7 ms·

Pinterest has this one unique ability to make me feel completely unable to predict if a service is going to be of any use and of any value. I just don't get the

by ozh 12y ago

Pinterest has this one unique ability to make me feel completely unable to predict if a service is going to be of any use and of any value. I just don't get the point of that site.

lunaru 12y ago
You can turn this feeling around into something more productive/lucrative: The feeling is a reminder that there are audiences that don't perceive value the same way you do. Specifically, audiences that are not male, geek/technical, software engineers. Their audience is probably mostly female, non-technical, and has lots of desire to spend lots of money. Flipping this around, imagine someone who is not the intended audience stumbling across HN. They'd probably think the Yahoo front page delivers better news signal than this site.
- est 12y ago
  any books on this? I think we fellow geeks need to learn these kind of stuff asap.
  - brc 12y ago
    Yes. Pick up a Vogue. A fat magazine with virtually no content but a lot of pictures. A mixture of advertising and photo shoots. There is a whole, massive demographic out there that just loves this stuff, and isn't technical at all. The existence of vogue shows that there is a demographic who likes to flip through nice pictures. Sometimes they dog-ear the pictures to come back later and look again. People like to leave the magazine lying around their place as a social indicator that they are interested in fashion, and they like to mark which bits of that fashion they're interested in. That's pinterest in a nutshell. Now go to any magazine rack. There are are broad range of these niches. It's not about replicating a magazine, it's about understanding what purpose that magazine exists for. Is it interesting articles? Wanted ads? Industry information? The purpose and niche of the information is what people want. These all can be more innovatively delivered and shared than a glossy magazine dropped on a doorstep.
    - ableal 12y ago
      Even faster and perhaps more instructive is looking up Bethany Mota: "Her YouTube channel has more subscribers than Lady Gaga (4.8 million), she has more Instagram followers than Elle, Vogue, Glamour and Marie Claire combined (2.2 million)." (First read about her yesterday, accidentally. Yeah.)
    - grinich 12y ago
      virtually no content but a lot of pictures this is ridiculous to say. photos are content.
      - brc 12y ago
        Well, exactly. That shows the difference in understanding.
      - psykovsky 12y ago
        Try telling that to the Google Adsense compliance department...
  - kmfrk 12y ago
    It's basically a "lookbook" concept, which is something you flip through for inspiration and to see what the current trends are. If you want a technical parallel, think Dribbble. Pinterest takes this and adds a mix of dynamic wishlists and storefronts to it - with alerts of price drops, and conceivably price and currency calculation for an international audience down the line. I generally hate the term, but Pinterest also acts as a more curated lookbook, since you can choose whom you follow to compose your own magazine-like feed. I don't mean to give the impression that I have any idea about the profitability of Pinterest, because they are hauling a truckload of static content - on Django, to boot.
    - est 12y ago
      How are they hauling static content on Django? Any reference for that? I thought everyone is using sendfile/x-accel and wrap CDN with static contents these days.
    - mtrimpe 12y ago
      You mean a mood-board; which is used to communicate a visual style. A lookbook is usually to give an overview of a single brand's season. It is used extensively in all visual creative industries, like interior decoration, architecture and of course fashion and photography. It's actually often one of the main deliverables early on in projects and thus also an important sales document (i.e. serious money is won or lost on the quality of the mood-board.)
- ozh 12y ago
  I think it gets a bit more complicated than that. I know quite a few nerds who use Pinterest as nerds, using the service as a bookmark-for-later, a whishlist, and more stuff I probably don't get
- mattmanser 12y ago
  Why non-technical? Anecdotally, when I first started seeing pintrest in FB, most of the women that were doing it tended to be the more computer savvy and then it spread.
mailarchis 12y ago
Neither did I. But this answer (Quora) gives some interesting insights. "Because Pinterest is not about sharing. Pinterest is about collecting" Ref - http://www.quora.com/Pinterest/How-did-Pinterest-become-so-successful-when-people-could-already-share-content-on-Facebook http://www.quora.com/Pinterest/How-did-Pinterest-become-so-s...
deleted 12y ago
[deleted]
nl 12y ago
Pinterest is what del.icio.us should have become.
riffraff 12y ago
while I still don't get pinterest, my wife showed me a sensible use for it twice already. When we get married she had already made this big list of stuff we could use for the wedding, by pinning stuff. Clever I thought. Now we're expecting a baby and all of a sudden she turns up this board full of stuff she had bookmarked long before, prems, cradles, textiles, wool, plush toys etc.. She had been pin'ning them for a long time, and can now go back and state "oh, we could get this <weird thing>, look I saved it here.."

