting system like a living body.
If someone else is willing to drop the funds, let me know if they're more specific on the timeframe involved.
- jpschorr 17y agoHere's a great response to the study from one of the icons of the Primal/Paleo/low-carb community: http://www.marksdailyapple.com/high-fat-diets-make-us-stupid-lazy/ http://www.marksdailyapple.com/high-fat-diets-make-us-stupid... Executive summary: This study (or at least the media's response to it) attempts to extrapolate a 9-day study on rats to an overall implication on human diets.
- DTrejo 17y ago>attempts to extrapolate and fails
- chrischen 17y agoI got the full text. Sometimes NYTimes does that when you've viewed too many articles in a day. Just open up in a different browser or different computer. You can do it under the same IP. Clearing your cookies might do it, but i've only tried a different computer.
- jerf 17y agoNot the NYTimes text, the text of the paper. I did read the NYTimes text, as well as the abstract of the paper.