3 ms·
Oh dear. Are we having a religious and political argument? We'll both get banned! 1. When they say "evangelicals" they don't mean 0.8%. They mean "people who s
by gruseom 17y ago
Oh dear. Are we having a religious and political argument? We'll both get banned!
1. When they say "evangelicals" they don't mean 0.8%. They mean "people who self-identify as born-again or evangelical" and it says right on the first page (under "Highlights") that this is 34% of the US. The confusion arises because they use the term in a much more specialized sense in two places. But if you look through all the uses of "evangelical" in the study, as I did, there's no doubt that everywhere else they're referring to the 34% definition.
2. GWB obviously fits in this 34%. Kennedy and Reagan obviously would not. Carter is an interesting hybrid.
3. Yes, atheists are rising as well. But this isn't any "opposite point" to what I "desire". Two things can be rising at the same time. (Indeed, my comment originally mentioned how the US is becoming more religiously polarized, with atheists and evangelicals growing and mainline Protestantism dwindling. But I deleted it for brevity.)
4. There are many examples of evangelicals exercising political power under GWB. Think of all the appointments that were made of people from evangelical law schools (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monica_Goodling http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monica_Goodling). I'm sure they did not exercise as much political power as they would have liked. But GWB went far further in this direction than ever before. That is all.
- DanielBMarkham 17y agoI think we're hidden deep enough it's okay. Let's agree to postpone this discussion for a better time and place. I've got problems with the term "evangelical law school" You do realize that almost every old college on the east coast was originally some sort of Christian institution, right? Which means there had to have been loads of folks trained at religious institutions in the past. I started to do some research on this, but BDS is currently so bad it made the process painful. Better to wait a while.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- wheels 17y agoThere's a bit of a difference between east coast schools being historically Christian institutions that have gradually shifted towards secularism over a few centuries and colleges that were founded in the last 30 years by politically active televangelists.