3 ms·
This is why I cringe when I hear people say that the current economic crisis is an indictment of capitalism; a proof that free markets behave irrationally. To
by modeless 17y ago
This is why I cringe when I hear people say that the current economic crisis is an indictment of capitalism; a proof that free markets behave irrationally. To believe that you have to ignore the enormous distortions government has created, not just with recent legislation but with things like the mortgage tax deduction that are so entrenched and popular we take them for granted.
- natrius 17y agoI've never understood the point that people who say that sort of thing are trying to make. Unbridled capitalism (which, as noted, this wasn't an example of) has problems. What are they suggesting we do about it? It seems like the idea must be more than just a small increase in regulation. That's already being done, so the point wouldn't be worth the breath.
- barrkel 17y agoIf the market were so perfect, why wouldn't it cope with distortions perfectly? In other words, why wouldn't it predict the effects of mortgage tax etc., and still come out OK in the end?
- barrkel 17y agoI find it very interesting that when this argument is presented, people don't post a counterargument - they downvote instead?
- cema 17y agoMarket is not perfect, it works well under certain assumptions which are not always accurate after government interventions.
- modeless 17y agoOf course markets aren't perfect. They can cope with distortions like the mortgage tax deduction but the cost is reduced efficiency and resiliency. The mortgage tax deduction didn't trigger the crisis but it amplified the effects by increasing the number and size of mortgages. (BTW, I'd like to clarify that I didn't downvote you and I agree it was uncalled for. I don't yet have the ability to downvote.)