by ozh 12y ago

Pinterest has this one unique ability to make me feel completely unable to predict if a service is going to be of any use and of any value. I just don't get the point of that site.

lunaru 12y ago

You can turn this feeling around into something more productive/lucrative: The feeling is a reminder that there are audiences that don't perceive value the same way you do. Specifically, audiences that are not male, geek/technical, software engineers. Their audience is probably mostly female, non-technical, and has lots of desire to spend lots of money. Flipping this around, imagine someone who is not the intended audience stumbling across HN. They'd probably think the Yahoo front page delivers better news signal than this site.

est 12y ago
any books on this? I think we fellow geeks need to learn these kind of stuff asap.
- brc 12y ago
  Yes. Pick up a Vogue. A fat magazine with virtually no content but a lot of pictures. A mixture of advertising and photo shoots. There is a whole, massive demographic out there that just loves this stuff, and isn't technical at all. The existence of vogue shows that there is a demographic who likes to flip through nice pictures. Sometimes they dog-ear the pictures to come back later and look again. People like to leave the magazine lying around their place as a social indicator that they are interested in fashion, and they like to mark which bits of that fashion they're interested in. That's pinterest in a nutshell. Now go to any magazine rack. There are are broad range of these niches. It's not about replicating a magazine, it's about understanding what purpose that magazine exists for. Is it interesting articles? Wanted ads? Industry information? The purpose and niche of the information is what people want. These all can be more innovatively delivered and shared than a glossy magazine dropped on a doorstep.
  - ableal 12y ago
    Even faster and perhaps more instructive is looking up Bethany Mota: "Her YouTube channel has more subscribers than Lady Gaga (4.8 million), she has more Instagram followers than Elle, Vogue, Glamour and Marie Claire combined (2.2 million)." (First read about her yesterday, accidentally. Yeah.)
  - grinich 12y ago
    virtually no content but a lot of pictures this is ridiculous to say. photos are content.
    - brc 12y ago
      Well, exactly. That shows the difference in understanding.
    - psykovsky 12y ago
      Try telling that to the Google Adsense compliance department...
- kmfrk 12y ago
  It's basically a "lookbook" concept, which is something you flip through for inspiration and to see what the current trends are. If you want a technical parallel, think Dribbble. Pinterest takes this and adds a mix of dynamic wishlists and storefronts to it - with alerts of price drops, and conceivably price and currency calculation for an international audience down the line. I generally hate the term, but Pinterest also acts as a more curated lookbook, since you can choose whom you follow to compose your own magazine-like feed. I don't mean to give the impression that I have any idea about the profitability of Pinterest, because they are hauling a truckload of static content - on Django, to boot.
  - est 12y ago
    How are they hauling static content on Django? Any reference for that? I thought everyone is using sendfile/x-accel and wrap CDN with static contents these days.
  - mtrimpe 12y ago
    You mean a mood-board; which is used to communicate a visual style. A lookbook is usually to give an overview of a single brand's season. It is used extensively in all visual creative industries, like interior decoration, architecture and of course fashion and photography. It's actually often one of the main deliverables early on in projects and thus also an important sales document (i.e. serious money is won or lost on the quality of the mood-board.)
ozh 12y ago
I think it gets a bit more complicated than that. I know quite a few nerds who use Pinterest as nerds, using the service as a bookmark-for-later, a whishlist, and more stuff I probably don't get
mattmanser 12y ago
Why non-technical? Anecdotally, when I first started seeing pintrest in FB, most of the women that were doing it tended to be the more computer savvy and then it spread.

mailarchis 12y ago

Neither did I. But this answer (Quora) gives some interesting insights. "Because Pinterest is not about sharing. Pinterest is about collecting" Ref - http://www.quora.com/Pinterest/How-did-Pinterest-become-so-successful-when-people-could-already-share-content-on-Facebook http://www.quora.com/Pinterest/How-did-Pinterest-become-so-s...

deleted 12y ago

[deleted]

nl 12y ago

Pinterest is what del.icio.us should have become.

riffraff 12y ago

while I still don't get pinterest, my wife showed me a sensible use for it twice already. When we get married she had already made this big list of stuff we could use for the wedding, by pinning stuff. Clever I thought. Now we're expecting a baby and all of a sudden she turns up this board full of stuff she had bookmarked long before, prems, cradles, textiles, wool, plush toys etc.. She had been pin'ning them for a long time, and can now go back and state "oh, we could get this <weird thing>, look I saved it here.."