3 ms·
I am in a 5th camp. I like going for interesting discussion. However after having people from group 1 decide that the discussion that I wanted was happening o
by btilly 13y ago
I am in a 5th camp. I like going for interesting discussion.
However after having people from group 1 decide that the discussion that I wanted was happening on off topic questions. There was one particular case where group 1, the moderation nazis, decided that the question was "off topic" and should be deleted. After I complained about it here, people went and voted it back into existence. But I've been pretty close to inactive there since once I'd had that taste of moderation and realized that, as far as the site was concerned, the moderation nazis were mostly correct - the kind of algorithm questions that I found fun were off topic.
See http://stackoverflow.com/questions/11314077/algorithm-for-exclusion-of-numbers/11317787 http://stackoverflow.com/questions/11314077/algorithm-for-ex... for the particular question that lead to my getting frustrated with the site.
- ericb 13y agoI left for the same reason. I wish someone would open a competitor where we could have these discussions.
- LunaSea 13y agoWouldn't Quora be an alternative for subjective / vague questions ?
- Cederfjard 13y agoI think the question mentioned above would fit in at http://cstheory.stackexchange.com http://cstheory.stackexchange.com, wouldn't it?
- btilly 13y agoNo, because cstheory is for academics, and it isn't a research question. Besides, nobody is actually on those sites, so those discussions don't happen there.
- _delirium 13y agoWhat do you mean by "nobody is actually on those sites"? It seems to have quite a bit of activity to me, with some quite detailed replies. It's not hundreds of posts a day, but high-quality posts appear at a rate of a few to a few dozen per day (depending on the day), which is about the right volume for a high S:N ratio community (good mailing lists tend to top out around there as well).
- btilly 13y agoI mean that I went there to try out the officially approved solution, and quickly found that there weren't a lot of interesting questions being asked, or much discussion. Indeed a lot of the questions that were asked were there only because they were moved from the main site, and it wasn't clear to me that the people asking the questions actually saw the answers.
- Cederfjard 13y agoI'm sorry, I should have linked http://cs.stackexchange.com http://cs.stackexchange.com instead. I do see the problem with having to ask questions on the other sites where there are fewer people to answer them, but certainly that's something that can be ameliorated if people are increasingly persuaded to make use of them? I don't think anything new has been said about the scope of Stack Overflow for a long time - everyone agrees on the specifics (by and large), the only real point of contention is whether you like the way things are or not. If you do, great! If you don't - you're probably not going to get the people in charge to change their minds at this point.
- oneeyedpigeon 13y agoThat post was closed, 'incorrectly', then reopened a day later. It has a great answer. What's your complaint - this seems to be an example of the community working almost perfectly. Edit: ok, I see your point, but you don't know that that wouldn't have happened anyway.
- TeMPOraL 13y ago> the kind of algorithm questions that I found fun were off topic But what is on-topic? After seeing pretty much every interesting/useful question I encountered on SO "closed as not constructive", I just can't piece in my head what questions are OK. The only ones that come to my mind that seems to be on-topic are the kind of "I'm too lazy to try and debug things for 5 minutes, so I need to ask on the Internet" kind.